BoxRec

WildWaylon wrote:

STRATHMAN wrote:Does anyone else think that this title should be subjected to a bit of Ant and Dec/GM TV etc scrutiny?

Beth Twaddle finished third last year ahead of Hatton and Calzaghe etc.
I am a sports fanatic and I had barely heard of her.

I would like to see the votes published afterwards.

For this year how can Hamilton win when his team cheated and he got immunity for testifying!

What a load of twoddle, Ive never heard of her.

Well, you can't be THAT much of a sports fanatic. It's Beth Tweddle and she won an individual gold at the World Championships (gymnastics) which is as rare as rocking horse shite. I wouldn't have objected if she or Nicole Cooke (cyclist) had won.

Then again, you've got the 'personality' element of the award to think about - which is bollocks if you ask me.

I've really lost a lot of respect for the BBC re this award. Phillips was showcased early and seemed to have longer than the other candidates meaning casual voters had more opportunity to ring in.

The Blade wrote: Can anyone tell me what Dennis Hobson did so wrong that he was shat on from a great height

Hobson didnt have the connections or experience to run promotions in the States, he would have just been an expensive advisor from what I can tell about the situation.

It's a popularity contest along the lines of reality t.v. talent shows whereby the most deserving may win but there's no guarantees.

Makes me wonder at last years winner. Perhaps there are more royalists in this country than I thought, but there again we are a pretty apathetic nation so who kows. In actual fact who cares. OOPS I'll be sure to cast a vote this year (if I can be bothered).

Frankie Gavin would get the sports personality award this year if it was judged purely on achievement

dr_devious wrote:Frankie Gavin would get the sports personality award this year if it was judged purely on achievement

right - or calsaghe. I mean the truth is amateur boxing is pro boxing's junior cousin.

Joe on Radio 5 live right now talking about the award...

calzaghe wins this dubious award

harrygreb wrote:calzaghe wins this dubious award

Yes but if Ricky beats Mayweather, in the uS....

E wrote:

dr_devious wrote:Frankie Gavin would get the sports personality award this year if it was judged purely on achievement

right - or calsaghe. I mean the truth is amateur boxing is pro boxing's junior cousin.

Frankie Gavin's achievement was unique, in that no Briton had ever won gold in the world amateurs before

It's a load of toss, and the show goes out before Ricky fights doesn't it?

Hamilton will be first or second, the fornicating England rugby team will get loads of plaudits for scraping and kicking their way to the final and shit like Michael Owen and Peter Crouch will be interviewed about their failures.

Real winners like JC, James Toseland and the more obscure sportsmen and women will not get a look in - snooker, squash, swimming etc etc

I mean, who the fornicate would have voted for Zara Phillips? Her nan must have run up a massive fornicating phone bill while sat on the throne, the old pudendum.

E wrote:

harrygreb wrote:calzaghe wins this dubious award

Yes but if Ricky beats Mayweather, in the uS....

A very big if

Without sounding like a xenophobic twat, if he was English, Joe would win it.

Anyone agree? Honestly....

Captain Hook wrote:Without sounding like a xenophobic twat, if he was English, Joe would win it.

Anyone agree? Honestly....

If boxing was on the BBc he would win it, that is the criteria they go by not nationality.

And anyone who wastes there time and money voting is stupid, the phone poll has nothing to do with who wins, people upstairs make the decision.

As a kid I used to love the programme, I know now what a nonsense it is

I would think that a lot of people with no sporting knowledge whatsoever did phone in and vote for the royal because she is....a royal, and no other reason.

Anyway Hamilton will probably get it this time as, even though he failed to win, he gave Formula 1 a serious boost around the world by helping to create a proper championship race after years boredom. He was also on everyones screens for most of 2007 whereas JC fights twice in a year, one fight being a joke and the other on Setanta at 1am.

Don't forget the likes of Andrew Murray, Paula Radcliffe, Johnny Wilkinson etc, they are bound to have more chance of winning. I'm sure boxing will get a mention though!

I hope her horse fornicating kicks her in the head.

And what the fornicate is a 'sports personality' anyway? Why not 'sports person' of the year?

The Blade wrote:

glahn wrote:Calzaghe deserves recognition for being one of the few truly supreme British sportsmen of his generation, but as we all know the general public is much more likely to vote for someone like Hamilton.

Agreed. Hatton may have popularity, but Calzaghe is ahead in terms of achievement, longevity etc. He doesn't come out with profanities on live tv. Nor does he bin two promoters for own interests. Can anyone tell me what Dennis Hobson did so wrong that he was shat on from a great height

He had a gap between his teeth that made him look seperated at birth from Eddie Chambers and Jimmy Tarbuck.

Seriously, Dennis is a good bloke. Hatton should not have left him. Then again, Hatton should not have left Warren, either.

that win by radcliffe in new york the other day was a terrific feat