Page 3 of 3
Re: Muhammad Ali vs Jimmy Young - The scoring thread
Posted: 23 Aug 2009, 22:28
by Robinson
That be true as that is generally always the case GI. I have seen fights in the flesh that
looked different on film.
At home you get multiple angles and so on to see things. I do not
know what this fight would have been like live, but from my
angle it was for Young.
Re: Muhammad Ali vs Jimmy Young - The scoring thread
Posted: 23 Aug 2009, 22:30
by Goodnight, Irene
Yes, Young certainly won, but in closer fights, the difference between live & television can make or break a scorecard, & if you're using YouTube, that can only further muddy the waters.
In this case, however, Young won hands down.
Re: Muhammad Ali vs Jimmy Young - The scoring thread
Posted: 23 Aug 2009, 22:36
by Robinson
Score Hagler-Leonard.
I have it on good DVD so I can enjoy it with supreme
quality
Re: Muhammad Ali vs Jimmy Young - The scoring thread
Posted: 23 Aug 2009, 22:38
by Goodnight, Irene
I have it as well, though the DVD quality isn't the best. Passable, though.
Re: Muhammad Ali vs Jimmy Young - The scoring thread
Posted: 23 Aug 2009, 23:50
by Collins2000
Irene, you simpleton, stop PMing me.
I just delete them without even opening them.
I have no wish to communicate further with you on any matters and that is why you are on "ignore" with the other eejits like BRR amd Elmo.
(I may, however, mention your ridiculous name when I am making an analogy involving weak, limp-wristed poseurs.)
Re: Muhammad Ali vs Jimmy Young - The scoring thread
Posted: 24 Aug 2009, 01:01
by Goodnight, Irene
Um, you asked me to PM you, mate. Now, you're backpeddling

Re: Muhammad Ali vs Jimmy Young - The scoring thread
Posted: 24 Aug 2009, 01:16
by Collins2000
Kym, if Leonard vs Hearns TWO is on Youtube, maybe we could give that one a whirl next.
Re: Muhammad Ali vs Jimmy Young - The scoring thread
Posted: 24 Aug 2009, 01:20
by Robinson
Deal, I have that on DVD, but I am pretty certain it would be up on
YT.
I shall be happy to score that one. As I have yet to do it
Re: Muhammad Ali vs Jimmy Young - The scoring thread
Posted: 24 Aug 2009, 01:26
by Collins2000
I too have it on DVD but I am away from home at the moment so will need to avail myself of good old youtube.
I'll check tonight.
Re: Muhammad Ali vs Jimmy Young - The scoring thread
Posted: 05 Oct 2009, 05:51
by wouter
Collins2000 wrote:I have no knowlegde of how the judges scored the fight.
These are the official scorecards broken down (Ali listed first):
Tom Kelly /Terry Moore / Larry Barrett
1. 5-5/4-5/5-5
2. 5-4/5-4/5-4
3. 5-4/5-4/5-5
4. 5-4/5-4/5-4
5. 5-4/5-4/5-4
6. 5-4/5-4/5-4
7. 5-4/5-4/5-4
8. 5-4/5-4/5-4
9. 5-4/5-4/5-4
10.5-4/5-4/5-5
11.4-5/4-5/4-5
12.5-4/5-4/5-4
13.4-5/5-4/4-5
14.4-5/4-5/4-5
15. 5-5/4-5/4-5
Re: Muhammad Ali vs Jimmy Young - The scoring thread
Posted: 06 Oct 2009, 14:20
by The Great John L
It looks like they just pretty much voted for the meal ticket until he was so far ahead that it was safe to actually score a round correctly.
Re: Muhammad Ali vs Jimmy Young - The scoring thread
Posted: 06 Oct 2009, 16:40
by BoxBuzz
If the officials saw it this way, that that's the way it is. They are trained professionals and you should not be attempting this at home. I did and obviously got it all wrong as a result. This is the age of Obama and if it has taught us one thing it should be that you should never question authority. They had/have the situation well in hand.
These trained pro's saw something you don't see. Sometimes you just gotta be there. They were there and you weren't, case closed.
Being serious.....Now I admit I did give the champion a round or two when I thought the round was essentially a draw. This is not a fight that should have seen a changing of champions IMHO.
Re: Muhammad Ali vs Jimmy Young - The scoring thread
Posted: 06 Oct 2009, 16:52
by elmersalsa
It was a complete robbery. If Ali won 3 rounds, that was enough.
Re: Muhammad Ali vs Jimmy Young - The scoring thread
Posted: 06 Oct 2009, 16:53
by The Great John L
BoxBuzz wrote:If the officials saw it this way, that that's the way it is. They are trained professionals and you should not be attempting this at home. I did and obviously got it all wrong as a result. This is the age of Obama and if it has taught us one thing it should be that you should never question authority. They had/have the situation well in hand.
These trained pro's saw something you don't see. Sometimes you just gotta be there. They were there and you weren't, case closed.
Being serious.....Now I admit I did give the champion a round or two when I thought the round was essentially a draw. This is not a fight that should have seen a changing of champions IMHO.
Except for the simple reason that Young won most of the rounds.
BTW, what does Obama have to do with this? Was he one of the judges?
Re: Muhammad Ali vs Jimmy Young - The scoring thread
Posted: 06 Oct 2009, 17:08
by yancey
Collins2000 wrote:Irene, you simpleton, stop PMing me.
I just delete them without even opening them.
I have no wish to communicate further with you on any matters and that is why you are on "ignore" with the other eejits like BRR amd Elmo.
(I may, however, mention your ridiculous name when I am making an analogy involving weak, limp-wristed poseurs.)
Can you feel the love?
Re: Muhammad Ali vs Jimmy Young - The scoring thread
Posted: 06 Oct 2009, 17:24
by Collins2000
yancey wrote:Collins2000 wrote:Irene, you simpleton, stop PMing me.
I just delete them without even opening them.
I have no wish to communicate further with you on any matters and that is why you are on "ignore" with the other eejits like BRR amd Elmo.
(I may, however, mention your ridiculous name when I am making an analogy involving weak, limp-wristed poseurs.)
Can you feel the love?
Your love for Joe?
Sure I can, brother.
It's like my love for a bacon sandwich on the way to work.
Undeniable.
PS Come back later when you start getting the PM treatement from Irene when she is menopausal. You'll be singing a different song then.
Re: Muhammad Ali vs Jimmy Young - The scoring thread
Posted: 06 Oct 2009, 17:26
by raylawpc
Collins2000 wrote:yancey wrote:Collins2000 wrote:Irene, you simpleton, stop PMing me.
I just delete them without even opening them.
I have no wish to communicate further with you on any matters and that is why you are on "ignore" with the other eejits like BRR amd Elmo.
(I may, however, mention your ridiculous name when I am making an analogy involving weak, limp-wristed poseurs.)
Can you feel the love?
Your love for Joe?
Sure I can, brother.
It's like my love for a bacon sandwich on the way to work.
Undeniable.
PS Come back later when you start getting the PM treatement from Irene when she is menopausal. You'll be singing a different song then.
Maybe he is trying the arrange a place in Sydney where you two can met and duke it out . . .

Re: Muhammad Ali vs Jimmy Young - The scoring thread
Posted: 06 Oct 2009, 17:36
by Collins2000
raylawpc wrote:Maybe he is trying the arrange a place in Sydney where you two can met and duke it out . . .

We can but hope, ray, we can but hope.
![[icon_e_biggrin.gif] :D](./images/smilies/icon_e_biggrin.gif)