For a start, here's my 1916 Middleweight Rankings.
CHAMPION. Les Darcy
1.Mike Gibbons
2.George Chip
3.Jimmy Clabby
4.Fred Kay
5.Harry Greb
6.Jeff Smith
7.Jack McCarron
8.Jackie Clark
9.Jimmy O'Hagan
10.Eddie Revoire
Some notes. Eddie McGoorty isn't included for being inactive the entire year. Champion Al McCoy isn't included for being one of the worst champions in history.