President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

IRONFIST
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 6496
Joined: 12 Jul 2005, 09:25

President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by IRONFIST »

:salut:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm93rpy6lx0do

No jokes about the judge's surname. please.. :lol:
gilgamesh
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 48164
Joined: 02 Sep 2010, 16:21

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by gilgamesh »

Gonna be one hell of an uphill battle to prove defamation when you're on camera saying the exact thing you're claiming you didn't say :lol:
IRONFIST
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 6496
Joined: 12 Jul 2005, 09:25

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by IRONFIST »

gilgamesh wrote: ↑11 Nov 2026, 06:17 Gonna be one hell of an uphill battle to prove defamation when you're on camera saying the exact thing you're claiming you didn't say :lol:
Not really when the BBC themselves have admitted and apologised that they spliced together two parts of the speech from different points which made their two top executives have to quit, The publiclity alone should bring down the chairman :yay:
bmw hector
Light Flyweight
Posts: 1110
Joined: 24 Jul 2025, 16:33

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by bmw hector »

Great! The big p3do will then get dragged up to testify under oath, and he'll drag the rest of his crime family into it as well :yay:
Booster McCrane
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 18121
Joined: 29 Dec 2004, 23:34

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by Booster McCrane »

IronTwat always preoccupied about minor things that won't have any effect on his life instead of real issues like inflation and cost of living that Trump has hoisted onto everyone in the world. :brick:
Nightmare Roy
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 17463
Joined: 18 May 2003, 17:29

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by Nightmare Roy »

Booster McCrane wrote: ↑11 Nov 2026, 13:55 IronTwat always preoccupied about minor things that won't have any effect on his life instead of real issues like inflation and cost of living that Trump has hoisted onto everyone in the world. :brick:
He likes socking it to the left and the left have kicked the living fcuk out of the right in the last week so I guess he sees it as a small victory. It isn't.
IRONFIST
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 6496
Joined: 12 Jul 2005, 09:25

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by IRONFIST »

Booster McCrane wrote: ↑11 Nov 2026, 13:55 IronTwat always preoccupied about minor things that won't have any effect on his life instead of real issues like inflation and cost of living that Trump has hoisted onto everyone in the world. :brick:
Funny how you never mention this Liebour government then with virtually the highest utility bills in the world etc.

This case is important, it's about holding news organisations to account when they deliberately distort the truth...
Nightmare Roy
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 17463
Joined: 18 May 2003, 17:29

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by Nightmare Roy »

IRONFIST wrote: ↑12 Nov 2026, 07:57
Booster McCrane wrote: ↑11 Nov 2026, 13:55 IronTwat always preoccupied about minor things that won't have any effect on his life instead of real issues like inflation and cost of living that Trump has hoisted onto everyone in the world. :brick:
Funny how you never mention this Liebour government then with virtually the highest utility bills in the world etc.

This case is important, it's about holding news organisations to account when they deliberately distort the truth...
Bro watches Fox ans GB news! :lol:
giacomino
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 15991
Joined: 14 Dec 2007, 19:33

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by giacomino »

IRONFIST wrote: ↑12 Nov 2026, 07:57
Booster McCrane wrote: ↑11 Nov 2026, 13:55 IronTwat always preoccupied about minor things that won't have any effect on his life instead of real issues like inflation and cost of living that Trump has hoisted onto everyone in the world. :brick:
Funny how you never mention this Liebour government then with virtually the highest utility bills in the world etc.

This case is important, it's about holding news organisations to account when they deliberately distort the truth...
It’s not about “the truth.” Never has been.

BBC were shoddy to piece together clips from his speech, largely because they didn’t need to do so to tell their story. Trump poured gasoline and lit the match for the Jan. 6 riot/attack/tourist visit, whatever you want to call it. That is “the truth” Even Fox News reporters on the scene would agree to that.

Trumpy is merely trying to point to bad journalistic editing to “prove” he had nothing to do with Jan. 6. In the end the suit will go nowhere because Trumpy can’t prove that either 1) He was harmed financially, since he made more last year than he has in any single year in his life 2) It was factually inaccurate that he was involved in Jan. 6 AND that BBC knowingly libeled him.(that is the legal language of defamation lawsuits in the US)
jamesmcdonnell
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 45333
Joined: 12 Nov 2003, 06:11

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by jamesmcdonnell »

giacomino wrote: ↑12 Nov 2026, 12:37
IRONFIST wrote: ↑12 Nov 2026, 07:57
Booster McCrane wrote: ↑11 Nov 2026, 13:55 IronTwat always preoccupied about minor things that won't have any effect on his life instead of real issues like inflation and cost of living that Trump has hoisted onto everyone in the world. :brick:
Funny how you never mention this Liebour government then with virtually the highest utility bills in the world etc.

This case is important, it's about holding news organisations to account when they deliberately distort the truth...
It’s not about “the truth.” Never has been.

BBC were shoddy to piece together clips from his speech, largely because they didn’t need to do so to tell their story. Trump poured gasoline and lit the match for the Jan. 6 riot/attack/tourist visit, whatever you want to call it. That is “the truth” Even Fox News reporters on the scene would agree to that.

Trumpy is merely trying to point to bad journalistic editing to “prove” he had nothing to do with Jan. 6. In the end the suit will go nowhere because Trumpy can’t prove that either 1) He was harmed financially, since he made more last year than he has in any single year in his life 2) It was factually inaccurate that he was involved in Jan. 6 AND that BBC knowingly libeled him.(that is the legal language of defamation lawsuits in the US)
What they did was foolish, but it doesn't change the facts of what Trump did in the slightest.

I am surprised the judge allowed the case to be brought, it has zero chance of success. Trump knows this himself.

He will have zero interest in getting involved as he's already shown by refusing to participate in discovery, which would reveal his actions on the day in great detail.
IRONFIST
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 6496
Joined: 12 Jul 2005, 09:25

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by IRONFIST »

jamesmcdonnell wrote: ↑12 Nov 2026, 15:00
giacomino wrote: ↑12 Nov 2026, 12:37
IRONFIST wrote: ↑12 Nov 2026, 07:57

Funny how you never mention this Liebour government then with virtually the highest utility bills in the world etc.

This case is important, it's about holding news organisations to account when they deliberately distort the truth...
It’s not about “the truth.” Never has been.

BBC were shoddy to piece together clips from his speech, largely because they didn’t need to do so to tell their story. Trump poured gasoline and lit the match for the Jan. 6 riot/attack/tourist visit, whatever you want to call it. That is “the truth” Even Fox News reporters on the scene would agree to that.

Trumpy is merely trying to point to bad journalistic editing to “prove” he had nothing to do with Jan. 6. In the end the suit will go nowhere because Trumpy can’t prove that either 1) He was harmed financially, since he made more last year than he has in any single year in his life 2) It was factually inaccurate that he was involved in Jan. 6 AND that BBC knowingly libeled him.(that is the legal language of defamation lawsuits in the US)
What they did was foolish, but it doesn't change the facts of what Trump did in the slightest.

I am surprised the judge allowed the case to be brought, it has zero chance of success. Trump knows this himself.

He will have zero interest in getting involved as he's already shown by refusing to participate in discovery, which would reveal his actions on the day in great detail.
What'd you mean zero success, the BBC are already on the record admitting the doctoring of the footage...
jamesmcdonnell
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 45333
Joined: 12 Nov 2003, 06:11

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by jamesmcdonnell »

I've blocked IW ages ago, but I can pretty much guess the tone of his reponse.
SticknMove
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 6119
Joined: 04 Aug 2006, 09:02

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by SticknMove »

jamesmcdonnell wrote: ↑13 Nov 2026, 10:01 I've blocked IW ages ago, but I can pretty much guess the tone of his reponse.
Are you a one man cancellation tool?

Or are there more passive ‘aggressive’ tools like you?

I guess groupthink and ideology will always detach itself from reality.
giacomino
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 15991
Joined: 14 Dec 2007, 19:33

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by giacomino »

IRONFIST wrote: ↑13 Nov 2026, 08:59
jamesmcdonnell wrote: ↑12 Nov 2026, 15:00
giacomino wrote: ↑12 Nov 2026, 12:37
It’s not about “the truth.” Never has been.

BBC were shoddy to piece together clips from his speech, largely because they didn’t need to do so to tell their story. Trump poured gasoline and lit the match for the Jan. 6 riot/attack/tourist visit, whatever you want to call it. That is “the truth” Even Fox News reporters on the scene would agree to that.

Trumpy is merely trying to point to bad journalistic editing to “prove” he had nothing to do with Jan. 6. In the end the suit will go nowhere because Trumpy can’t prove that either 1) He was harmed financially, since he made more last year than he has in any single year in his life 2) It was factually inaccurate that he was involved in Jan. 6 AND that BBC knowingly libeled him.(that is the legal language of defamation lawsuits in the US)
What they did was foolish, but it doesn't change the facts of what Trump did in the slightest.

I am surprised the judge allowed the case to be brought, it has zero chance of success. Trump knows this himself.

He will have zero interest in getting involved as he's already shown by refusing to participate in discovery, which would reveal his actions on the day in great detail.
What'd you mean zero success, the BBC are already on the record admitting the doctoring of the footage...
“Success” in a lawsuit is winning your case and ultimately getting a settlement from the judge/jury. It is proving your case, which in the Us law is proving BBC deliberately knowingly libeled Trump and it caused reputational and financial damage. Since his involvement in Jan. 6 is well-accepted by non-cult, non-tribal members - the majority of Americans, his family made $3 billion last year - more than ever before - few if any Americans saw the program (standing to sue), and he is unwilling to allow discovery in the case, he has zero chance of “success.” BBC made a silly mistake and should apologize, but the premise of their piece wasn’t wrong and Trumpy will spend millions losing in court, again. Hopefully US taxpayers aren’t paying his legal bills.
jamesmcdonnell
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 45333
Joined: 12 Nov 2003, 06:11

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by jamesmcdonnell »

giacomino wrote: ↑15 Nov 2026, 05:01
IRONFIST wrote: ↑13 Nov 2026, 08:59
jamesmcdonnell wrote: ↑12 Nov 2026, 15:00

What they did was foolish, but it doesn't change the facts of what Trump did in the slightest.

I am surprised the judge allowed the case to be brought, it has zero chance of success. Trump knows this himself.

He will have zero interest in getting involved as he's already shown by refusing to participate in discovery, which would reveal his actions on the day in great detail.
What'd you mean zero success, the BBC are already on the record admitting the doctoring of the footage...
“Success” in a lawsuit is winning your case and ultimately getting a settlement from the judge/jury. It is proving your case, which in the Us law is proving BBC deliberately knowingly libeled Trump and it caused reputational and financial damage. Since his involvement in Jan. 6 is well-accepted by non-cult, non-tribal members - the majority of Americans, his family made $3 billion last year - more than ever before - few if any Americans saw the program (standing to sue), and he is unwilling to allow discovery in the case, he has zero chance of “success.” BBC made a silly mistake and should apologize, but the premise of their piece wasn’t wrong and Trumpy will spend millions losing in court, again. Hopefully US taxpayers aren’t paying his legal bills.
You can be sure Trump will do everything possible to make sure he doesn't pay it
IRONFIST
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 6496
Joined: 12 Jul 2005, 09:25

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by IRONFIST »

giacomino wrote: ↑15 Nov 2026, 05:01
IRONFIST wrote: ↑13 Nov 2026, 08:59
jamesmcdonnell wrote: ↑12 Nov 2026, 15:00

What they did was foolish, but it doesn't change the facts of what Trump did in the slightest.

I am surprised the judge allowed the case to be brought, it has zero chance of success. Trump knows this himself.

He will have zero interest in getting involved as he's already shown by refusing to participate in discovery, which would reveal his actions on the day in great detail.
What'd you mean zero success, the BBC are already on the record admitting the doctoring of the footage...
“Success” in a lawsuit is winning your case and ultimately getting a settlement from the judge/jury. It is proving your case, which in the Us law is proving BBC deliberately knowingly libeled Trump and it caused reputational and financial damage. Since his involvement in Jan. 6 is well-accepted by non-cult, non-tribal members - the majority of Americans, his family made $3 billion last year - more than ever before - few if any Americans saw the program (standing to sue), and he is unwilling to allow discovery in the case, he has zero chance of “success.” BBC made a silly mistake and should apologize, but the premise of their piece wasn’t wrong and Trumpy will spend millions losing in court, again. Hopefully US taxpayers aren’t paying his legal bills.
The BBC did not make a "silly mistake" it was deliberate, this is not some amateur outfit, it's the BBC and they did it twice, once on Newsnight also...
Nightmare Roy
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 17463
Joined: 18 May 2003, 17:29

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by Nightmare Roy »

If you are a know liar with a proven bad character, can you even be defamed? Serious question.
greg
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 5479
Joined: 23 Mar 2007, 07:44

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by greg »

Nightmare Roy wrote: ↑16 Nov 2026, 12:06 If you are a know liar with a proven bad character, can you even be defamed? Serious question.
Donald Trump is a convicted felon with 34 felony counts, civil liability for sexual abuse and defamation, fraud findings, ongoing lawsuits, and 30,573 documented false or misleading claims. Calling him a liar with a bad character is the understatement of the century. :KO:
giacomino
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 15991
Joined: 14 Dec 2007, 19:33

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by giacomino »

IRONFIST wrote: ↑16 Nov 2026, 09:12
giacomino wrote: ↑15 Nov 2026, 05:01
IRONFIST wrote: ↑13 Nov 2026, 08:59

What'd you mean zero success, the BBC are already on the record admitting the doctoring of the footage...
“Success” in a lawsuit is winning your case and ultimately getting a settlement from the judge/jury. It is proving your case, which in the Us law is proving BBC deliberately knowingly libeled Trump and it caused reputational and financial damage. Since his involvement in Jan. 6 is well-accepted by non-cult, non-tribal members - the majority of Americans, his family made $3 billion last year - more than ever before - few if any Americans saw the program (standing to sue), and he is unwilling to allow discovery in the case, he has zero chance of “success.” BBC made a silly mistake and should apologize, but the premise of their piece wasn’t wrong and Trumpy will spend millions losing in court, again. Hopefully US taxpayers aren’t paying his legal bills.
The BBC did not make a "silly mistake" it was deliberate, this is not some amateur outfit, it's the BBC and they did it twice, once on Newsnight also...
Ok, you say it was deliberate. It’s still edit splicing that backs up the facts, which is that Trump created the environment that led to a storming of the Capitol. I thought it was a stupid (and wrong) thing to do since there was mounds of evidence to make the case,, but it in no way had any impact on Trump’s reputación or finances, which he must prove in a US libel case. Would you be as dickhurt if it had been Labor (sorry for the American spelling) inciting crazy lefties to storm Parliament?
giacomino
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 15991
Joined: 14 Dec 2007, 19:33

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by giacomino »

Nightmare Roy wrote: ↑16 Nov 2026, 12:06 If you are a know liar with a proven bad character, can you even be defamed? Serious question.
That would be an interesting test in US courts. The fact that he is a pathological liar might be brought up in this case if it ever went to trial, which it won’t
IRONFIST
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 6496
Joined: 12 Jul 2005, 09:25

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by IRONFIST »

giacomino wrote: ↑16 Nov 2026, 13:54
IRONFIST wrote: ↑16 Nov 2026, 09:12
giacomino wrote: ↑15 Nov 2026, 05:01
“Success” in a lawsuit is winning your case and ultimately getting a settlement from the judge/jury. It is proving your case, which in the Us law is proving BBC deliberately knowingly libeled Trump and it caused reputational and financial damage. Since his involvement in Jan. 6 is well-accepted by non-cult, non-tribal members - the majority of Americans, his family made $3 billion last year - more than ever before - few if any Americans saw the program (standing to sue), and he is unwilling to allow discovery in the case, he has zero chance of “success.” BBC made a silly mistake and should apologize, but the premise of their piece wasn’t wrong and Trumpy will spend millions losing in court, again. Hopefully US taxpayers aren’t paying his legal bills.
The BBC did not make a "silly mistake" it was deliberate, this is not some amateur outfit, it's the BBC and they did it twice, once on Newsnight also...
Ok, you say it was deliberate. It’s still edit splicing that backs up the facts, which is that Trump created the environment that led to a storming of the Capitol. I thought it was a stupid (and wrong) thing to do since there was mounds of evidence to make the case,, but it in no way had any impact on Trump’s reputación or finances, which he must prove in a US libel case. Would you be as dickhurt if it had been Labor (sorry for the American spelling) inciting crazy lefties to storm Parliament?
Doesn't back up anything except the BBC lies, edited to make it seem that he incited violence when he did no such thing in that speech.
Nightmare Roy
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 17463
Joined: 18 May 2003, 17:29

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by Nightmare Roy »

IRONFIST wrote: ↑17 Nov 2026, 06:18
giacomino wrote: ↑16 Nov 2026, 13:54
IRONFIST wrote: ↑16 Nov 2026, 09:12

The BBC did not make a "silly mistake" it was deliberate, this is not some amateur outfit, it's the BBC and they did it twice, once on Newsnight also...
Ok, you say it was deliberate. It’s still edit splicing that backs up the facts, which is that Trump created the environment that led to a storming of the Capitol. I thought it was a stupid (and wrong) thing to do since there was mounds of evidence to make the case,, but it in no way had any impact on Trump’s reputación or finances, which he must prove in a US libel case. Would you be as dickhurt if it had been Labor (sorry for the American spelling) inciting crazy lefties to storm Parliament?
Doesn't back up anything except the BBC lies, edited to make it seem that he incited violence when he did no such thing in that speech.
Does Trump ever lie?
IRONFIST
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 6496
Joined: 12 Jul 2005, 09:25

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by IRONFIST »

Nightmare Roy wrote: ↑17 Nov 2026, 06:20
IRONFIST wrote: ↑17 Nov 2026, 06:18
giacomino wrote: ↑16 Nov 2026, 13:54

Ok, you say it was deliberate. It’s still edit splicing that backs up the facts, which is that Trump created the environment that led to a storming of the Capitol. I thought it was a stupid (and wrong) thing to do since there was mounds of evidence to make the case,, but it in no way had any impact on Trump’s reputación or finances, which he must prove in a US libel case. Would you be as dickhurt if it had been Labor (sorry for the American spelling) inciting crazy lefties to storm Parliament?
Doesn't back up anything except the BBC lies, edited to make it seem that he incited violence when he did no such thing in that speech.
Does Trump ever lie?
Irrelevant to the case and clip in question...
IRONFIST
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 6496
Joined: 12 Jul 2005, 09:25

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by IRONFIST »

Methinks the BBC like the rest of the Fake News will settle out of court, too embarrassing for them to have Newsnight and Panorama whistleblowers etc take to the stand... :OhYes:
hhaehre
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 6578
Joined: 23 Oct 2008, 07:26

Re: President Trump defamation case against BBC allowed by judge

Post by hhaehre »

IRONFIST wrote: ↑17 Nov 2026, 06:18
giacomino wrote: ↑16 Nov 2026, 13:54
IRONFIST wrote: ↑16 Nov 2026, 09:12

The BBC did not make a "silly mistake" it was deliberate, this is not some amateur outfit, it's the BBC and they did it twice, once on Newsnight also...
Ok, you say it was deliberate. It’s still edit splicing that backs up the facts, which is that Trump created the environment that led to a storming of the Capitol. I thought it was a stupid (and wrong) thing to do since there was mounds of evidence to make the case,, but it in no way had any impact on Trump’s reputación or finances, which he must prove in a US libel case. Would you be as dickhurt if it had been Labor (sorry for the American spelling) inciting crazy lefties to storm Parliament?
Doesn't back up anything except the BBC lies, edited to make it seem that he incited violence when he did no such thing in that speech.
He sure did incite violence, or are you saying the insurrection would have happened without Trump? Or maybe you think there was no violent insurrection at all?
Post Reply