Page 1 of 1

Re: The Greatest 12 Rounder of the Modern Era

Posted: 18 Jan 2010, 07:02
by dtjenkins
I would have the first 3 rounds as Hagler vs Hearns!

Re: The Greatest 12 Rounder of the Modern Era

Posted: 18 Jan 2010, 08:25
by Poncey
Bobby Chacon v Rafael Limon 4 is greater than the rest of the list combined.

Re: The Greatest 12 Rounder of the Modern Era

Posted: 18 Jan 2010, 09:32
by Ketchel
GATTI v WARD 1 ROUND 9 was better than Round 9: John David Jackson v Jorge Castro.

Re: The Greatest 12 Rounder of the Modern Era

Posted: 18 Jan 2010, 09:57
by Wales
i for one would like to say well done, great effort IMO. Never going to please everyone, but I'd say thats a damned fine effort!!

Look forward to watching them at home later, bloody work restrictions.

Re: The Greatest 12 Rounder of the Modern Era

Posted: 18 Jan 2010, 10:10
by The Law
Poncey wrote:Bobby Chacon v Rafael Limon 4 is greater than the rest of the list combined.
I totally agree.

Re: The Greatest 12 Rounder of the Modern Era

Posted: 18 Jan 2010, 10:14
by Counter-puncher
The Law wrote:
Poncey wrote:Bobby Chacon v Rafael Limon 4 is greater than the rest of the list combined.
I totally agree.
fair enough but i don 't think it would serve to cover every round, there was not a lot going on in the first round of that one for start, and there are rounds in the above selection every bit as good as the individual rounds of Chacon - Limon 4, IMO

Re: The Greatest 12 Rounder of the Modern Era

Posted: 18 Jan 2010, 10:55
by lefthook82
Round 10 of Corrales would have been laughed at if it was Rocky movie. Such was the hollywoodesque nature of the comeback

But Round 10 will always have to be Tyson v Douglas. The significance of what was being witnessed. Iron Mike, the baddest man on the planet, sprawled on the canvas.

Surely the most signifacnt round in the history of boxing?

Re: The Greatest 12 Rounder of the Modern Era

Posted: 18 Jan 2010, 11:00
by whiskey
A great link mate on a nice site ive never been on before.

thanks 8)

Re: The Greatest 12 Rounder of the Modern Era

Posted: 18 Jan 2010, 11:57
by Deno1986
Ketchel wrote:GATTI v WARD 1 ROUND 9 was better than Round 9: John David Jackson v Jorge Castro.
I would have picked Ward-Gatti Round 9 aswell but Castro-Jackson was a thriller too, think Castro was nearly floored before catching Jackson with a great left hook. Jackson was cruising to victory in that fight.

Re: The Greatest 12 Rounder of the Modern Era

Posted: 18 Jan 2010, 12:08
by Chris W 1982
How about a domestic one?

Round 1- Benn v McClellan
Round 2- Earl v Katsidis


Please continue

Re: The Greatest 12 Rounder of the Modern Era

Posted: 18 Jan 2010, 12:13
by Wales
Round 3 Haye Barrett, for magnitude more than excitment. This was the round Haye announced himself to the heavyweight division.

Can I make a case for Calzaghe Mitchell to be round 2 ?

Re: The Greatest 12 Rounder of the Modern Era

Posted: 18 Jan 2010, 12:14
by Wales
Wales wrote:Round 3 Haye Barrett, for magnitude more than excitment. This was the round Haye announced himself to the heavyweight division.

not sure about the above actually... im going back to the drawing board on that one.

Re: The Greatest 12 Rounder of the Modern Era

Posted: 18 Jan 2010, 12:22
by Chris W 1982
Im getting David Walker in there somewhere.

Re: The Greatest 12 Rounder of the Modern Era

Posted: 18 Jan 2010, 12:25
by Wales
Moore Jones is getting crowbarred in too, think it was the 4th round of their 3rd fight that was immense wasnt it ?? or wa sit the 5th?

Re: The Greatest 12 Rounder of the Modern Era

Posted: 18 Jan 2010, 12:56
by lefthook82
Domestic wise Hobson v Enzo had a few notable ounds. And then there is Rigby-Ayers that also ahd a few barnstoming rounds, lets not forget and Carl J v Kevin Mitchell with a few tasty rounds

If we are talking about on these shores with at least one domestic opponent then Thompson v Sellers was insane all 4 rounds

Probably not enough quality to be included in this domestic list but I liked the Khan Gomez round where Gomez visibly hurt Khan to the body and he responded with a 10-15 punch combo

Re: The Greatest 12 Rounder of the Modern Era

Posted: 18 Jan 2010, 13:56
by chris s
lefthook82 wrote:Round 10 of Corrales would have been laughed at if it was Rocky movie. Such was the hollywoodesque nature of the comeback

But Round 10 will always have to be Tyson v Douglas. The significance of what was being witnessed. Iron Mike, the baddest man on the planet, sprawled on the canvas.

Surely the most signifacnt round in the history of boxing?
Great round for sure, what about the 10th of Holyfield-Bowe I

Re: The Greatest 12 Rounder of the Modern Era

Posted: 18 Jan 2010, 14:22
by Syntax Error
MachoMan09 wrote:You may have seen this before. If you haven't, it is well worth looking at. Andrew Harrison has compiled, what in his opinion, are the greatest 12 rounds of the modern era. The article brings up some fantastic memories and there is video footage for each round for you to enjoy.

http://queensberry-rules.com/2010-artic ... n-era.html

Round 1: Ray Mancini v Art Frias
Round 2: Bobby Chacon v Rafael Limon
Round 3: Thomas Hearns v Iran Barkley
Round 4: George Foreman v Ron Lyle
Round 5: Erik Morales v Marco Antonio Barrera
Round 6: John Mugabi v Marvelous Marvin Hagler
Round 7: Michael Carbajal v Humberto ‘Chiquita’ Gonzalez
Round 8: Matthew Saad Muhammad v Alvaro ‘Yaqui’ Lopez
Round 9: John David Jackson v Jorge Castro
Round 10: Diego Corrales v Jose Luis Castillo
Round 11: Chris Eubank v Michael Watson
Round 12: Wilfredo Gomez v Lupe Pintor
12 fantastic rounds! :bag:

Round 8 is my favourite.

It was brilliant; typical Saad! :TU:

Re: The Greatest 12 Rounder of the Modern Era

Posted: 18 Jan 2010, 15:05
by Loynesy
Macho Man

That is genius. I may have some slight debates over a few, but that is mere white noise. I salute you.

PL