BoxRec

1. (1.) Ricky Hatton
2. (2.) Carl Froch
3. (3.) David Haye
4. (4.) Amir Khan
5. (5.) Clinton Woods
6. (6.) Junior Witter
7. (8.) Bernard Dunne (Irish)
8. (9.) Rendall Munroe
9. (29.) Ryan Rhodes
10. (10.) Matthew Macklin

11. (11.) Nicky Cook
12. (18.) John Murray
13. (19.) Nathan Cleverly
14. (7.) Jamie Moore
15. (12.) Kell Brook
16. (15.) Ian Napa
17. (13.) Alex Arthur
18. (14.) Kevin Mitchell
19. (23.) Jason Booth
20. (16.) Martin Lindsay (Irish)

21. (17.) Darren Barker
22. (20.) Anthony Small
23. (21.) Ajose Olusegan
24. (22.) Enzo Maccarinelli
25. (24.) John Simpson
26. (25.) Sam Sexton
27. (27.) John Duddy (Irish)
28. (26.) Martin Rogan (Irish)
29. (28.) Gavin Rees
30. (30.) Paul McCloskey (Irish)

Any comments, criticisms or P4P lists are very welcome.

Did you deliberately wait until the the bell struck midnight to post this? Erm, that is a tad sad.

Horse wrote:Any comments, criticisms or P4P lists are very welcome.

Froch should be number 1! Even if be struggled with dirrell. Pascal Taylor and dirrell tops Hatton! Getting knocked out in 2 of your last 4 drops Hatton!

sg1985 wrote:

DG. wrote:

Horse wrote:Any comments, criticisms or P4P lists are very welcome.

Froch should be number 1! Even if be struggled with dirrell. Pascal Taylor and dirrell tops Hatton! Getting knocked out in 2 of your last 3 drops Hatton!

Hatton didn't get knocked out in two of his last three.

Edited. Meant 2 of last 4!

I'd have Jason Booth higher than Alex Arthur and Froch at number 1 but good list all the same

alexpaterson wrote:I'd have Jason Booth higher than Alex Arthur and Froch at number 1 but good list all the same

How can you put Froch at No1?He's not even the best super middleweight in Europe.When his acheivements match Ricky's,maybe so...

mickey1975 wrote:

alexpaterson wrote:I'd have Jason Booth higher than Alex Arthur and Froch at number 1 but good list all the same

How can you put Froch at No1?He's not even the best super middleweight in Europe.When his acheivements match Ricky's,maybe so...

It's not an all time list mickey.

Its the current list.

Otherwise Lennox would be no1.

Finch wrote:Did you deliberately wait until the the bell struck midnight to post this? Erm, that is a tad sad.

I didn't want people to have to wait for it. Some people may have been staying up to get a look.

boring - McCloskey too low!!

No way should Rendall Munroe be so high!! Yeah he is Europian champion but who has he actually beat, No one of note.

Horse wrote:

Finch wrote:Did you deliberately wait until the the bell struck midnight to post this? Erm, that is a tad sad.

I didn't want people to have to wait for it. Some people may have been staying up to get a look.

Haha - fair play

Then they are a tad sadder than you.

I think Froch should be top, the likes of Murray and Cleverly should be higher than Nicky Cook who has done nothing since losing his belt to Martinez and I also think Booth should be ahead of Napa and that Martin Lindsay is ranked a little bit too high.

spot on otherwise

DG. wrote:Froch should be number 1! Even if be struggled with dirrell. Pascal Taylor and dirrell tops Hatton! Getting knocked out in 2 of your last 4 drops Hatton!

Dirrell was unproven at World class level, so I didn't think that a close decision win over him was enough for Froch to claim the number 1 spot.

If Froch beats Kessler or Abraham then he has a good chance of overtaking Hatton.

Murray outside the top 10 is just crazy talk! Especially when you have a retired fighter at five.

alexpaterson wrote:I'd have Jason Booth higher than Alex Arthur and Froch at number 1 but good list all the same

Hunter looked awful, so I didn't feel that I could raise Booth any further up the list based on beating him. Booth would have had to climb another two places to go above Arthur and I didn't think he deserved to climb up that many places.

I might have put Froch at the top if he had beaten Dirrell convincingly, but he didn't.

sligobhoy67 wrote:boring - McCloskey too low!!

McCloskey has not fought since March. I cannot move him up until he wins a fight.

Regarding Hatton/Froch -

Does a Pacman loss and Malinaggi, Lazcano victories, beat Froch's wins over Pascal, Taylor, Dirrell?

I'd have sided with Froch and given him No.1

And because Froch won't put on and lose 18st before Kessler.

Horse wrote:

DG. wrote:Froch should be number 1! Even if be struggled with dirrell. Pascal Taylor and dirrell tops Hatton! Getting knocked out in 2 of your last 4 drops Hatton!

Dirrell was unproven at World class level, so I didn't think that a close decision win over him was enough for Froch to claim the number 1 spot.

If Froch beats Kessler or Abraham then he has a good chance of overtaking Hatton.

Sorry, but beating PASCAL and Jermaine Taylor and Dirrell BACK TO BACK is better than getting stretched by PBF - dubious stoppage against Maliganaggi and points win against Lazcano then stretched against Pacman.

Its a current list after all.

What does it say about British Boxing if getting knocked out by a p4p smaller man makes you number 1?

Pascal is a World Champion up a weight, remember!!!

Sorry, but Hatton is STILL living off Kostya!



Froch Number 1!!!

Gwannnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn,Froch!!!


Number 1 British P4P!

Also, Kessler is good -as is Abrahms, but apart from Jermain Taylor, who have either of them really beat?

Mundine?

Froch Number1!

CEO_Hoodlem wrote:No way should Rendall Munroe be so high!! Yeah he is Europian champion but who has he actually beat, No one of note.

He has beaten Kiko Martinez twice, who is a noteworthy opponent. The other three opponents he has fought as European champion may not be that great, but are they decent.

Which fighters that are below Munroe have a better record over the last two years?

Finch wrote:Haha - fair play

Then they are a tad sadder than you.

Horse wrote:1. (1.) Ricky Hatton
2. (2.) Carl Froch
3. (3.) David Haye
4. (4.) Amir Khan
5. (5.) Clinton Woods
6. (6.) Junior Witter
7. (8.) Bernard Dunne (Irish)
8. (9.) Rendall Munroe
9. (29.) Ryan Rhodes
10. (10.) Matthew Macklin

11. (11.) Nicky Cook
12. (18.) John Murray
13. (19.) Nathan Cleverly
14. (7.) Jamie Moore
15. (12.) Kell Brook
16. (15.) Ian Napa
17. (13.) Alex Arthur
18. (14.) Kevin Mitchell
19. (23.) Jason Booth
20. (16.) Martin Lindsay (Irish)

21. (17.) Darren Barker
22. (20.) Anthony Small
23. (21.) Ajose Olusegan
24. (22.) Enzo Maccarinelli
25. (24.) John Simpson
26. (25.) Sam Sexton
27. (27.) John Duddy (Irish)
28. (26.) Martin Rogan (Irish)
29. (28.) Gavin Rees
30. (30.) Paul McCloskey (Irish)

I think it's an absolute disgrace that Martin Rogan is above Gavin Rees. I'm simply fuming, and I'm going to contact Rees immediately to let him know what you've done. You should be ashamed. You've let your family down with that one Horse. Honestly, do you deliberately try to offend people with these things?

DG. wrote: Sorry, but beating PASCAL and Jermaine Taylor and Dirrell BACK TO BACK is better than getting stretched by PBF - dubious stoppage against Maliganaggi and points win against Lazcano then stretched against Pacman.

A dubious stoppage against Malignaggi?? Are you having a laugh?? His corner threw in the towel after ten one sided rounds. Dubious stoppage, indeed.

Classic.

napa above booth mitchell and about 20 others? napa is 19-7