Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Kalan
Super Middleweight
Posts: 10083
Joined: 23 Sep 2012, 23:22

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by Kalan »

gilgamesh wrote: 25 Apr 2018, 11:35 So even though you acknowledge that Ezzard Charles was great in his prime you still hold it against him that he lost fights when past it?
No I don't hold it against him really....each person is free to do as he pleases... You've done fool things and so have I.

But why a fellow who was the best boxer in the world at his best - why does he continues fighting when he can no longer swing well or ward off damaging blows? .... You're getting paid a fortune at your peak and coming through fights without a scratch.... Now you're getting punched around and battered and your paycheck is reduced by 95%. :witzend:

If they didn't save a dime maybe....but some boxers have never heard of a job... Joey Maxim didn't save any money, but he drove a taxi cab for 30 years... You tell some guys who are getting beaten up "It's 9 to 5 buddy... You should try it."
gilgamesh
Cruiserweight
Posts: 46556
Joined: 02 Sep 2010, 16:21

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by gilgamesh »

I doubt too many fighters fight on into their Twilight years just for the fun of it. I would imagine most of them need the money, and still can get more money thanks to their name value in Boxing than they could doing anything else.

Now obviously this isn't good for their long term health, but I'm sure it's easier in theory to just hang 'em up and walk away when you're not the guy who's seeing the offers coming in for more money than you could make doing anything else.
Kalan
Super Middleweight
Posts: 10083
Joined: 23 Sep 2012, 23:22

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by Kalan »

Certainly.... That is what life is about....making decisions... Doing the wise thing is often very difficult.
BoxBuzz
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 29847
Joined: 07 Jun 2005, 16:37

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by BoxBuzz »

The only thing I hold more dearly to my heart than my own personal health...is my own personal freedom.

So....hats off to any and all folks who continue to do as their hearts/minds tell them to do....based on the information that is in front of them, base on THEIR OWN judgment.....regardless of the judgment of others.....as long as it is personally fulfilling....whether successful or not.

Oh...and of course as long as it is not imposing on others. And I don't mean sentimentally....like...."lets make a law restricting that boxers freedom, because he was just so good, and I wish to restrict his freedom "FOR HIS OWN GOOD".

The only person who know WTF their "own good" is.....is the person themselves. Not the government, not your mommy, not your bestest buddy.

Once again....as long as it's not imposing on others. And yes....regardless of the degree of risk that make OTHERS sad weepy or nervous.
Kalan
Super Middleweight
Posts: 10083
Joined: 23 Sep 2012, 23:22

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by Kalan »

I disagree....

It's in society's best interest that citizens remain healthy and don't become burdens on the state... THEREFORE, if a man FAILS a neurological examination such as Muhammad Ali did at the Mayo Clinic - the test should NOT be finessed in the same manner a expert technician will finesse a smog test for a dubious car - which is also immoral, but not a big deal.

"Now Doctor Howard... You guys understand that Ali needs to pass his neurological exam to fight Holmes? ... This is a 10 million dollar fight for Ali.. This fight is going to pull more than 50 million in revenue worldwide... This absolutely HAS to happen... The sissy assed NSAC demanded this fool neurological examination - but I know you're going to get it done for us... I think you know how appreciative I'll be if this exam doesn't hold up the fight for any stupid reason."

"Don't worry Don...I understand your concern.. We're on the same team buddy."
BoxBuzz
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 29847
Joined: 07 Jun 2005, 16:37

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by BoxBuzz »

Kalan wrote: 26 Apr 2018, 04:24 I disagree....

It's in society's best interest that citizens remain healthy and don't become burdens on the state... THEREFORE, if a man FAILS a neurological examination such as Muhammad Ali did at the Mayo Clinic - the test should NOT be finessed in the same manner a expert technician will finesse a smog test for a dubious car - which is also immoral, but not a big deal.

"Now Doctor Howard... You guys understand that Ali needs to pass his neurological exam to fight Holmes? ... This is a 10 million dollar fight for Ali.. This fight is going to pull more than 50 million in revenue worldwide... This absolutely HAS to happen... The sissy assed NSAC demanded this fool neurological examination - but I know you're going to get it done for us... I think you know how appreciative I'll be if this exam doesn't hold up the fight for any stupid reason."

"Don't worry Don...I understand your concern.. We're on the same team buddy."


Yes yes yes, your nothing if not disagreeable.

However in the spirit of your own statement, I have asked the government to step in on your behalf, and subsidize your contributions to this forum. Because you clearly can't do a good job on your own, and they know best what opinions you ought to be having.

So check with them and have your opinions vetted by the "higher authority".


....as I think about it, not even the govt could goof that mission up.
elmersalsa
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 15708
Joined: 02 Feb 2003, 03:50

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by elmersalsa »

1. Roberto Duran
2. Muhammad Ali
3. Sugar Ray Leonard
4. Eusebio Pedroza
5. Julio Cesar Chavez

Other favorites of mine:
Vicente Saldivar
Kid Gavilan
Henry Armstrong
James Toney
Bobby Chacon
Manny Pacquiao
Kalan
Super Middleweight
Posts: 10083
Joined: 23 Sep 2012, 23:22

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by Kalan »

BoxBuzz wrote: 27 Apr 2018, 21:45
Kalan wrote: 26 Apr 2018, 04:24 I disagree....

It's in society's best interest that citizens remain healthy and don't become burdens on the state... THEREFORE, if a man FAILS a neurological examination such as Muhammad Ali did at the Mayo Clinic - the test should NOT be finessed in the same manner an expert technician will finesse a smog test for a dubious car - which is also immoral, but not a big deal.

"Now Doctor Howard... You guys understand that Ali needs to pass his neurological exam to fight Holmes? ... This is a 10 million dollar fight for Ali... This fight is going to pull more than 50 million in revenue worldwide... This absolutely HAS to happen... The sissy assed NSAC demanded this fool neurological examination - but I know you're going to get it done for us... I think you know how appreciative I'll be if this exam doesn't hold up the fight for any stupid reason."

"Don't worry Don...I understand your concern... We're on the same team buddy."


Yes yes yes, your nothing if not disagreeable.

However in the spirit of your own statement, I have asked the government to step in on your behalf, and subsidize your contributions to this forum. Because you clearly can't do a good job on your own, and they know best what opinions you ought to be having.

So check with them and have your opinions vetted by the "higher authority".


....as I think about it, not even the govt could goof that mission up.
You’re not agreeable… You’re a non-thinker... You immediately think the government screws everything up.

I'm the most agreeable person on the face of the earth when in the company of intelligent, clear headed, temperate, educated adults who have good knowledge and experience relating to the subject matter.

You’re telling me that neurologists and medical scientists should have NO say in whether somebody’s MRI and neurological examinations show whether it’s inappropriate or not for a boxer to obtain or keep a boxing license. Basically you’re a Libertarian who thinks the government should have no conscience. Fine, but so few people think as you do (a good thing) that you’ll never win at the polls.

Ali's life might have been a lot better if he were denied a license when it was inappropriate to give him one.
BoxBuzz
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 29847
Joined: 07 Jun 2005, 16:37

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by BoxBuzz »

Yes yes, just as yours would improve if we could just get you to stop being so shy and understated. Govt Program? You tell me. Also....when the govt is in full control of things like...let's say the schools.... everyone will get just the right amount of exposure to all the facts about just how great and thoughtful and heartfelt the govt is. (Because unlike businesses the government is made of just the "best of the best" of humanity. Never a thought for itself, or "it's own".

And as a result of it's purity and sweetness we will all be a little more open minded toward understanding and accepting it's unselfish, and wise goals. And Kool Aid will be distributed to all. I think Merle Haggard said it well..... We'll all be drinking that free bubble up, and eatin' that Rainbow stew!


and just so's I stay on topic.

Archie Moore For his endurance
Muhammad Ali For his indomitable psyche
Roberto Duran For his journey up and down the fame/honor scale
Carlos Monzon For all the wrong reasons
Kostya Tzyu Because he reminded me of Joe Louis in terms of being an honorable warrior
Kalan
Super Middleweight
Posts: 10083
Joined: 23 Sep 2012, 23:22

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by Kalan »

BoxBuzz wrote: 01 May 2018, 12:54 Govt Program? You tell me. Also....when the govt is in full control of things like...let's say the schools.... everyone will get just the right amount of exposure to all the facts about just how great and thoughtful and heartfelt the govt is. (Because unlike businesses the government is made of just the "best of the best" of humanity. Never a thought for itself, or "it's own".

And as a result of it's purity and sweetness we will all be a little more open minded toward understanding and accepting it's unselfish, and wise goals. And Kool Aid will be distributed to all.
I love how you never address what I say. Instead you put on your Libertarian anti-government hat... Nobody wants the government to be in full control of our lives. We don't want to live in a Totalitarian State -- but the next time you fasten your seat belt, the government was responsible for that... When you friend's life was saved by a deployed airbag the government had a hand in that... From the food you eat, to the water you drink, to the air you breathe...it's a little healthier because of government rules and regulations... Buildings are built to code so they don't collapse on people.

Here's a straight forward question for you to evade... If a boxer take a neurological examination that demonstrates he's suffered significant brain damage... does ANY regulating body have the right to deny him a boxing license? Boxers who suffer devastation have become wards of the state and receive disability... In the interest of taxpayers, a responsibility of the government is to help keep citizens mentally, physically, and emotionally healthy.

Most people feel that way... Do you?
MrGuy
Lightweight
Posts: 294
Joined: 03 Jan 2018, 04:11

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by MrGuy »

Kalan wrote: 20 Apr 2018, 15:08
BoxBuzz wrote: 20 Apr 2018, 12:47 Muhammad Ali For his indomitable psyche
He didn't budge Larry Holmes with his indomitable brain games...

Larry was subdued before the Ali fight - like a man who wasn't happy with himself.. He said... "I'm doing this for Ali more than for myself... I should have gotten an Ali Title shot instead of Leon Spinks... For all of Ali's talking? .... His talking sells the fight and that's what he's good at.. He can do all the talking he wants, but his ass is grass and I'm the lawnmower."

In the ring, just before the fight, Ali walked up to Holmes and showered him with non-stop verbal abuse - calling Larry every name in the book... Holmes got tired of it and gave Ali a mighty shove....letting Ali know "You're not selling any more tickets lad.. Just get your ass out of my face and get ready to box."

Ali didn't quite reach the heights of Klitschko-Joshua with his fistic presentation...

At 38, Ali was 3 years younger than Wlad was for AJ...

As for your other choices... good selections.
You do realize some reach their prime quicker.....right? Maybe Wlad looked that great because his comp was questionable.
Kalan
Super Middleweight
Posts: 10083
Joined: 23 Sep 2012, 23:22

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by Kalan »

MrGuy wrote: 02 May 2018, 03:53
Kalan wrote: 20 Apr 2018, 15:08
BoxBuzz wrote: 20 Apr 2018, 12:47 Muhammad Ali For his indomitable psyche
He didn't budge Larry Holmes with his indomitable brain games...

Larry was subdued before the Ali fight - like a man who wasn't happy with himself.. He said... "I'm doing this for Ali more than for myself... I should have gotten an Ali Title shot instead of Leon Spinks... For all of Ali's talking? .... His talking sells the fight and that's what he's good at.. He can do all the talking he wants, but his ass is grass and I'm the lawnmower."

In the ring, just before the fight, Ali walked up to Holmes and showered him with non-stop verbal abuse - calling Larry every name in the book... Holmes got tired of it and gave Ali a mighty shove....letting Ali know "You're not selling any more tickets lad.. Just get your ass out of my face and get ready to box."

Ali didn't quite reach the heights of Klitschko-Joshua with his fistic presentation...

At 38, Ali was 3 years younger than Wlad was for AJ...

As for your other choices... good selections.
You do realize some reach their prime quicker.....right? Maybe Wlad looked that great because his comp was questionable.
Maybe Ali's comp was questionable... Neon Leon... Evangelista... Coopman... Dunn... London... Mildenbooger.... Wepner... Lubbers... Blinn... Blubber Mathis etc.

And right... Ali reached his prime when he was 22 and slipped past it at 28 according to his most maniacal fans... Holmes reached his prime at 26 and slipped past it at 35 with the Truth Williams and Michael Spinks Fights.... Wladimir reached his prime at 30 and slipped past it at 39 for his Jennings fight... He was still looking great when he blasted undefeated Kubrat Pulev out in 5 rounds, with savage left hooks at 38.
MrGuy
Lightweight
Posts: 294
Joined: 03 Jan 2018, 04:11

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by MrGuy »

Kalan wrote: 02 May 2018, 15:43
MrGuy wrote: 02 May 2018, 03:53
Kalan wrote: 20 Apr 2018, 15:08

He didn't budge Larry Holmes with his indomitable brain games...

Larry was subdued before the Ali fight - like a man who wasn't happy with himself.. He said... "I'm doing this for Ali more than for myself... I should have gotten an Ali Title shot instead of Leon Spinks... For all of Ali's talking? .... His talking sells the fight and that's what he's good at.. He can do all the talking he wants, but his ass is grass and I'm the lawnmower."

In the ring, just before the fight, Ali walked up to Holmes and showered him with non-stop verbal abuse - calling Larry every name in the book... Holmes got tired of it and gave Ali a mighty shove....letting Ali know "You're not selling any more tickets lad.. Just get your ass out of my face and get ready to box."

Ali didn't quite reach the heights of Klitschko-Joshua with his fistic presentation...

At 38, Ali was 3 years younger than Wlad was for AJ...

As for your other choices... good selections.
You do realize some reach their prime quicker.....right? Maybe Wlad looked that great because his comp was questionable.
Maybe Ali's comp was questionable... Neon Leon... Evangelista... Coopman... Dunn... London... Mildenbooger.... Wepner... Lubbers... Blinn... Blubber Mathis etc.

And right... Ali reached his prime when he was 22 and slipped past it at 28 according to his most maniacal fans... Holmes reached his prime at 26 and slipped past it at 35 with the Truth Williams and Michael Spinks Fights.... Wladimir reached his prime at 30 and slipped past it at 39 for his Jennings fight... He was still looking great when he blasted undefeated Kubrat Pulev out in 5 rounds, with savage left hooks at 38.
Frazier, Foreman, Norton, and Lyle. Think on it. Wlads prime......covered it. Pulev is a crude amateur.
Kalan
Super Middleweight
Posts: 10083
Joined: 23 Sep 2012, 23:22

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by Kalan »

MrGuy wrote: 02 May 2018, 17:58
Kalan wrote: 02 May 2018, 15:43
MrGuy wrote: 02 May 2018, 03:53
You do realize some reach their prime quicker.....right? Maybe Wlad looked that great because his comp was questionable.
Maybe Ali's comp was questionable... Neon Leon... Evangelista... Coopman... Dunn... London... Mildenbooger.... Wepner... Lubbers... Blinn... Blubber Mathis etc.

And right... Ali reached his prime when he was 22 and slipped past it at 28 according to his most maniacal fans... Holmes reached his prime at 26 and slipped past it at 35 with the Truth Williams and Michael Spinks Fights.... Wladimir reached his prime at 30 and slipped past it at 39 for his Jennings fight... He was still looking great when he blasted undefeated Kubrat Pulev out in 5 rounds, with savage left hooks at 38.
Frazier, Foreman, Norton, and Lyle. Think on it. Wlads prime......covered it. Pulev is a crude amateur.
Pulev won world amateur tournaments beating the top Cubans... He wasn't as crude or hittable as Frazier, Foreman, Norton, and Lyle who were all wide open.... Frazier never fought Norton or Lyle... They'd be way too big and strong for him.
MrGuy
Lightweight
Posts: 294
Joined: 03 Jan 2018, 04:11

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by MrGuy »

Kalan wrote: 03 May 2018, 02:41
MrGuy wrote: 02 May 2018, 17:58
Kalan wrote: 02 May 2018, 15:43

Maybe Ali's comp was questionable... Neon Leon... Evangelista... Coopman... Dunn... London... Mildenbooger.... Wepner... Lubbers... Blinn... Blubber Mathis etc.

And right... Ali reached his prime when he was 22 and slipped past it at 28 according to his most maniacal fans... Holmes reached his prime at 26 and slipped past it at 35 with the Truth Williams and Michael Spinks Fights.... Wladimir reached his prime at 30 and slipped past it at 39 for his Jennings fight... He was still looking great when he blasted undefeated Kubrat Pulev out in 5 rounds, with savage left hooks at 38.
Frazier, Foreman, Norton, and Lyle. Think on it. Wlads prime......covered it. Pulev is a crude amateur.
Pulev won world amateur tournaments beating the top Cubans... He wasn't as crude or hittable as Frazier, Foreman, Norton, and Lyle who were all wide open.... Frazier never fought Norton or Lyle... They'd be way too big and strong for him.
I don't care what he won, the guy looks crude. You have no idea how he wouldve done because those guys weren't in Foremans zip code.
Kalan
Super Middleweight
Posts: 10083
Joined: 23 Sep 2012, 23:22

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by Kalan »

But they'd be punching his face all the way... If you want to see crude watch Foreman-Lyle.... Slophouse city all the way.
paddy chavez
Super Lightweight
Posts: 2678
Joined: 13 Jun 2017, 08:08

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by paddy chavez »

mine do change a bit

1 ...tommy hearns
2..marvin hagler
3 roberto duran
4 julio cesar chavez
5 mike tyson/ evander holyfield ....this is tough one because both were brilliant at their peaks then had dramatic falls i loved the evander that fought dokes i lost a bit of respect when he boxed foreman and holmes a bit of cherry picking there and a young tyson was just so exciting
paddy chavez
Super Lightweight
Posts: 2678
Joined: 13 Jun 2017, 08:08

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by paddy chavez »

mine do change a bit

1 ...tommy hearns
2..marvin hagler
3 roberto duran
4 julio cesar chavez
5 mike tyson/ evander holyfield ....this is tough one because both were brilliant at their peaks then had dramatic falls i loved the evander that fought dokes i lost a bit of respect when he boxed foreman and holmes a bit of cherry picking there and a young tyson was just so exciting
keithmoonhangover
Cruiserweight
Posts: 16894
Joined: 16 Sep 2010, 10:42

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by keithmoonhangover »

1. The Michigan Assassin
2, The Easton Assassin
3. The Hitman
4. The Manassa Mauler
5. The Galveston Giant
NateJR
Light Heavyweight
Posts: 1181
Joined: 03 Jul 2012, 19:58

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by NateJR »

Felix Trinidad
Floyd Mayweather Jr.
Lennox Lewis
Juan Manuel Marquez
Carl Froch

Honerable mentions:

Naseem Hamed
Acelino Freitas
Emmanuel Augustus
Miguel Cotto
Charlie Burley(only based on reading about him)
yiddle
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 117
Joined: 24 Apr 2009, 14:45

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by yiddle »

I'd have to post 2 lists but it's hard keep to 5

Pre 60's

Jack kid berg
Barney Ross
Kid Gavilán
Jack Dempsey
Ted kid Lewis

Post 50's
Marvin hagler
Roberto Duran
Nigel benn
Joe Frazier
Alexis arguello


Second list could partly change daily :OhYes:
chrisjs1985
Lightweight
Posts: 783
Joined: 11 Jan 2018, 12:45

Re: Top 5 Favorite Fighters of All Time

Post by chrisjs1985 »

Juan Manuel Marquez
Felix Trinidad
Eder Jofre
Salvador Sanchez
Marvin Hagler

Just going off retired guys. I am a huge fan of Lomachenko and Crawford too.
Post Reply