Page 1 of 1
Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 10 Oct 2009, 01:24
by lacollier883
http://fightfranchise.com/brodie_and_cr ... _meet.html
Michael Brodie and Anthony Crolla are set to meet on the 27th November on a Hatton Promotions card. Who will win this one.
If Brodie loses will he retire, where will Crolla go if he loses.
Is this a good move by Hatton to put these 2 fighters in the ring together
Craig Watson and Thomas McDonagh are set to be on the card too
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 10 Oct 2009, 03:06
by leforge
Who the main fight?
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 10 Oct 2009, 03:11
by whicker
Yes it is!
Quality competative boxing is exactly what the sport needs.
Another decent fight or 2 on this card, and I'd be tempted to go and watch the show live.
Regarding the fight itself - Brodie is 35- he needs to be getting on with it- no point "treading water" fighting journeymen. Likewise Crolla. OK, he could be "excused" a warm up fight, but again, it's in his interests to keep his career moving and fighting quality opponents.
I'd say Crolla will win this. However, if Brodie wins, and does so comfortably, he will be right back "in the mix."
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 10 Oct 2009, 03:32
by Deserter
Good match-up and a real cross-roads fight. I see a Crolla victory sending Brodie back into retirement unfortunately.
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 10 Oct 2009, 03:34
by lacollier883
leforge wrote:Who the main fight?
The only fight I have is Craig Watson is on the bill fighting Riad Menasria, and Thomas McDonagh is on the bill too
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 10 Oct 2009, 03:39
by Londonirish
whicker wrote:.
I'd say Crolla will win this. However, if Brodie wins, and does so comfortably, he will be right back "in the mix."
I see Crolla Winning this one by KO, he didnt look good against Mark Alexander was put over twice Mark aint a Puncher..
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 10 Oct 2009, 04:05
by 15829
hope crolla wins this brodie although not the force he used to be will still be a decent name on crollas record
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 10 Oct 2009, 04:35
by stevieb_8006
dont think this will even be close. Crolla by stoppage. Brodies finished.
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 10 Oct 2009, 05:09
by gobbles
Crolla. Brodie is totally shot and should not be boxing.
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 10 Oct 2009, 05:12
by chris s
Poor Brodie should not be boxing.
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 10 Oct 2009, 05:27
by alexpaterson
I hope Crolla wins I really like him I think he's a good boxer with heart and guts this is another tough fight for him I see him KO'ing Brodie and I hope Brodie retires
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 10 Oct 2009, 12:53
by xXHAMMERXx
ive been in the gym with brodie this week an i no crolla really well there both good friends of mine an i think alot of people are judging brodie on his last performance i no he isnt shot cos ive seen him sparring an no he can still take a wack he did the weight wrong last time an this time i hope he is right as for crolla he is a top lad an very skillfull but i still think its a 50 50 fight if brodie ha done is work right if he dosent he will get his head boxed off an that will be a shame to end like that !!!!!!
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 11 Oct 2009, 04:44
by jrh
was thinking crolla at fist but when i thnk about it hink brodie will stp him if its an 8 rounder , as he is stil very srong ,might be an up and down battle cant wait for this one

Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 11 Oct 2009, 07:03
by steve689
If Crolla has anything about him then he must win this one. Brodie you would have thought has seen much better days and it's debatable whether he should be continuing at all.
I think it's pretty obvious that Crolla is not going to live up to the lofty expectations that he had when turning pro, but with more experience and wins under his belt he could still compete at British title level.
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 11 Oct 2009, 15:06
by landon
brodie is shot 2 pieces good name on crollas record
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 11 Oct 2009, 16:31
by nigeltsport
Judge for yourselves by watching Brodie's last fight v Mark Alexander
http://www.brandhatton.com/TV/Events/Professional
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 11 Oct 2009, 16:46
by standing8
Brilliant match up,this stuff brings in joe public from the streets with hard earned ££££...
not friends/family that know nowt!!!!!
50/50 fight bring it on!!!!!!
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 11 Oct 2009, 17:01
by Spud
Very good fight to put on.
The outcome is dependant on how much Brodie has left in the tank - if Crolla can take him to the limits it could get interesting.
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 11 Oct 2009, 17:57
by jBacca
Crolla to stop Brodie.. Brodie looked like he had no resistance against Alexander.
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 12 Oct 2009, 01:55
by oliverfennell
whicker wrote:Regarding the fight itself - Brodie is 35- he needs to be getting on with it- no point "treading water" fighting journeymen.
Yep, if this comeback isn't going to work out, better to find out sooner rather than later.
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 12 Oct 2009, 04:53
by Wales
Spud wrote:Very good fight to put on.
The outcome is dependant on how much Brodie has left in the tank - if Crolla can take him to the limits it could get interesting.
Nope Crolla was dismantle him with ease.
Hatton promotions are putting some great cards on, lots of 50-50 or 60-40 fights, unlike many promotions that seem to be 80-20 or even 99-01 fights!!
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 12 Oct 2009, 05:04
by Podmore_Birmingham
As much as it pains me to say, Crolla will stop Brodie within four rounds, possibly sooner. Always been a huge Michael Brodie fan but his weakness around the body will see him dismantled.
Re: Brodie vs Crolla - Who wins
Posted: 12 Oct 2009, 05:35
by Captain Hook
gobbles wrote:Crolla. Brodie is totally shot and should not be boxing.
x2