BoxRec

1. (1.) Tyson Fury
2. (2.) Carl Frampton
3. (3.) James DeGale
4. (4.) Kell Brook
5. (5.) Amir Khan
6. (6.) Lee Selby
7. (7.) Jamie McDonnell
8. (8.) George Groves
9. (9.) Tony Bellew
10. (10.) Billy Joe Saunders

11. (11.) Terry Flanagan
12. (12.) Scott Quigg
13. (13.) Ricky Burns
14. (14.) Anthony Crolla
15. (17.) Callum Smith
16. (19.) Lee Haskins
17. (15.) Martin Murray
18. (16.) Chris Eubank Jr.
19. (18.) Anthony Joshua
20. (20.) Andy Lee (Irish)

21. (27.) Stuart Hall
22. (21.) Ovill McKenzie
23. (22.) Nathan Cleverly
24. (23.) Josh Warrington
25. (24.) Luke Campbell
26. (25.) Tyrone Nurse
27. (26.) Bradley Skeete
28. (28.) Liam Williams
29. (29.) David Haye
30. (30.) Gavin McDonnell

Any comments/criticisms of the British Top 30 P4P list are very welcome.

Tyson Fury shouldn't be in there

davie wrote:Tyson Fury shouldn't be in there

He should be out of the December as he won't have fought for one year.

Nothing I massively disagree with.
Maybe Stephen smith in at 30 instead of Gav McDonnell.

Khan

Should have waited until tonight to see what happens with Cleverly

"The Jackal" is no1

Murray too low. Are you punishing him for losing fights?

Fury and Khan too high.
Fury hasn't boxed for 11 months and won't be boxing for a long time.
Khan hasn't won a world title fight for 63 months and rarely goes in a boxing gym.

Frampton should be top of the list. Hall moving up 6 places after a defeat is strange but overall a decent list.

Deno1986 wrote:Frampton should be top of the list. Hall moving up 6 places after a defeat is strange but overall a decent list.

This

davie wrote:Tyson Fury shouldn't be in there

I think that he should.

Naandrew wrote:He should be out of the December as he won't have fought for one year.

I don't take fighters out of the rankings for being inactive for a year.

Horse wrote:

Naandrew wrote:He should be out of the December as he won't have fought for one year.

I don't take fighters out of the rankings for being inactive for a year.

Why update it every month then?

Khan is too high. Frampton should be number 1.

Naandrew wrote:Nothing I massively disagree with.
Maybe Stephen smith in at 30 instead of Gav McDonnell.

Stephen Smith did respectably against Pedraza, so he is close to a place in the rankings.

If he beats someone decent this month then he might enter next month's list.

DannyMCR wrote:Khan

Should have waited until tonight to see what happens with Cleverly

Fights from October can't change October's rankings.

Keko wrote:"The Jackal" is no1

If he wins his next fight then he will probably move up to No. 1.

Horse wrote:

DannyMCR wrote:Khan

Should have waited until tonight to see what happens with Cleverly

Fights from October can't change October's rankings.

Okay boss

BigDoofus wrote:Fury and Khan too high.
Fury hasn't boxed for 11 months and won't be boxing for a long time.
Khan hasn't won a world title fight for 63 months and rarely goes in a boxing gym.

Fury's the heavyweight champion. He belongs at No. 1 for now.

If the fighters below Khan were being more active then he would have fallen quite a few places already.

DannyMCR wrote:

Horse wrote:

DannyMCR wrote:Khan

Should have waited until tonight to see what happens with Cleverly

Fights from October can't change October's rankings.

Okay boss

BigDoofus wrote: Khan rarely goes in a boxing gym.

How do you know,out of interest?

Deno1986 wrote:Frampton should be top of the list. Hall moving up 6 places after a defeat is strange but overall a decent list.

Hall vs Haskins was a very close fight and a lot of people scored it for Hall. I thought that the gap between them should close rather than widen afterwards.

DannyMCR wrote:

Horse wrote:I don't take fighters out of the rankings for being inactive for a year.

Why update it every month then?

What leap of logic took place in your mind to think that that question was any sort of a reasonable response to what I wrote?

Counter-puncher wrote:

BigDoofus wrote: Khan rarely goes in a boxing gym.

How do you know,out of interest?

His trainer said he needs to spend time in the gym - not just when he has a fight announced.