Heavyweights: Primo Carnera versus Nikolai Valuev...battle of the giants!!

[AntonioMartin]

Who, how and why? (why would it happen being an obvious question even to myself, but I will answer that: it would be a HUGE fight!!)

[AngryGoon38]

I'd have to favor Valuev. He wasn't particularly good,especially for his size,but he'd have half a foot of height on Primo. I think that type of leverage would enable Valuev to prevail. Plus he had an iron jaw and skull of steel.
Valuev by fairly narrow but clear cut UD.

[DrDuke]

Carnera had a better jab, which would be enough to deal with slower Valuev.

[scorpio83]

Between the two, Carnera would have more speed than Valuev, but Valuev would out-jab and out-punch the Ampling Alp for a decision win.

[Tony1244]

Carnera by decision with the jab.

It would be so slow people would think they're looking at a photograph.

[Crease]

Carnera was 6'6 - a big man... But hardly super, super big...
Valuev is over 7 feet....
Valuev wins by stoppage

[BoxBuzz]

If it was in the early part of Primo's Career I'm sure Carnera's management would intervene on his behalf.

[AntonioMartin]

If it was in the early part of Primo's Career I'm sure Carnera's management would intervene on his behalf.

good one!!

[emallini]

Valuev was better than him.

[Ambling Alp II]

That would no. As in hell no.

[BoxBuzz]

That would no. As in hell no.

Alp, you just disagreed with someone who has clearly stated that he knows the ropes. And is accurate on all levels.

Now what? I mean you both can't be right.