The Truth

[alexpaterson]

I would like to see Ward fighting someone in the class of Hopkins before calling him great same with Kessler and Froch not great yet but good fighters but Calzaghe, Williams and Hopkins are great IMO

[Deserter]

1. Bernard Hopkins (Great)
2. Andre Ward (Great)
3. Paul Williams (Great)
4. Joe Calzaghe (Great)
5. Carl Froch (Great)
6. Mikkel Kessler (Great)

That's about as much 'The Truth' as Star Wars. Mupppet.

[Hagler2002]

What a great thread

[teddy009]

1. Bernard Hopkins (Great)
2. Andre Ward (Great)
3. Paul Williams (Great)
4. Joe Calzaghe (Great)
5. Carl Froch (Great)
6. Mikkel Kessler (Great)

That's about as much 'The Truth' as Star Wars. Mupppet.

What dont you believe in the force

[Captain Hook]

1. Bernard Hopkins (Great)
2. Andre Ward (Great)
3. Paul Williams (Great)
4. Joe Calzaghe (Great)
5. Carl Froch (Great)
6. Mikkel Kessler (Great)

That's about as much 'The Truth' as Star Wars. Mupppet.

I don't get this, what was the point of this thread....

I'd rather it have been about Carl Williams.

[TerribleTerry]

1. Bernard Hopkins (Great)
2. Andre Ward (Great)
3. Paul Williams (Great)
4. Joe Calzaghe (Great)
5. Carl Froch (Great)
6. Mikkel Kessler (Great)

"The Truth?

You can't handle the truth!"

[TerribleTerry]

Err 6 great fighters, who would dominate in any era, it’s not hard.

Poor troll attempt.

2/10 for effort alone.

Must try harder

[Captain Hook]

Superheavyweight - So where does "the truth" bit come in you facetious twot?

[Poncey]

Just saying we got 6 great fighters @ the classic weight and below, no one can beat them (with the exception of each other of course).

Tell that to Quintana, Taylor, Jones Jr and Mitchell.

[Asterix]

Err 6 great fighters, who would dominate in any era, it’s not hard.

Poor troll attempt.

2/10 for effort alone.

Must try harder

[carrotcruncher]

Just saying we got 6 great fighters @ the classic weight and below, no one can beat them (with the exception of each other of course).

Tell that to Quintana, Taylor, Jones Jr and Mitchell.

RJJ is the only guy who’s really beaten Bhop, the rest were draws @ worst.

Jones won it like a thief
ran all night

[Quixall]

1. Bernard Hopkins (Great)
2. Andre Ward (Great)
3. Paul Williams (Great)
4. Joe Calzaghe (Great)
5. Carl Froch (Great)
6. Mikkel Kessler (Great)

Very strange list....

Paul Williams is'nt great, and neither are Kessler, Froch and Ward. I would even have my doubts against Calzaghe. He had four big fights in his career, Lacy, Kessler, Hopkins and Jones. Kessler is very good, put has'nt fought anyone that called be called an "elite" fighter, apart from Joe obviously. Lacy was well over-rated and Hopkins and Jones were well past there primes and p4p status when Calzaghe fought them. Maybe Calzaghe's win against Hopkins(I still have Hopkins wining that fight by a round) looks better, now that he has beaten Pavlik, but i would'nt personally say that Calzaghe is one of the greats, but he is certainly a lot closer to it than most of the fighters you have mentioned on your list.

[Quixall]

Hopkins is the greatest fighter of all time.

Why is he ?

[Poncey]

My finger is hovering over that lock thread button. Trying to resist.