British Top 30 P4P January 2008

stujones · Post by **stujones** » 05 Jan 2008, 18:46

I do think Horse that now even on achievements Khan should be above Thaxton..... Thaxton's best wins since his return - Meager, Lawton and Stewart (a major struggle) - I say Limond, Lawton and Earl eclipse them - espcially if you look at the manor of wins.

Horse · Post by **Horse** » 05 Jan 2008, 20:46

Max Molyneux wrote:Well Rees did pull off a huge upset considering that he mostly fought In 6 rounders so 10's not a bad rating.

Thanks.

Asterix wrote:That's fair enough. I believe that P4P lists should take into account ability as well as achievements, so that's why those two rankings really stood out to me.

I do take both into account, but achievement demonstrates ability, so it means more to me.

Horse · Post by **Horse** » 06 Jan 2008, 10:28

stujones wrote:I do think Horse that now even on achievements Khan should be above Thaxton..... Thaxton's best wins since his return - Meager, Lawton and Stewart (a major struggle) - I say Limond, Lawton and Earl eclipse them - espcially if you look at the manor of wins.

You seem to be forgetting Khan's "major struggle" with Limond.

Based on recent results I think they are about level, I gave the benefit of the doubt to Thaxton, as Khan has just entered the list.

stujones · Post by **stujones** » 06 Jan 2008, 13:45

Horse wrote:
stujones wrote:I do think Horse that now even on achievements Khan should be above Thaxton..... Thaxton's best wins since his return - Meager, Lawton and Stewart (a major struggle) - I say Limond, Lawton and Earl eclipse them - espcially if you look at the manor of wins.
You seem to be forgetting Khan's "major struggle" with Limond.

Based on recent results I think they are about level, I gave the benefit of the doubt to Thaxton, as Khan has just entered the list.

Was it really a major struggle - did Khan lose any other rounds - really it was a similar struggle as Cooper vs Clay.

Having a major struggle vs Limond is better than having a major struggle vs Stewart IMO.

Horse · Post by **Horse** » 06 Jan 2008, 19:47

stujones wrote:Was it really a major struggle - did Khan lose any other rounds - really it was a similar struggle as Cooper vs Clay.

Khan almost got stopped, so I would call it as major a struggle as Thaxton had against Stewart.

stujones wrote:Having a major struggle vs Limond is better than having a major struggle vs Stewart IMO.

You could be right.

They should be fighting each other soon, so we will find out who really should be higher soon enough (hopefully).

ABA Boxing · Post by **ABA Boxing** » 07 Jan 2008, 09:51

Frankie Gavin (GBR) WC
Joseph Murray (GBR)
Bradley Saunders (GBR)
Darren Sutherland (IRL)
David Price (GBR)
Kennet Egan (IRL)
James Degale (GBR)
Paddy Barnes (IRL)
Daniel Price (GBR)
Stephen Smith (GBR)

Roy Sheehan (IRL)
Billy Joe Saunders (GBR)
Cathal McMonagle (IRL)
Fundo Mhura (GBR)
Neil Perkins (GBR)
Tony Jeffries (GBR)
Thomas Stalker (GBR)
Conor Ahern (IRL)
Darren Langley (GBR)
Darren O'Neil (IRL)

Callum Johnson (GBR)
Carl Frampton (IRL)
Ryan Lindberg (IRL)
David Oliver Joyce (IRL)
John Joe Joyce (IRL)
Paul Butler (GBR)
Eamon O'Kane (IRL)
Michael Maguire (GBR)
Obed Mbwakongo (GBR)
Eamon Finnegan (IRL)