That's a wicked tough grouping. Honestly, just about any order would be acceptable. Cob Castro is pretty clearly on the bottom.
Lujan
Laporte
Davis
Castro
Penalosa
Lopez
Cob Castro
Style wise, Lujan was really slick. He had some pop in his shots and a granite chin, but he wasn't overly aggressive. I don't see the Qawi comparison.
Davis,Castro & Lopez were similar.
How would you sort them p4p?
-
SaadOffTheDeck
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 19602
- Joined: 04 Jun 2009, 07:38
Re: How would you sort them p4p?
Luv da spellin m8! 
-
SaadOffTheDeck
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 19602
- Joined: 04 Jun 2009, 07:38
Re: How would you sort them p4p?
The idea that Lujan wasn't overly aggressive came from watching him fight. Yes, Qawi was much more aggressive than Lujan and their styles were completely different.
I don't recall saying that CobCastro sucked or I didn't know who he was. He ranks lower than all of the other guys to me.
I don't recall saying that CobCastro sucked or I didn't know who he was. He ranks lower than all of the other guys to me.
-
SaadOffTheDeck
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 19602
- Joined: 04 Jun 2009, 07:38
Re: How would you sort them p4p?
Were you actually asking a question or just looking for an argument? If it's the latter, as much as I enjoy an online tussle the language barrier is just too great.frankenfrank wrote:Michael Spinks made Qawi retreat and maybe Holyfield (did so) as well (as soon as in their 1st fight) .
I wocht Lujan vs Zamora , Chandler and Pedroza and do not recall him ever retreating or even stopping from moving 4ward or stopping from throwing panches .
So based on der faits det i wocht , Lujan woz mor agresiv
End Castro is so under8ed beist jast on not geting de nod in clous decijens .
close decijens with Carbajal and Gonzalez*2 end den 2 times champion @ 108 .
Qawi didn't retreat from Spinks, he got out-boxed. He never stopped coming after Holyfield either. You're clearly confusing Lujan with Roberto Duran.
-
SaadOffTheDeck
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 19602
- Joined: 04 Jun 2009, 07:38
Re: How would you sort them p4p?
So you saw Qawi retreat for 3 minutes and Lujan never took a backward step?frankenfrank wrote:Qawi retreated from Spinks in the 1st round of their fight . It does not mean in its entirety .SaadOffTheDeck wrote:Were you actually asking a question or just looking for an argument? If it's the latter, as much as I enjoy an online tussle the language barrier is just too great.frankenfrank wrote:Michael Spinks made Qawi retreat and maybe Holyfield (did so) as well (as soon as in their 1st fight) .
I wocht Lujan vs Zamora , Chandler and Pedroza and do not recall him ever retreating or even stopping from moving 4ward or stopping from throwing panches .
So based on der faits det i wocht , Lujan woz mor agresiv
End Castro is so under8ed beist jast on not geting de nod in clous decijens .
close decijens with Carbajal and Gonzalez*2 end den 2 times champion @ 108 .
Qawi didn't retreat from Spinks, he got out-boxed. He never stopped coming after Holyfield either. You're clearly confusing Lujan with Roberto Duran.
Maybe he did not stop coming after Holyfield but my claim on the Michael Spinks fight holds.
I did not confuse Lujan with Duran.
Did u watch him vs Zamora , Chandler and Pedroza? because I did.
I do not know why always coming forward always throwing punches is not aggressive enough for you.
Who was overly aggressive then? Holyfield? Foreman? Ibeabuchi? because I watched each one of them retreating more than I watched Lujan retreat and the same holds when comparing Qawi with Lujan.
You didn't see Lujan/Davila on the Ali/Spinks undercard? It's obvious that your mind is made up, wrong as you may be, I'm not going to waste my time on it any further. You think Lujan was a mini Joe Frazier, good for you.
-
SaadOffTheDeck
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 19602
- Joined: 04 Jun 2009, 07:38
Re: How would you sort them p4p?
Lujan and qawi were both incredibly durable. That's one way in which they were very similar. I'm starting to think you've never Jorge fight at all.
-
SaadOffTheDeck
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 19602
- Joined: 04 Jun 2009, 07:38
-
King Carlos
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 1123
- Joined: 11 May 2010, 19:10
Re: How would you sort them p4p?
Frankenfrank is one of the internet's greatest boxing trolls. Debating him is an exercise in futility. oar shood i zay un ecksersize in fyootilitee