Page 1 of 1

Pavlik V Trinidad?!

Posted: 19 Feb 2008, 17:58
by steve689
Yes, according to today's Irish News. If Duddy doesn't impress against Smichet this weekend then the Puerto Rican parades could be exploited for a Pavlik V Trinidad summer showdown. I'm not one bit enthused. How can anyone get excited about recycled names being shovelled out time after time.

Is it me or is Trinidad becoming a world class journeyman? Never thought when he ripped through the Welterweights all those years ago we would see him being used as a top name to pad people's records. It's sad to see :(

Posted: 19 Feb 2008, 18:13
by Goz
Do you not think Tito might have a little bit of a chance there?

He looked quite sharp at times against Jones and it's basically movers/slick guys he has lost to, he won't have to go looking for Pavlik.

I think it could be a thriller to be honest.

Sure Pavlik a favourite but it could be very entertaining....

Posted: 19 Feb 2008, 20:23
by stujones
Pavlik isn't all that, but his size and strength will surely be the factor. I might view Wright vs Trinidad again just to see how many body shots landed. We all know the jab was the key (and Kelly has a similar jab to Wright in terms of it being more than just a range finding) - but both Jones and Hopkins landed body shots that were also telling... did Wright? Relatively speaking, Kelly doesn't do Body shots.

Posted: 20 Feb 2008, 01:04
by Southpaw Stylist
Pav would chin him.

Posted: 20 Feb 2008, 04:55
by Poncey
Trinidad is a better fight than Duddy, whom I can't see going past 6.

Posted: 20 Feb 2008, 05:52
by Autobarn
Pavlik wants to defend his titles, and unify the division after being forced into a catchweight with Taylor.

Papa Trinidad says they can't get down to 160. Arum says the fight HAS to be at middleweight. Bit of a non starter, IMO.

Rather see Pavlik-Duddy. At least Duddy is young & exciting. It will still be a draw. If you can get a very winnable, very lucrative bout, take it.

Anyway, Winky Wright is a far more meaningful fight that Tito. After all, he won every round vs Tito. Wright and Abraham are the only 2 fights for Pavlik to go for after Duddy.

Posted: 20 Feb 2008, 05:56
by Chambers2
Goz wrote:Do you not think Tito might have a little bit of a chance there?
No, not even a molecule of a chance.

I know it's very unlikely to happen now that Calzaghe is at 175 and Pavlik is stopping at 160, but a fight between the 2 would be a cracker IMO

Posted: 20 Feb 2008, 06:12
by Poncey
Autobarn wrote:Pavlik wants to defend his titles, and unify the division after being forced into a catchweight with Taylor.

Papa Trinidad says they can't get down to 160. Arum says the fight HAS to be at middleweight. Bit of a non starter, IMO.

Rather see Pavlik-Duddy. At least Duddy is young & exciting. It will still be a draw. If you can get a very winnable, very lucrative bout, take it.

Anyway, Winky Wright is a far more meaningful fight that Tito. After all, he won every round vs Tito. Wright and Abraham are the only 2 fights for Pavlik to go for after Duddy.
Not convinced Wright would be the logical move, as Taylor drew with him and Pavlik beat Taylor, but somehow I think this would be a good fight.

I've read that Wright may not be able to get back down to 160 due to his Kripsy Kreme addictions (no, I@m not joking). Personally, I see absolutely no merit in Duddy facing Pavlik. He's done nothing to deserve a shot.

Pavlik v Abraham is a fight I'd go and see.

Posted: 20 Feb 2008, 07:03
by Autobarn
There's plenty for Taylor at 168. I think more ppl are willing to give him a pass due to him being weight weakened at 160 (though Pavlik and Miranda clearly were as well, and Allan Green when he moved down for the Miranda catchweight). A fight with Allan Green would be a good start.

I think Wright will go down to fight Pavlik. Wright was obsessed with going back down to 154 for DLH not long ago. With Pavlik pehraps close to becoming a very big star, well, this is WW's chance right now. Wright AND Pavlik would struggle to get down to 160 now.

I think Pavlik needs to try and get Abraham. Unification, etc. But if he can't, then Wright would be the fight IMO, the big fight at middleweight. Before Pavlik moves up. Kelly has limited time to enjoy his titles and so needs to make the important fights ASAP.

I hope WW's ego has been dented a bit. He got too big for his boots, became VERY unappealing, and looked silly up at 175-lbs.

Posted: 20 Feb 2008, 07:10
by Shirow
I can't see this happening at all for 3 reasons.


Papa Trinidad doesn't want his boy getting down to within a stone of his best fighting weight.

Bob Arum insists that this fight must be for the titles but...

A quick scan of Tito's record tells me that he has a 50/50 win/loss record at middleweight and his one impressive perfomance at MW was against Joppy 7 years ago (Mayorga doesn't count as a MW).

Posted: 20 Feb 2008, 07:36
by steve689
Goz wrote:He looked quite sharp at times against Jones and it's basically movers/slick guys he has lost to, he won't have to go looking for Pavlik.
Missed that bit Goz, must have sneezed mate :D :TU:

Posted: 20 Feb 2008, 07:37
by jamesmcdonnell
Precisely, Pavlik would batter him from pillar to post

Tito is finished, and has been for some time.

Posted: 20 Feb 2008, 07:41
by Goz
I'll have a £500 'lirva' bet with any of you that Tito wins! :lol:

Posted: 20 Feb 2008, 07:47
by MightyWarrior
Tito will end up with brain damage if they keep matching him up like this, with Don King grinning all the way to the bank.


Had to laugh at a serious faced Steve Bunce last weekend, breathlessly telling everyone that Bob Arum had said Pavlik was maybe better than Hagler, Monzon etc - like Bob's word is gospel. The same Arum who called Nigel Benn an English version of Marvin Hagler.

Posted: 20 Feb 2008, 07:49
by Poncey
MightyWarrior wrote:The same Arum who called Nigel Benn an English version of Marvin Hagler.
You mean he isn't? :o

Next you'll be telling me Margarito isn't the most avoided fighter on the planet.

Posted: 20 Feb 2008, 08:29
by MightyWarrior
Goz wrote:I'll have a £500 'lirva' bet with any of you that Tito wins! :lol:
:TU: I know what you mean about Tito, you'd think he'd have a outside puncher's chance at 160 against a fair few, but it's a remote chance against Pavlik - who looks to have a very solid chin.

Surviving Miranda he must have.

Plus I think Taylor caught him with some almighty punches in their first fight, to put him in trouble, and a few were round the back of his head, then he goes and sticks his chin out and allows Taylor a free shot...

Taylor found out pretty quickly on Sat night that it was a bit of a fluke, as he came out trying to take Pavlik's head off again in the first, but changed his mind after about 2 mins, as a crunching left and right from KP turned Taylor's tactics to safetly first after that.

Pavlik is due an easy defence after the hard run of fights he's had though, and I suppose a colourful fight with Duddy fits the bill prefectly.

The real fight at 160 is with "top contender" Abrahams though. I think AA's chin is good enough to stand up to Pavlik's bombs, and it'd be a helluva fight. Plus the German's might just be confident enough to make it.

Posted: 20 Feb 2008, 10:10
by Chambers2
Goz wrote:I'll have a £500 'lirva' bet with any of you that Tito wins! :lol:
I'll even give you 10/1 (on our 'lirva' bet)

Posted: 20 Feb 2008, 11:09
by steve689
MightyWarrior wrote:The real fight at 160 is with "top contender" Abrahams though. I think AA's chin is good enough to stand up to Pavlik's bombs, and it'd be a helluva fight. Plus the German's might just be confident enough to make it.
Abraham's good enough to win that one ,although whether he will is another matter.

Posted: 20 Feb 2008, 11:21
by Asterix
stujones wrote:Pavlik isn't all that, but his size and strength will surely be the factor. I might view Wright vs Trinidad again just to see how many body shots landed. We all know the jab was the key (and Kelly has a similar jab to Wright in terms of it being more than just a range finding) - but both Jones and Hopkins landed body shots that were also telling... did Wright? Relatively speaking, Kelly doesn't do Body shots.
In the Taylor rematch it was actually the body shots that hurt Taylor in the 11th round.
Unless Pavlik improves technically he's going to be outboxed at some point in his career (like Taylor could have if he had stamina). But Pavlik is a special fighter. He's obviously very intelligent (if you watch his analysis on FNF and his interviews) and is physically gifted.