Jamie McDonnell V Kal Yafai

Who'd win?

McDonnell points
46
46%
McDonnel KO
11
11%
Yafai points
15
15%
Yafai KO
27
27%
 
Total votes: 99

Pugilist-specialist
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 1632
Joined: 11 Jul 2008, 04:37

Re: Jamie McDonnell V Kal Yafai

Post by Pugilist-specialist »

BobbyG wrote:
dhb-raging bull wrote:
Crease wrote:At this moment in time, I would strongly favour McDonnell.

Yafai is good now, but he will get better in the future. This is not a fight for 2012 - nor for 2013 for that matter.
:shame:
I agree way too early for yafai to get in with Jamie.. He is a cracking little prospect though I've loved watching him so far but when Jamie ko'ed him in sparring it was an heavy one
Thats sparring, not the real thing. Some fighters need the nerves of the 'fight' to perform and many a top fighter have been beat up in sprring by fighters less than them. Lets not forget that Yafai would have been a lot less mature then and being an amatuer boxer with McDonnell being a pro, yes? By coming here and saying more than once what supposedly happened in a spar shows your class....Or lack off
If the spar was actually 2 years ago than McDonnell would have been the European bantamweight champion for 9 months and Yafai a 21 year old amateur flyweight.
fightacademy
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 229
Joined: 08 Nov 2009, 07:38

Re: Jamie McDonnell V Kal Yafai

Post by fightacademy »

Kal is a great prospect i enjoy watching him develop.... lets see what hes going to be like when hes getting hit back over the distance.. matchroom are doing a great job matching him at the minute i think he is a great looking prospect but that jumping the gun him v Jamie whos a proven fighter

kal v hall would be a step to far at the mo IMO

like i say lets see what hes like when hes got someone with youth who will be hiiting him back over the distance doing 12 rounds is a job in its self never mind when someone at the same level is hitting you back
tear up
Cruiserweight
Posts: 1832
Joined: 06 Dec 2010, 12:25

Re: Jamie McDonnell V Kal Yafai

Post by tear up »

Think people r forgetting Martin wards the English champ lets see him get past him first
leforge
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 7790
Joined: 04 Mar 2005, 12:44

Re: Jamie McDonnell V Kal Yafai

Post by leforge »

Anyone know what the plan for Jamie?
fightacademy
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 229
Joined: 08 Nov 2009, 07:38

Re: Jamie McDonnell V Kal Yafai

Post by fightacademy »

leforge wrote:Anyone know what the plan for Jamie?
We are currently in training for a IBF world title fight no date set but we have been told mid feb is penciled in :TU:
leforge
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 7790
Joined: 04 Mar 2005, 12:44

Re: Jamie McDonnell V Kal Yafai

Post by leforge »

fightacademy wrote:
leforge wrote:Anyone know what the plan for Jamie?
We are currently in training for a IBF world title fight no date set but we have been told mid feb is penciled in :TU:
Who will be putting that show on?
bripez
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 4877
Joined: 11 Feb 2010, 18:07

Re: Jamie McDonnell V Kal Yafai

Post by bripez »

fightacademy wrote:
leforge wrote:Anyone know what the plan for Jamie?
We are currently in training for a IBF world title fight no date set but we have been told mid feb is penciled in :TU:
That is what he needs.

If he doesn't get a shot in the next 6 months then he will end up taking another fight to mark time and before you know it he will end up in a situation like Rendall Munroe or Jamie Moore.
leforge
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 7790
Joined: 04 Mar 2005, 12:44

Re: Jamie McDonnell V Kal Yafai

Post by leforge »

bripez wrote:
fightacademy wrote:
leforge wrote:Anyone know what the plan for Jamie?
We are currently in training for a IBF world title fight no date set but we have been told mid feb is penciled in :TU:
That is what he needs.

If he doesn't get a shot in the next 6 months then he will end up taking another fight to mark time and before you know it he will end up in a situation like Rendall Munroe or Jamie Moore.
What did those fighters have in common?
los2
Cruiserweight
Posts: 454
Joined: 30 May 2011, 04:38

Re: Jamie McDonnell V Kal Yafai

Post by los2 »

dhb-raging bull wrote:Too early to be comparing the two I know that Jamie put yafai to sleep in sparring a couple of years back too
when mcdonnell was that age he was losing to haskins and lee edwards
IRLangmaid25
Cruiserweight
Posts: 3316
Joined: 01 Feb 2010, 19:08

Re: Jamie McDonnell V Kal Yafai

Post by IRLangmaid25 »

I agree it is too much of a jump ahead for a guy that has only 6 professional fights so far and it is practially chucking him in head first against a guy that is a former British, Commonwealth and European Champion who is meant to be on the verge of a IBF title shot.
Post Reply