BoxRec

Shawn Porter
Danny Garcia
Keith Thurman
Kell Brook
Adrien Broner

DrunkenBoxer wrote:Shawn Porter
Danny Garcia
Keith Thurman
Kell Brook
Danny Garcia
Adrien Broner

Thurman
Brook
Porter
Broner
Garcia

Brook
Thurman
Garcia
Porter
Broner

Brook
Thurman
Garcia
Porter
Broner

NateJR wrote:Brook
Thurman
Garcia
Porter
Broner

This for me.

I can't call the Thurman vs Brook fight but this has to be the order.

Brook beat Porter and Porter beat Broner so that sorts out half the pile.
Garcia is a funny one, we'll have to wait till he fights one of those names until we really rank him in WW

1-2 Brook/Thurman hard to call
3 Porter
4 Garcia
5 Broner

Kell Brook
Keith Thurman
Shawn Porter
Danny Garcia
Adrien Broner

Thurman
Brook
Porter
Danny Garcia
Adrien Broner

For now

1. Kell Brook
2. Keith Thurman
3. Danny Garcia
4. Shawn Porter





5. Adrien Broner


Though I'd say if Thurman beats Porter he can possibly become #1.

Kell Brook
Keith Thurman
Danny Garcia
Shawn Porter
Adrien Broner

NateJR wrote:Brook
Thurman
Garcia
Porter
Broner

tigermoth87 wrote:Brook
Thurman
Garcia
Porter
Broner

Tarkus wrote:Kell Brook
Keith Thurman
Danny Garcia
Shawn Porter
Adrien Broner

I agree

Resume wise Garcia is the easy #1.

Brook
Porter
Thurman
Broner

Thurman
Brook
Garcia
Porter
Broner

If you go by whats happened.

Brook or Garcia are the 1 and 2, probably Brook 1.

Porter and Thurman are close 3 and 4s.

Big gap to Broner.

SaadOffTheDeck wrote:Resume wise Garcia is the easy #1.

Brook
Porter
Thurman
Broner

What resume he's only had 2 fights at WW and it took him 9 rounds to be a shot to fcuk Paulie who hadn't fought for over a year when he got destroyed in 4 by Porter.

Larrylefthook wrote:

SaadOffTheDeck wrote:Resume wise Garcia is the easy #1.

Brook
Porter
Thurman
Broner

What resume he's only had 2 fights at WW and it took him 9 rounds to be a shot to fcuk Paulie who hadn't fought for over a year when he got destroyed in 4 by Porter.

Forgive me, I do not have your infrared goggles that came up with strictly Welterweight fights in the question.

SaadOffTheDeck wrote:

Larrylefthook wrote:

SaadOffTheDeck wrote:Resume wise Garcia is the easy #1.

Brook
Porter
Thurman
Broner

What resume he's only had 2 fights at WW and it took him 9 rounds to be a shot to fcuk Paulie who hadn't fought for over a year when he got destroyed in 4 by Porter.

Forgive me, I do not have your infrared goggles that came up with strictly Welterweight fights in the question.

Haha yeh my bad, wouldn't have Danny as clear #1 I think they're fairly close except Broner being clearly bottom of the pack.

Larrylefthook wrote:

SaadOffTheDeck wrote:

Larrylefthook wrote: What resume he's only had 2 fights at WW and it took him 9 rounds to be a shot to fcuk Paulie who hadn't fought for over a year when he got destroyed in 4 by Porter.

Forgive me, I do not have your infrared goggles that came up with strictly Welterweight fights in the question.

Haha yeh my bad, wouldn't have Danny as clear #1 I think they're fairly close except Broner being clearly bottom of the pack.

Really? Matthysse, Peterson, Khan, Paulie, Guerrero, Morales, Judah...

I don't think any of the rest of these come close to that.

SaadOffTheDeck wrote:

Larrylefthook wrote:

SaadOffTheDeck wrote:
Forgive me, I do not have your infrared goggles that came up with strictly Welterweight fights in the question.

Haha yeh my bad, wouldn't have Danny as clear #1 I think they're fairly close except Broner being clearly bottom of the pack.

Really? Matthysse, Peterson, Khan, Paulie, Guerrero, Morales, Judah...

I don't think any of the rest of these come close to that.

I wasn't impressed with the performance in most of those fights. If he was elite he would of walked through Paulie, wouldn't have got out boxed by Peterson in the last 5 rounds and wouldn't have struggled against Herrera.

He's just faced higher caliber. I thought Brook/porter was unimpressive on both sides. Thurman probably has the eye test imo, resume wise, impressed or not, Garcia has this in a landslide.

Resume:
Garcia
Brook
Porter
Thurman
Broner

Current welterweight rank:
Brook
Thurman
Porter
Garcia
Broner

Trying to rate them pound-for-pound is trickier, because Garcia and Broner have come up divisions, which is something I like to give fighters credit for when doing these sort of rankings.

SFW wrote:

DrunkenBoxer wrote:Shawn Porter
Danny Garcia
Keith Thurman
Kell Brook
Danny Garcia
Adrien Broner

Thurman
Brook
Porter
Broner
Garcia

Thurman, Brook, Porter in same make-up. Broner already lost to one of them, didn't he? Garcia...yeah. Idk. I didn't personally like him what-ever [he never done nothing to ME, though..his "team" pretty (vulgar talking, noticed!)]
How CAN you rate these guys. It's like picking straws isn't it??
I like a "sure bet"..pick 1-2-3: RON LYLE, KEN NORTON, ERNIE SHAVERS.
I'll tell YOU if you are a knowledgeable boxing fan for that era.

Boxerbeetle wrote:Thurman
Brook
Garcia
Porter
Broner

I agree with this.

DrunkenBoxer wrote:Shawn Porter
Danny Garcia
Keith Thurman
Kell Brook
Adrien Broner

Thurman
Garcia
Brook
Porter
Broner

No takers 1-2-3 RON LYLE, KEN NORTON, ERNIE SHAVERS?