Chi vs Brodie - who wins and why

Post Reply
stujones
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 27488
Joined: 29 Aug 2003, 15:08

Chi vs Brodie - who wins and why

Post by stujones »

Well its been confirmed now that Michael Brodie and Injin Chi (spelling?) will contest the vacant WBC Featherweight contest. :lol:

I for one am very happy that this fight is taking place, two world class guys both worthy of world title shots on the basis of their last valiant effort, but who comes through.

Both fighters have so many question marks it makes the fight very intriguing.

Chi's question marks are raised due to the fact he's only faught 1 named fighter (a tremendous fighter). I remeber thinking that Chi was just a mandatory with a bulked up record who Morales would eat up. Wrong!

It was a close contest and chi came very close to being one of (maybe the only) person to geniunely put Morales down (I don't count the KD in the 12th in the first fight with Barrera). He was still punching into the 12th and it was one of the best fights of the millenium.

However, Chi's activity has been poor since, and Morales was going through a very rough patch in his career. Remember he was gifted two decisions vs Barrera and Espedas in the fights before his battle with Chi. Espedas is fighter who's not in Brodies class, losing a few fights after to a journeyman and was involved in one of the worse major contests of this millenium against Bone Adams, in which both fighter looked finished. To say that the Morales/Espedas rematch is not anticipated is an understatment.

So did Morales's shaky patch (maybe due to motivation difficulties) flatter Chi a bit?? Quite possibly.

Brodie skill wise is up there amongst the top 5 or 6 in the devision (and this devision is red hot at the moment with 4 good champions). However question marks arise about his ability to absorb punishment in this devision and also with cuts. He's gone down a few times already as a feather and he hasn't stepped up to top ten level in this devision yet. Paul Ingle was a guy who seemed like he could take a punch when up against the Billy Hardy's of this world, however he was KD (and hurt) in all four of his world title fights. Chi could hurt Morales, but hasn't got a great punchers record. So can Chi hurt and KO Mikey?

The cuts is another issue for Brodie, Chi's busy style throwing lots of punches will make it hard for Mikey not to get some damage, he boxed brilliantly against Molina (British performance of the year??) but that was Molina who was limited, Can Chi bust him up.

So what will happen in this fight. I think its possibly the most winnable fight for Brodie for a major belt (even more winnable than Medina), he's got the skills to do it and deserves to win the belt. However, while I think if facially he can hold up he'll win a unaminous decision, something tells me that when on the verge of winning Brodie's face will go with Chi been declared the winner on a technixally somewhere between 8 and 10.

I don't know why but when I see Brilliant Brodie displays I keep thinking back to Billy Schwer (perhaps the WBF/IBO is the best belt he'll hold) both deserved more, but nice guys never seem to win in this business.
bennie
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 15244
Joined: 15 Nov 2002, 09:53

Post by bennie »

Brodie will never have a better chance of winning a big world title. He's at home, he's got plenty of recent rounds under his belt...and he can fight.
I really fancy him to beat the hard-punching Chi.
MC Stompin
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 15
Joined: 09 Jul 2002, 15:22

Post by MC Stompin »

Chi has got the best chance of winning I reckon.

Chi was able to hurt Morales and absorb all his punishment, even if it was a bad day for Morales that's still a feat. Brodie won't be able to hurt Chi and will be on the end of some very hurtful combinations that will keep coming none stop.

Chi has a tremendous work rate and will be able to outwork Brodie. He's also very ruff with his bonce, this will cause Brodie major problems with his dodgy skin. Brodie will be relying totally on his skills and will that be enough? I doubt it.

65/45 in favour of Chi.
The_Wild_Man
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 29
Joined: 14 Mar 2003, 08:44

Post by The_Wild_Man »

MC Stompin wrote:65/45 in favour of Chi
65/45 ?????
That doesnt make sense :D


As for this fight I think Brodie will win because of the home ground advantage. The rounds will be close with Chi throwing a high output of punches but Brodie landing a few decent shots as well. Come the end I think Brodie will probably have done enough to win at least 7 of the 12 rounds.
MC Stompin
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 15
Joined: 09 Jul 2002, 15:22

Post by MC Stompin »

The_Wild_Man v2.0 wrote:
MC Stompin wrote:65/45 in favour of Chi
65/45 ?????
That doesnt make sense :D
Sharp eye's m'man, you should be a detective.
Ulysses
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 453
Joined: 29 Aug 2003, 13:06

Post by Ulysses »

I'm slightly favouring the rough-house Chi, all arms and head, he can give anyone problems. Should be good.
The_Wild_Man
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 29
Joined: 14 Mar 2003, 08:44

Post by The_Wild_Man »

MC Stompin wrote:
The_Wild_Man v2.0 wrote:
MC Stompin wrote:65/45 in favour of Chi
65/45 ?????
That doesnt make sense :D
Sharp eye's m'man, you should be a detective.
I am :D

The thing is though as I said previously, this will be a close fight and as such I think Brodie will win because of his home ground advantage. It wont be controversial just him receiving the benefit of the doubt.
steve689
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 9655
Joined: 20 Jan 2003, 13:50

Post by steve689 »

I hope Brodie can pull it off BUT Chi hits hard, Brodie has a suspect chin, it could all end in tears :cry:
Kilburn
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 6620
Joined: 25 Jul 2002, 07:27

Post by Kilburn »

I got the impression watching Morales v Chi that the champion was trying to have an easy day at the office but was forced into having a tough one. Lucky for him he could match Chi for grit because the Korean clearly has it in abundance.

To me this is judgement night for Brodie, we're all going to be on the edge of our seats I think come the first bell. Michael is not as solid as Morales, doesn't punch as hard and marks up quite badly these days. I have to pick against him here. He was on his bike big time towards the end against Jorrin (a mediocre champion lets face it) back at 122, and Chi has to be considerably stronger than Jorrin.

It goes without saying that I'll be over the moon if Brodie pulls this off, I've been impressed by the lad ever since I first saw him fighting 2-minute rounds on Eurosport. Maybe he can be smart enough and do a Cabrera on Chi, I bloody well hope he can!
Post Reply