Gamboa/Casamayor at either 130 or 135.

[Rover]

This is assuming Casa's finished for good (why I put it in BOTP). Who takes a battle between the Gamboa of today and the Casamayor of a decade ago?
Casa by decision for me.

[RadioElRadar]

Based on Gamboa v Farenas (130) and Perez (135) I think Casa would handle him quite comfortably at either weight.

Casamayor UD for me.

[gilgamesh]

For now you gotta give the edge to Casamayor because he proved his talent more against top level fighters, while Gamboa still hasn't.

The best opponent Gamboa's beaten is Salido.

[Diamond WEAPON]

For now you gotta give the edge to Casamayor because he proved his talent more against top level fighters, while Gamboa still hasn't.

The best opponent Gamboa's beaten is Salido.

Casamayor's top opponents were bigger guys than Gamboa's as well, which can account for something when it relates to how physical the two are with one another despite being about the same weight fight-night wise.

[Vladimir5555]

Casamayoor win UD