ALI wrote:Mayweather is better than he was 5 years ago, based on what exactly, do you think he's pot-shoting the right hand with more accuracy now or what? You must be mad, at best you could argue he's not deteriorated, but how you could possibly come to the conclusion he's better baffles me???
If he can get through a fight just pot-shotting the right hand and looking that much in control then thats hardly a step backwards is it? My opinion is that over the past few years he's faced better fighters than he did circa 2006 and has not been challenged with the exception of De La Hoya.
Baldomir, De La Hoya, Hatton, Marquez, Mosley and Ortiz is a better line-up than Castillo, Mitchell, Gatti, Bruseles, Corley and N'Dou. While he was stopping the latter fighters on the list, the ease at which he has handled the likes of Marquez and Hatton and Mosley leads me to believe he is in his prime right now.
ALI wrote:Mayweather could have fought Frietas, Tyszu, Margarito, Cotto, Williams, a younger Mosley, Pacquiao, Martinez. Thats a whole bunch of elite names, you'd have to be a real dumbass not to think he's avoided at least a couple of them.
Ok, ignoring the fact that Mayweather has always been a WBC fighter and always preferred going that route to titles:
Freitas - When he was at his peak in '02-'03 Mayweather was the weight class above him. When they were both in the 130lb division Floyd had already mashed the divisions #2 in Diego Corrales so where is the challenge in Freitas?
Tsyzu - Mayweather wasn't at 140lb while Tsyzu was in his busy fighting period. He had almost 2 years off from the beginning of 03 up until he fought Mitchell in November '04 and by the time Floyd had a 140lb title and the fight made sense, Hatton had sent Tsyzu into retirement.
Margarito - wasn't a really big name until he beat Miguel Cotto in '08. Then he got battered by Mosley in his very next fight. Mosley's next fight was Mayweather.
A younger Mosley - When Floyd was near Mosley's weight he was coming off of two straight loses to Winky Wright and then campaigning at 154lbs until he beat Collazo for the Interim WBC 147lb title in '07. The fight didn't happen then because Mayweather had already agredd to De La Hoya at 154 and no one blames him for taking that fight over Mosley. Shane lost his next fight to Cotto and then see Margarito for how that situation plays out.
Pacquiao - The whole boxing world is scratching their heads as to why this hasn't happened yet. However, by saying he is on Floyd's avoid list, you are placing all the blame for the fight not happening at Mayweathers door. We both know thats not the case.
Martinez - The fight hasn't been mentioned that much yet but I would be interested to hear his reaction to a possible match-up if asked. I would hardly count him as being on Floyd's avoid list just yet.
Despite these points, you feel Mayweather never fighting the above people when you thought he should have is all his doing? None of them were avoiding him? There weren't any other factors in the fights not getting made? I may be mad, baffling and a real dumbass but I'm not naive.
ALI wrote:I think Pacquiao should swallow his pride and take the tests, but perhaps he's not for a reason, who knows? I also think Mayweather should fight him even if he's not willing to take the tests. Mayweather never mentioned illegal drugs until Pacquiao flew into his radar, now all of a sudden he wont fight anyone unless they take tests.
Mayweather should stop being a pussy and just fight a guy he suspects of using performance enhancing drugs? So fight a guy on an uneven playing field?
Or Pacquiao should just give in to the demands of one man and have random drug testing when he has never failed a test in his life, is scared of needles and says that giving blood can make his feel a bit tired and sluggish for a few days after. Something he doesn't want to happen if he is randomly tested a few days before the fight.
You surely have to side with one or the other. You've basically just said both of them should cave and give in to the others demands??? I thought the baffling was being left to me??
ALI wrote:Look, when Mayweather and Pacquiao were 16 years of age they were both fighting at 106lbs. Mayweather moved up the weights faster, but then he is slightly taller, Manny's around 5'6 to Mayweather's 5'8. Also, i'm inclined to think Mayweather had a much better diet throughout his life, Manny's struggles have been well documented and during the early part of his career he was still in extreme poverty and struggling to find enough money to buy food. Pacquiao's walkaround weight is correct for a man of his age and height, so the speculation that he's juicing is unfair IMO. It has all come from the fact that in the space of two years he went from featherweight to lightweight to light-welter to welter, dominating elite fighters all the way.
It took Manny 4 years to go from featherweight to lightweight. 2 years from lightweight to welterweight (I know he fought Margarito for the light-middle belt but it was a 150lb catch weight and Manny has never weighed more than 145).
There are a host of other PEDs beside anabolic steroids or pro-hormones that Floyd may want him tested for.
ALI wrote:Mayweather should just fight him and stop being a pussy. Manny should also just swallow his pride, take the tests and get it on. Nobody is ever going to be 100% correct IMO!
Like before, pick one? Both can't happen.