Fight:144236

Freddie Welsh 139 lbs lost to Johnny Kilbane 130 lbs by NWS in round 10 of 10

• Date: 1917-05-01
• Location: Manhattan Casino, New York, New York, USA
• Referee: Billy Joh

• Newspaper decision for Kilbane from Ed Curley (New York American), Left Jab (New York Evening Mail), Rube Goldberg (New York Evening Mail), P.T. Knox (New York Evening Telegram), Robert Edgren (New York Evening World), New York Herald, Igoe (New York Morning World), George B. Underwood (New York Sun), New York Times, W.O. McGeehan (New York Tribune), New York Call, Brooklyn Daily Eagle, Brooklyn Standard Union, William H. Rocap (Philadelphia Public Ledger), Robert W. Maxwell (Philadelphia Evening Ledger), Louis H. Jaffe (Philadelphia Evening Ledger), James S. Carolyn (Philadelphia Press), William R. Cluxton (Trenton Evening Times), Tom Terrell (Cleveland Plain Dealer), Jack Veiock (International News Service), Arthur Struwe (International News Service), H.C. Hamilton (United Press), Associated Press.
• A draw from Philadelphia Inquirer.