Maidana/Gatti at 140.

[Rover]

Marcos stops him in a war IMO. How do you see it?
gil, this one's for you.

[gilgamesh]

One of my all time favorites against one of my current favorites...tough one to call. I could see either one of them getting the better of it, I would figure it would be Gatti by decision or Maidana by KO. I think Maidana's added a little more craft to his game recently as a Welterweight...so I think Gatti has the edge in boxing skill in the proposed bout at 140.

I'll take Gatti by decision in a war...but it could go either way and would've definitely been rematch worthy.

[SaadOffTheDeck]

Maidana would have massacred Gatti.

[giacomino]

Couldn't see this lasting the distance. Seemed like it was fairly easy to draw Gatti into a war late in his career, negating his better boxing skills, and IMO that gives Maidana the advantage

[Vladimir5555]

I d take Chino.He more danger puncher.

[Giancarlo]

Maidana