BoxRec

Lenny wrote:

rhino222 wrote:i can only think that the top few in the british p4p's are those that are either the best in the world or those that can be/have been beaten by the very best in the world.

therefore... froch, brook, haye, fury, afolabi, macklin, murray, magee....should all be in the top 10. burns is yet to be tested at top top level, khan has been beaten by persons that are not the worlds best, cleverley and groves are in the same boat as burns!

so my top 8 would be:

Froch
Haye
Brook
Macklin
Murray
Afolabi
Magee
Fury

Burns has not been tested at top level? Ridiculous thing to say.
Martinez, Moses, Katsides, Mitchell, Arthur?

Especially when you think that Brook has been for the Jones win. Or that Murray has been for the Strum loss.
And I've just noticed Fury? Who was his top level opponent, fat out of shape Del Boy or fearless Kevin Johnson?

And the logic is massively flawed anyway. We get British p4p lists from one poster and one poster only. Unless you can match his dedication then please do not attempt to compete, you will lose

rhino222 wrote:

Lenny wrote:

rhino222 wrote:i can only think that the top few in the british p4p's are those that are either the best in the world or those that can be/have been beaten by the very best in the world.

therefore... froch, brook, haye, fury, afolabi, macklin, murray, magee....should all be in the top 10. burns is yet to be tested at top top level, khan has been beaten by persons that are not the worlds best, cleverley and groves are in the same boat as burns!

so my top 8 would be:

Froch
Haye
Brook
Macklin
Murray
Afolabi
Magee
Fury

Burns has not been tested at top level? Ridiculous thing to say.
Martinez, Moses, Katsides, Mitchell, Arthur?

Especially when you think that Brook has been for the Jones win. Or that Murray has been for the Strum loss.
And I've just noticed Fury? Who was his top level opponent, fat out of shape Del Boy or fearless Kevin Johnson?

And the logic is massively flawed anyway. We get British p4p lists from one poster and one poster only. Unless you can match his dedication then please do not attempt to compete, you will lose

my opinion is allowed on here. Are Johnson and Chisora not world last gatekeepers?

Katsidis and mitchell are not bordering on the worlds best. mitchell was iced by katsides who is way past his best, so how are you touting mitchell as top world class opponent? you have contradicted yourself.

Brook had life or death with jones, but won. next step is the big one.

Its all subjective and a matter of opinion, like it or not.