BoxRec

dagilechia wrote: ↑02 Jan 2018, 11:43 the list is good, and i think we should keep voting in future, i also would like to make a similar vote on CW division

our ranking looks better than the one of Boxrec, not to mention ABC organizations

If you happen to make one for the CW I will surely drop my vote in

Heretic wrote: ↑03 Jan 2018, 15:51

dagilechia wrote: ↑02 Jan 2018, 10:23 but your actual system is okay too and it's all up to you
but i think the main issue is that in your system a fighter ranked 4-3-3-3-3-3-2-2-2-1 is above a fighter ranked 1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-unranked, we can argue which one deserves the higher spot, but i actually think the second fighetr should be ranked higher

I just noticed this bit of text... Did you add it afterwards?

Yeah that seems to be a problem with my way of calculating the votes. Fighter number two should definitely be above the other.

Your points systems seems to be better

I guess there is some kind of fancy mathematical way around this problem. I might need to do a bit of research if I can find the time.

yeah i added it later because i forgot to add it at first
in my voting system, fighter ranked 9x 1st and 1x unranked has (depends on a system, i proposed 3 systems) 360/450/450 points, while fighter ranked 1x 4th, 5x 3rd, 3x 2nd, 1x 1st has 337/421/421 points

i will make a CW vote but first i want to find the best scoring method, while this one is good, i think if i find some spare time i can think of a better scoring system

1 JOSHUA Anthony
2 POVETKIN Alexander
3 WILDER Deontay
4 PARKER Joseph
5 HAMMER Christian
6 ORTIZ Luis
7 MILLER Jarrell
8 PULEV Kubrat
9 BREAZEALE Dominic
10 WHYTE Dillian
11 MARTIN Charles
12 TAKAM Carlos
13 WACH Mariusz
14 DUHAUPAS Johann
15 CHARR Manuel

Belanio wrote: ↑28 Feb 2018, 08:24 1 JOSHUA Anthony
2 POVETKIN Alexander
3 WILDER Deontay
4 PARKER Joseph
5 HAMMER Christian
6 ORTIZ Luis
7 MILLER Jarrell
8 PULEV Kubrat
9 BREAZEALE Dominic
10 WHYTE Dillian
11 MARTIN Charles
12 TAKAM Carlos
13 WACH Mariusz
14 DUHAUPAS Johann
15 CHARR Manuel

its the first time i have seen someone rank Hammer in top 5. also, Martin and Charr in top 15 is funny too