James Toney vs Dick Tiger

[Nile4000]

15/160, who wins?

[goose 5]

Toney from the first McCallum bout wins a decision.

[scorpio83]

This would be a war, but Toney would outcounter Tiger with better jabs and combinations on the outside and inside to take a decision in a close fight.

[elmersalsa]

X3

[gilgamesh]

At 160 I'm taking Tiger. Toney was never at his best at 160 pounds because he struggled too much to make weight there. Tiger was a strong, tough Middleweight who was going to force a pace that Toney wouldn't be able to match.

Toney would land several clean counter punches, but would generally be outworked, and Tiger would get a lot of the close rounds by being the man who appears to be making the fight.

Tiger by UD.