BoxRec

I was wondering, can you remember cases where a rematch had the same, exact result as the first bout?

Here are a few cases:
Sonny Liston KO1 Floyd Patterson
Carlos Monzon W15 Rodrigo Valdes
Carlos Ortiz KO14 Gabriel Elorde
Alexis Arguello KO13 Alfredo Escalera
Vinny Paz W12 Roberto Duran
Hector Camacho W12 Roberto Duran
Colin Jones KO9 Kirkland Laing
Ken Buchanan W15 Ismael Laguna
Hugo Corro W15 Rodrigo Valdes
Carmen Basilio KO12 Tony DeMarco
Carl Olson KO4 Wayne Powell
Gene Tunney W10 Jack Dempsey
Ivan Robinson W10 Arturo Gatti

Bowe/Golotta I and II.

oogiebe wrote: ↑10 Dec 2019, 19:59 Bowe/Golotta I and II.

Almost!!

Floyd Mayweather UD 12 Jose Luis Castillo
Vernon Forrest UD 12 Shane Mosley
Orzubek Nazarov UD 12 Dingaan Thobela
Paulie Ayala UD 12 Johnny Tapia
Gianfranco Rosi SD 12 Gilbert Dele
Chad Dawson UD 12 Antonio Tarver
In Joo Cho SD 12 Gerry Penalosa Volodymyr Sidorenko Draw 12 Ricardo Cordoba

Craig Evans and Tom Stalker fought to split draws in their first 2 fights, and then Evans won the 3rd fight by majority decision

Woldemar wrote: ↑11 Dec 2019, 01:59 Floyd Mayweather UD 12 Jose Luis Castillo
Vernon Forrest UD 12 Shane Mosley
Orzubek Nazarov UD 12 Dingaan Thobela
Paulie Ayala UD 12 Johnny Tapia
Gianfranco Rosi SD 12 Gilbert Dele
Chad Dawson UD 12 Antonio Tarver
In Joo Cho SD 12 Gerry Penalosa Volodymyr Sidorenko Draw 12 Ricardo Cordoba

margaret thatcher wrote: ↑11 Dec 2019, 02:02 Craig Evans and Tom Stalker fought to split draws in their first 2 fights, and then Evans won the 3rd fight by majority decision

Winky Wright W12 Shane Mosley

Jorge Fernando Castro SD 12 Reggie Johnson

There are probably scores of fights where the same guy won the decision over the same amount of rounds. Not that many where the KO was in the same round though.

Guty Espadas KO 13 Alfonso Lopez
Sugar Ray Robinson KO 1 George 'Sugar' Costner

scartissue wrote: ↑11 Dec 2019, 12:50 Guty Espadas KO 13 Alfonso Lopez
Sugar Ray Robinson KO 1 George 'Sugar' Costner

Damn yeah lol!

Ambling Alp II wrote: ↑11 Dec 2019, 12:23 There are probably scores of fights where the same guy won the decision over the same amount of rounds. Not that many where the KO was in the same round though.

Very true!!!

Woldemar wrote: ↑11 Dec 2019, 08:21 Jorge Fernando Castro SD 12 Reggie Johnson

Ohh yeah!

Romeo Anaya KO3 Enrique Pinder

Joe Louis W10 Cesar Brion

Gerald McClellan WKO1 Julian Jackson.

Something like that.

elmersalsa wrote: ↑12 Dec 2019, 07:08 Gerald McClellan WKO1 Julian Jackson.

Something like that.

McClellan stop Jackson one time in 5R ,one time in 1R

Saemi Hanagata split draw Nao Ikeyama in their first 2 fights (had 1 round swung in their third bout we could have had 3 split draws)

Boxing Prospect wrote: ↑13 Dec 2019, 15:48 Saemi Hanagata split draw Nao Ikeyama in their first 2 fights (had 1 round swung in their third bout we could have had 3 split draws)

Wow that's crazy!

Leroy Haley W12 Saoul Mamby
Bruce Curry W12 Leroy Haley

Back in the old days, there must have been thousands (literally!) of these cases.

Vince Dundee D6 Charles Barber
Vince Dundee W PTS 8 Tony Cortez
Vince Dundee L PTS 10 Jackie Fields
Vince Dundee D 10 Abie Bain
Vince Dundee W PTS 10 Young Ketchell
Vince Dundee W PTS 10 Ben Jeby
Vince Dundee W PTS 12 Len Harvey
Vince Dundee L PTS 10 Teddy Yarosz

That's just one former world champion. I can't even imagine the numbers we would get, if we took a close look at guys like Greb, Dillon, Levinsky, Rosenbloom, Britton, etc.