BoxRec

Should JC be inducted in to the Hall of Fame?

Yes or No?

THE COUNT:

YES (2 members)
Fist of legend
BoxBuzz



NO (6 members)
Kevo
Gilgamesh
Techno89
Crease
Armageto
HyacinthusTurnipseed

Juan Carlos Gomez:

Accolades:
Was ranked The Number One for 19 consecutive weeks (week 8-26)
Finished 2nd place in The Super Six.
The only man to defeat RJJ in the Super Six.
Held all four World titles.
Joint most wins this season (31 victories)
Achieved a 24-fight win streak.


Belts:
x3 time WBO World Champion: (weeks 10, 21, 37)
x2 time WBC World Champion: (weeks 8, 37)
x2 time IBF World Champion: (weeks 26, 37)
x1 time WBA World Champion: (week 37)
x2 time Lonsdale Champion: (weeks 26, 37)


- Never ranked low enough to contest the minor titles which is undoubtedly a further testament to Gomez's legacy.

An excellent fighter, but not HoF worthy for me.

No

No Record, No Hall.

Hard to say without his record.
I'm saying NO

For exactly the same reason that I gave Joe Calzaghe, I can't vote Gomez in;

Crease wrote:We at Don Krease Productions always prefer to vote 1 fighter in to the HOF per season, it makes the Hall all the more difficult to get in to.
With that said, we are looking at RJJ & Evander as the top 2 candidates...

NO from me.

I'll say no due to lack of record.

armageto wrote:I'll say no due to lack of record.

It's a problem, definitely a problem...

From what I've gathered from his fights with guys whose records are there he has had a good season. Saying that, really the only difference between his season and Ward's is that JCG was luckier with the judges and didn't fight Holyfield, Calzaghe and RJJ as many times. So it was a good season, but not a HOF season AFAIC.

There were 10 Managers last season.

6 of us have now voted NO - so even if the rest vote otherwise, the majority rules - so Mr Gomez will not be entering The Hall on this occasion.

wow, not even one yes vote, Gomez won more championships than anybody and beat Holyfield and Roy Jones Jr.

I vote yes....Which should more than make up for the naysayers.

The vote is now closed

The majority vote NO

This thread will now be locked.