Ian 'Mr' McNeilly wrote:
Yes, I've seen stu come on here before and explain that if the judges scored it as the ref wanted them to, there wouldn't have been much in it.
But if the ref had have been fair, the very least Reid would have got is a points win and I actually think he'd have sparked him.
And well said Autobarn with your 'glass half full' approach. I get sick of some of you miserable twats on here. Reid was a bloody good pro and a genuine world champ to boot and all some of you can do is say he was no great shakes.
F*ck off and watch Strictly Come Dancing or whatever is on the other side.
Not sure you can say that categorically Ian regarding what might have happend in the Ottke vs Reid fight? Though I can see why you think that. However, you don't think not having the point deductions and the general attitude of the Ref (stopping Reid's work) would have altered Ottke's approach? I'm of the opinion that Ottke knew that by moaning and holding, the Ref would pull up Reid - so continued to "fight" that way... Had the Ref just told Sven to shut up, then he would have fought different. Surely, a point deduction would have made Reid more determined to KO Ottke - than if things were remained to be going "honky dory" in the early aspect then he surely just would have carried on and not seeked the KO. He just seemed to give up at the end, and that was dissapointing... Just for the record, I had Ottke 1 round up, so the point deduction prevented it from being a draw - The KD that was never scored would have then given Reid the win.
Yes, that was a good display - up there with the Wharton approach. Yes, I am guilty of having a "half empty" approach - but two fighters the IMO have had world titles due to fantastic management rather than awesome ability - yet, years since they done anything decent still get mentioned (albeit loosely these days) in the World class bracket - is Hide and Reid. For me, Reid was the worst of the geniune World Super Middleweight champions from the UK.... Good no doubt, but 1 decent performance in 8 years (a losing one) isn't the kind of form thats worthy of the amount of coverage he gets on these forums.... Only my take mind.
A bit of a difference between the terms "Overated" and "no great shakes" and I think that Rob being consider/ed at least fringe World class for over 10 years is overating him.
He was good, but not great - well managed.