granberry wrote:Very good thread here.
Thank you, Robinson and Expug, for your comments.
Everyone should try to learn a little judo -- (how to fall).
I knew one fighter--Adrian Davis--who said he had some background in judo.
A guy I had Taekwondo (sp) lessons with (Jim Joseph) told me that a friend of his who taught karate in Pennsylvania gave a few lessons to Ali, who wanted to learn specifically about things to do to an opponent’s head and neck (twisting it, jerking it, etc).
Joseph disliked me because I always forgot to bow when I came in the room or when I asked him a question. He said the guy in PA regarded Ali as a very obnoxious student.
I never picked up the karate way of punching but I had a great time.
Whenever a fellow instructor friend of Joseph would come to visit the class Joseph would always point me out as we went through our basic kicks/punches. Joseph would nod toward me and say, "He used to box."
The visitor would say, "Yeah, I can see that."
It had to do with the way I punched when I tried to do their karate punches (I may be misusing some of these words here--such as karate).
The class was full contact. Almost every class there was a broken wrist or ankle. People came from big distances who wanted that rough level.
I was there because the classes were at a community center close to me.
I remember asking Joseph about doing the judo throws on a bare wooden floor as they were doing. ''Aren't you supposed to use a mat?" I asked.
"No, you learn how to fall better this way" he said.
I would be interested in your more educated opinions on this--but I found many karate-taekwando people to be physically weak.
I had some talks with Joseph when he was in the mood to talk, and he agreed with me that most (or maybe all) of what most people learn in such classes is not usable by them in the real world.
I was through boxing by that time, but I still used to spar occasionally with friends of mine.
I remember after I had done the taekwondo classes for a while,
one guy I sparred with who had been a sparring partner for Bob Foster
said, "You seem to block (avoid) everything."
I really think the experience with handling not only arms (punches) but legs (kicks) coming at you also in the karate classes heightened my defensive abilities in boxing--where I only had to defend against punches.
Joseph would have his best longtime students go all out on me when he was irritated with me. I was a very slow thinker in the karate since it was new to me. I thought one step at a time. I got amazing bruises from the kicks, especially around the kidneys. Worse than any boxing bruises I got to the body. The former Foster sparring partner commented on the kidney area bruises, saying they looked bad and warning me about that.
I just laughed.
Some of the guys in the class were good at finding my solar plexus with kicks. I got the wind knocked out of me repeatedly during the classes.
I learned to relax and keep a straight face and the wind came back in a few seconds. I think the body blows from kicks were a terrific training aid for a boxer.
I lacked the flexibility to do a real roundhouse kick and never came near doing that. Joseph liked my front kick, which had a lot of power.
I always had a big smile on my face there. Once a guy who drove a long distance for the full contact classes was psyching himself up before we started. He stopped and said to me, "Why are you always smiling here? Don't you know this is serious?."
I had a wonderful time at those classes, even though you guys would say I was pathetic as a serious student.
Its very good that you were able to train in a full contact manner.
Nowadays it is hard to find that in many Martial Arts systems.
I believe there is something to be gained in many of the styles , perhaps not all.
But you are right that some are better suited for self defense than others.
What I liked about Judo is a guy who claims a high rank can be tested Immediatley in Randori(sparring).
There are no illusions and one cant hide on the mat.
That said, sportsmanship is important.(ideally).
The thing that gets on my nerves is the selling of some of these arts.
10 year old kids that are supposed Black Belts, 300 pound Grandmasters who cant fight.
Guys who are self promoted etc etc.
I think there are more Ultra Supreme Grandmasters here in Chicgo than in all of Asia.