Page 1 of 2

Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 16 Jun 2023, 16:18
by Controversial
Any good examples where a fight ends in a really close points win (or draw) but the rematch ends in a quick KO?

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 16 Jun 2023, 16:23
by Mangoraj
Holyfield vs Qawi 1 was a very close fight going the distance but the second fight was a completely different story with qawi getting knocked out in the 4th

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 16 Jun 2023, 19:10
by jaouad
Every loss that Hagler had avenged .

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 16 Jun 2023, 19:40
by Ambling Alp II
Saad Muhammad-Conteh
Marciano-Walcott
Moore-Durelle

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 16 Jun 2023, 21:07
by HomicideHenry
Virtually every rematch Joe Louis had.

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 16 Jun 2023, 22:22
by oogiebe
HomicideHenry wrote: 16 Jun 2023, 21:07 Virtually every rematch Joe Louis had.
:OhYes:

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 17 Jun 2023, 01:39
by Sweet Dick Willie
Inoue - Donaire

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 17 Jun 2023, 01:55
by margaret thatcher
virgil hill-fabrice tiozzo

on the strength of 2 early kds hill wins a close first fight on split decision, then drops him 3 times in the 1st in their rematch 7 years later for a 1 round blowout. hill not a puncher but seemed to have a knack for hurting tiozzo in particular

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 17 Jun 2023, 03:01
by Controversial
margaret thatcher wrote: 17 Jun 2023, 01:55 virgil hill-fabrice tiozzo

on the strength of 2 early kds hill wins a close first fight on split decision, then drops him 3 times in the 1st in their rematch 7 years later for a 1 round blowout. hill not a puncher but seemed to have a knack for hurting tiozzo in particular
Good shout

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 17 Jun 2023, 06:31
by wouter
Orlin Norris vs. Arthur Williams

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 17 Jun 2023, 08:03
by tiny_acres
Jones vs Tarver
A close fight in the first that many thought Tarver won. The rematch was all Tarver.

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 17 Jun 2023, 12:28
by AngryGoon38
RJJ rematch versus Montell Griffith.
Mayweather Jr versus Castillo
SR Robinson versus Gene Fulmer

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 17 Jun 2023, 22:44
by oogiebe
AngryGoon38 wrote: 17 Jun 2023, 12:28 RJJ rematch versus Montell Griffith.
Mayweather Jr versus Castillo
SR Robinson versus Gene Fulmer
Was RJJ/Griffith I really close?

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 18 Jun 2023, 04:44
by wouter
oogiebe wrote: 17 Jun 2023, 22:44 Was RJJ/Griffith I really close?
Yes it was, many had Griffith ahead on points.

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 18 Jun 2023, 06:42
by margaret thatcher
one of the judges had griffin up and another only had hiim down by a point

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 18 Jun 2023, 06:49
by wouter
wouter wrote: 18 Jun 2023, 04:44
oogiebe wrote: 17 Jun 2023, 22:44 Was RJJ/Griffith I really close?
Yes it was, many had Griffith ahead on points.
I see that I went along with Griffith here, the correct name is of course Griffin. What made it close was that Jones was credited with a knockdown in an earlier round that was really a slip. Otherwise Griffin seemed to handle him pretty well and Jones couldn't do much with him.

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 18 Jun 2023, 10:39
by oogiebe
wouter wrote: 18 Jun 2023, 06:49
wouter wrote: 18 Jun 2023, 04:44
oogiebe wrote: 17 Jun 2023, 22:44 Was RJJ/Griffith I really close?
Yes it was, many had Griffith ahead on points.
I see that I went along with Griffith here, the correct name is of course Griffin. What made it close was that Jones was credited with a knockdown in an earlier round that was really a slip. Otherwise Griffin seemed to handle him pretty well and Jones couldn't do much with him.
It's funny I don't remember it being close, just the crazy ending.

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 18 Jun 2023, 10:47
by bwu
Michael Dokes v. Ossie Ocasio

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 18 Jun 2023, 11:13
by Controversial
bwu wrote: 18 Jun 2023, 10:47 Michael Dokes v. Ossie Ocasio
Good one

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 18 Jun 2023, 19:00
by Ambling Alp II
HomicideHenry wrote: 16 Jun 2023, 21:07 Virtually every rematch Joe Louis had.
I don't think there is one time that it really happened. The first fight with Buddy Baer was close for about 7 rounds. When else was the first fight close and the rematch ended early?

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 18 Jun 2023, 19:09
by oogiebe
Ambling Alp II wrote: 18 Jun 2023, 19:00
HomicideHenry wrote: 16 Jun 2023, 21:07 Virtually every rematch Joe Louis had.
I don't think there is one time that it really happened. The first fight with Buddy Baer was close for about 7 rounds. When else was the first fight close and the rematch ended early?
More like ended 'earlier' or stoppage after loss or decision I'd say for Louis
conn
Schmeling
Godoy
Walcott
etc.

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 18 Jun 2023, 21:04
by HomicideHenry
oogiebe wrote: 18 Jun 2023, 19:09
Ambling Alp II wrote: 18 Jun 2023, 19:00
HomicideHenry wrote: 16 Jun 2023, 21:07 Virtually every rematch Joe Louis had.
I don't think there is one time that it really happened. The first fight with Buddy Baer was close for about 7 rounds. When else was the first fight close and the rematch ended early?
More like ended 'earlier' or stoppage after loss or decision I'd say for Louis
conn
Schmeling
Godoy
Walcott
etc.
That's what I meant.

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 19 Jun 2023, 00:20
by Redback Rasta
Holyfield-Moorer is the closest to the criteria - not already mentioned - I can come up with.

Moorer won the first fight narrowly by majority decision. The rematch did last 8 rounds but Moorer was down 5 times along the way.

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 19 Jun 2023, 11:36
by Jaywheel
Hilton-Ouellet
Williams-Martinez

Re: Rematches that ended early after close first fight

Posted: 19 Jun 2023, 12:17
by bwu
Ben Villaflor-Kuniaki Shibata