| ||||||||||||||||||
| Georgie Balduc | 32 15 18 |   
| D-PTS
| Vincent Sanchez | 13 7 9 |
| Box-pro | light | ||||||||||
The decision was considered so unfair that the two officials who voted for Rosen were fired. New York Times
| ||||||||||||||||||
| Charlie Rosen | 17 3 3 |
| W-PTS
| Lucien Vinez | 103 27 22 |
| Box-pro | |||||||||||
| Willie Suess | 16 10 3 |
| W-PTS
| Willie O'Connell | 48 6 6 |
| Box-pro | |||||||||||
| Teddy Lambrino | 1 0 1 | 
| W-PTS
| Al Amatrano | 0 2 0 |
| Box-pro | |||||||||||