Boxerbeetle wrote: ↑10 Nov 2025, 04:55
I just don’t think combat sports are remotely equivalent to things like tennis. Have a look down Shields’ list of opponents and seriously tell me the average guy wouldn’t simply smash their face in with ease?
Savannah Marshall would beat the shit out of a non boxer. No question at all.
She’s the only one I’d be concerned about for sure
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
Posted: 10 Nov 2025, 05:59
by smiling assassin
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
Boxerbeetle wrote: ↑10 Nov 2025, 04:55
I just don’t think combat sports are remotely equivalent to things like tennis. Have a look down Shields’ list of opponents and seriously tell me the average guy wouldn’t simply smash their face in with ease?
Savannah Marshall would beat the shit out of a non boxer. No question at all.
not her obviously - she's like Shields.
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
Posted: 10 Nov 2025, 12:20
by Nightmare Roy
Stare I'm in now I'd get my arse handed to me,
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
Posted: 10 Nov 2025, 14:52
by MasterG
Boxerbeetle wrote: ↑09 Nov 2025, 11:38
Without wanting to sound disrespectful, I think the average guy would smash her face in, even without training whatsoever?
I don't agree. She knows the moves and would kick the average Joe to tomorrow.
Anyone with a reasonable amount of fight knowledge then maybe so.
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
Boxerbeetle wrote: ↑10 Nov 2025, 04:55
I just don’t think combat sports are remotely equivalent to things like tennis. Have a look down Shields’ list of opponents and seriously tell me the average guy wouldn’t simply smash their face in with ease?
Savannah Marshall would beat the shit out of a non boxer. No question at all.
You clearly know nothing about boxing / street fighting / violence you should link up within that other guy who claims that Katie Taylor who can barely knock out a 9 stone woman would ko every forum member on a round
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
Boxerbeetle wrote: ↑10 Nov 2025, 04:55
I just don’t think combat sports are remotely equivalent to things like tennis. Have a look down Shields’ list of opponents and seriously tell me the average guy wouldn’t simply smash their face in with ease?
Savannah Marshall would beat the shit out of a non boxer. No question at all.
. LMAO any average tough guy or bouncer would destroy her
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
Posted: 10 Nov 2025, 16:13
by Cecil Coffee
I’m 4-0 against my ex-girlfriends, I’d fancy my chances.
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
Boxerbeetle wrote: ↑10 Nov 2025, 04:55
I just don’t think combat sports are remotely equivalent to things like tennis. Have a look down Shields’ list of opponents and seriously tell me the average guy wouldn’t simply smash their face in with ease?
Savannah Marshall would beat the shit out of a non boxer. No question at all.
You clearly know nothing about boxing / street fighting / violence you should link up within that other guy who claims that Katie Taylor who can barely knock out a 9 stone woman would ko every forum member on a round
Street fighting and violence? The question is about a boxing match
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
Posted: 10 Nov 2025, 16:49
by JamesPhilips
Cecil Coffee wrote: ↑10 Nov 2025, 16:13
I’m 4-0 against my ex-girlfriends, I’d fancy my chances.
Is this Gervonta Davis’s account
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
Savannah Marshall would beat the shit out of a non boxer. No question at all.
You clearly know nothing about boxing / street fighting / violence you should link up within that other guy who claims that Katie Taylor who can barely knock out a 9 stone woman would ko every forum member on a round
Street fighting and violence? The question is about a boxing match
I also said boxing. I have in the flesh seen many top female amateurs spar and they were so vulnerable and so poor compared to novice amateurs males and juniors it was embarrassing.
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
You clearly know nothing about boxing / street fighting / violence you should link up within that other guy who claims that Katie Taylor who can barely knock out a 9 stone woman would ko every forum member on a round
Street fighting and violence? The question is about a boxing match
I also said boxing. I have in the flesh seen many top female amateurs spar and they were so vulnerable and so poor compared to novice amateurs males and juniors it was embarrassing.
Based on the replies, most Boxrec users are either old or not active boxers.
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
Posted: 10 Nov 2025, 17:31
by gilgamesh
Or they have eyes and understand biology
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
Posted: 10 Nov 2025, 17:53
by JamesPhilips
gilgamesh wrote: ↑10 Nov 2025, 17:31
Or they have eyes and understand biology
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
Posted: 10 Nov 2025, 18:41
by Taansend
Coco wrote: ↑09 Nov 2025, 10:53
50, 5'9, 150lbs
Gimme 6 weeks and 5 grand I'd def take it and make it competitive
I'd fancy it
Ex pro journeyman I'd have beaten Flintoff
I dunno, Mate.
I know he has a cuddly exterior but he was a bloody caveman, for fucks sake. You don't get to be middle aged in prehistoric times without being a tough bastard.
Although I do reckon Barney is the true hard man of the two.
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
You clearly know nothing about boxing / street fighting / violence you should link up within that other guy who claims that Katie Taylor who can barely knock out a 9 stone woman would ko every forum member on a round
Street fighting and violence? The question is about a boxing match
I also said boxing. I have in the flesh seen many top female amateurs spar and they were so vulnerable and so poor compared to novice amateurs males and juniors it was embarrassing.
Which ones?
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
Posted: 10 Nov 2025, 19:19
by forcefraser
52, 5ft 9, 180bs, decent nick.
I'd beat her around the ring for a round to get warmed up and smash it in the 2nd
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
Cecil Coffee wrote: ↑10 Nov 2025, 16:13
I’m 4-0 against my ex-girlfriends, I’d fancy my chances.
Is this Gervonta Davis’s account
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
Posted: 11 Nov 2025, 03:32
by Greg Houston
At 42 years old, and very much overweight with no boxing experience, I reckon she sends me to the canvas with a body shot in the first round and I ain't getting up.
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
skanksta wrote: ↑09 Nov 2025, 15:40
It's certainly an interesting problem...
I've said this before, but it must be possible to calculate a 'male advantage formula' and let them fight off that.
Say 108 man vs 168 woman ?
Really hard to scale it remember the tennis equivalent -
Serena Williams lost to Karsten Braasch, who was ranked ATP World No. 203 at the time, during an exhibition "Battle of the Sexes" match at the 1998 Australian Open.
Braasch, described by one journalist as a player whose training regime centered around cigarettes and alcohol, defeated Serena 6–1 in a single-set contest after racing to a 5–0 lead.
Although she was still good then, she was only 17. Even still, 200th in the world is still a hell of a lot better than the average Boxrec user is in comparison to Shields.
200th in the world is a phenomenally good male athlete.
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
Coco wrote: ↑09 Nov 2025, 10:53
50, 5'9, 150lbs
Gimme 6 weeks and 5 grand I'd def take it and make it competitive
I'd fancy it
Ex pro journeyman I'd have beaten Flintoff
I dunno, Mate.
I know he has a cuddly exterior but he was a bloody caveman, for fucks sake. You don't get to be middle aged in prehistoric times without being a tough bastard.
Although I do reckon Barney is the true hard man of the two.
He'd fit in well on this thread.
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
Posted: 11 Nov 2025, 11:41
by tigermoth87
I'd clean her clock.
Any man in half decent shape would be a match for any boxer. It's like when the Williams sisters played some no hoper 200 ranked scrub and got their arse handed to them.
Re: Clarissa Shields vs You. 10 x 2 Min Rounds Who Wins?
Posted: 11 Nov 2025, 11:44
by smiling assassin
tigermoth87 wrote: ↑11 Nov 2025, 11:41
I'd clean her clock.
Any man in half decent shape would be a match for any boxer. It's like when the Williams sisters played some no hoper 200 ranked scrub and got their arse handed to them.
