Mundine is still a super middy!

[AntonS]

Tonight's Newcastle weights

Mundine 74.55 Kim 74.80
Dib 58.75 Marali 58.55
Withers 89.75 Ellis 88.20
A Elomar 61.30 Glover 61.95
Quinlan 75.35 Lilomaiava 76.60
Wickins 64.00 Drysdale 63.50

[Grant]

He's waiting for a no hoper to win a super middy title somewhere so he can challenge. Then he will be a three time champ....

[toppity]

He's waiting for a no hoper to win a super middy title somewhere so he can challenge. Then he will be a three time champ....

was there ever an agreed weight for this fight, or did they just make it up as they went along?

[Lowie]

He only has to lose two kilo's to fight Geale,for some reason I was thinking he was around 78-79kg??

Might happen early 09??

[p4p1]

He only has to lose two kilo's to fight Geale,for some reason I was thinking he was around 78-79kg??

Might happen early 09??

he would beat geale

[toppity]

He only has to lose two kilo's to fight Geale,for some reason I was thinking he was around 78-79kg??

Might happen early 09??

he would beat geale

tend to agree

[buster007]

he has been trying to convince us he is going to dominate the world middleweight division.

no wonder he has no credibility.

[unleash06]

he needs to step up right now and fight and beat these topline blokes to have any credence with the true fight fans in australia. if he leaves it too long, another story of wasted potential.

[madball1982]

Gives up the SMW belt to fight at MW and then makes a catchweight fight where he's still SMW? Tool.

[Marlin]

Gives up the SMW belt to fight at MW and then makes a catchweight fight where he's still SMW? Tool.

Exactly.

[p4p1]

Gives up the SMW belt to fight at MW and then makes a catchweight fight where he's still SMW? Tool.

only 2 kilos over middlweight

[Lowie]

HE WONT BEAT GEALE.He will step up to the occasion lads!!

[madball1982]

Gives up the SMW belt to fight at MW and then makes a catchweight fight where he's still SMW? Tool.

only 2 kilos over middlweight

Doesn't matter if it was only 500g over. He's still SMW.

[p4p1]

Gives up the SMW belt to fight at MW and then makes a catchweight fight where he's still SMW? Tool.

only 2 kilos over middlweight

Doesn't matter if it was only 500g over. He's still SMW.

im maiking the point that he most likely wil make middle when he want to but i dont see why he didnt fight this fight at middle

[AntonS]

Just goes to show what frigging circus WBA is.
He requests a rating @ middleweight & gets it (even though he never fought @ the weight) because he intends to fight @ the weight.
I wonder when this will happen?

[p4p1]

Just goes to show what frigging circus WBA is.
He request a rating @ middleweight & gets it (even though he never fought @ the weight) because he intends to fight @ the weight.

that is a joke

[unleash06]

ok, can i play devil's advocate here guys. shouldn't his record at SMW count towards a rating whether it be MW or LH??? i do realise in some sports that when the new season starts, we all start from scratch but there are some where you are seeded(ranked) on past performance.

[p4p1]

ok, can i play devil's advocate here guys. shouldn't his record at SMW count towards a rating whether it be MW or LH??? i do realise in some sports that when the new season starts, we all start from scratch but there are some where you are seeded(ranked) on past performance.

yes it should but i do believe he should fight at the weight first, he has not yet proved to the WBA that he can make the weight thats why i think it is stupid if he had a fight at the weight no matter who it was against he deserves to be rated because of his past accomplishments

[unleash06]

ok, can i play devil's advocate here guys. shouldn't his record at SMW count towards a rating whether it be MW or LH??? i do realise in some sports that when the new season starts, we all start from scratch but there are some where you are seeded(ranked) on past performance.

yes it should but i do believe he should fight at the weight first, he has not yet proved to the WBA that he can make the weight thats why i think it is stupid if he had a fight at the weight no matter who it was against he deserves to be rated because of his past accomplishments

thanks p4p, good to get a fighters perspective on it. i suppose rankings don't really come into until you are in top ten and then the money fights and titles are at stake. where would be a realistic ranking for a situation like this then??

[p4p1]

ok, can i play devil's advocate here guys. shouldn't his record at SMW count towards a rating whether it be MW or LH??? i do realise in some sports that when the new season starts, we all start from scratch but there are some where you are seeded(ranked) on past performance.

yes it should but i do believe he should fight at the weight first, he has not yet proved to the WBA that he can make the weight thats why i think it is stupid if he had a fight at the weight no matter who it was against he deserves to be rated because of his past accomplishments

thanks p4p, good to get a fighters perspective on it. i suppose rankings don't really come into until you are in top ten and then the money fights and titles are at stake. where would be a realistic ranking for a situation like this then??

i think he should be ranked as a SMW prob number 1 or 2 because he was the champion and if he request to be rated at MW he should be on the condition he has a fight at the weight before he is rated if he does he should be in the top few of the ratings i believe

[madball1982]

He does deserve to be ranked, but ONLY after he's already fought in the division IMO. Everyone does. It's not footy with a new season and given it can take initially 15fights or so to get somewhere in the first place it would take too long.

BTW, anyone complaining, just keep in mind, the same thing happened with fighters like Green (if memory serves me correctly) to a degree at least.

[buster007]

i don't mind if they do rate him high at mw, but if that's what has happened and then he comes out and fights like last night and fights at smw then that is farcicle to say the least.

he should now be taken off the mw rankings immediately.

[ccorrigan]

IMO he doesn't deserve to be ranked in the top 5 SMW let alone MW. Besides Green, he hasn't fought a credible opponent in years and anybody that has ever been rated highly has beaten him.

He had the perfect opportunity to right a wrong in Kessler and a win would have ranked him 1 @ SMW in line to fight any number of MW's or SMW's looking to consolidate belts. His best chance to fight someone like Pavlik or Taylor would have been from a Kessler win.

Instead he fabricates a reality where Kessler coming off a lose is a step down from him!!!! (This same rational doesn't apply to people like Sam). Moving to MW means better champions in Pavlik and Taylor (depsite the fact they are all likely to move up to SMW) and then goes and fights Kim...

I am well aware that he is all about the best payday with the least risk and he has been relatively successful from that point of view. He's a gifted athlete and with the right guidance he might have accomplished more or even kept his mouth shut long enough to get a sponsorship deal, but ultimately I wish everyone would turn there back on him until he steps up and takes a real fight.

[toppity]

IMO he doesn't deserve to be ranked in the top 5 SMW let alone MW. Besides Green, he hasn't fought a credible opponent in years and anybody that has ever been rated highly has beaten him.

He had the perfect opportunity to right a wrong in Kessler and a win would have ranked him 1 @ SMW in line to fight any number of MW's or SMW's looking to consolidate belts. His best chance to fight someone like Pavlik or Taylor would have been from a Kessler win.

Instead he fabricates a reality where Kessler coming off a lose is a step down from him!!!! (This same rational doesn't apply to people like Sam). Moving to MW means better champions in Pavlik and Taylor (depsite the fact they are all likely to move up to SMW) and then goes and fights Kim...

I am well aware that he is all about the best payday with the least risk and he has been relatively successful from that point of view. He's a gifted athlete and with the right guidance he might have accomplished more or even kept his mouth shut long enough to get a sponsorship deal, but ultimately I wish everyone would turn there back on him until he steps up and takes a real fight.

that just about hits the nail on the head. And that is why this forum, and the boxing fans in general, have lost respect for him. I believe, as has been stated by others, that he would quickly regain massive support he he took the risks.

[Marlin]

I believe, as has been stated by others, that he would quickly regain massive support he he took the risks.

He would also rack up a few more in the L column and he clearly doesn't want that...