Amir Khan

Post Reply
slapbangwhallop
Heavyweight
Heavyweight

Amir Khan

Post by slapbangwhallop »

listed as being from Bolton, Lancashire - the record should read Bolton, Greater Manchester
slapbangwhallop
Heavyweight
Heavyweight

Re: Amir Khan

Post by slapbangwhallop »

sligobhoy67 wrote:listed as being from Bolton, Lancashire - the record should read Bolton, Greater Manchester
bump
Asterix
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 7128
Joined: 02 Nov 2007, 10:42

Re: Amir Khan

Post by Asterix »

Seeing as it's on topic, Amir Khan's height is incorrect. He should be listed at 5' 9" tall.

Please see the following video for Amir Khan and Martin Kristjansen next to each other. They are very nearly the same height. On Boxrec Khan is listed at 5' 10" and Kristjansen at 5' 7½"!!!

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=OuQurD7niBY

Kristjansen should be listed at 5' 8" at the minimum. 5' 8½" would be preferable.
slapbangwhallop
Heavyweight
Heavyweight

Re: Amir Khan

Post by slapbangwhallop »

Asterix wrote:Seeing as it's on topic, Amir Khan's height is incorrect. He should be listed at 5' 9" tall.

Please see the following video for Amir Khan and Martin Kristjansen next to each other. They are very nearly the same height. On Boxrec Khan is listed at 5' 10" and Kristjansen at 5' 7½"!!!

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=OuQurD7niBY

Kristjansen should be listed at 5' 8" at the minimum. 5' 8½" would be preferable.
this wasnt a query with regards his height
Asterix
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 7128
Joined: 02 Nov 2007, 10:42

Re: Amir Khan

Post by Asterix »

sligobhoy67 wrote:
Asterix wrote:Seeing as it's on topic, Amir Khan's height is incorrect. He should be listed at 5' 9" tall.

Please see the following video for Amir Khan and Martin Kristjansen next to each other. They are very nearly the same height. On Boxrec Khan is listed at 5' 10" and Kristjansen at 5' 7½"!!!

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=OuQurD7niBY

Kristjansen should be listed at 5' 8" at the minimum. 5' 8½" would be preferable.
this wasnt a query with regards his height
It's entitled 'Amir Khan', hence my reply. ;;-)
slapbangwhallop
Heavyweight
Heavyweight

Re: Amir Khan

Post by slapbangwhallop »

Asterix wrote:
sligobhoy67 wrote:
Asterix wrote:Seeing as it's on topic, Amir Khan's height is incorrect. He should be listed at 5' 9" tall.

Please see the following video for Amir Khan and Martin Kristjansen next to each other. They are very nearly the same height. On Boxrec Khan is listed at 5' 10" and Kristjansen at 5' 7½"!!!

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=OuQurD7niBY

Kristjansen should be listed at 5' 8" at the minimum. 5' 8½" would be preferable.
this wasnt a query with regards his height
It's entitled 'Amir Khan', hence my reply. ;;-)
? I dont understand.
Asterix
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 7128
Joined: 02 Nov 2007, 10:42

Re: Amir Khan

Post by Asterix »

I posted about Amir Khan in your topic because you titled it 'Amir Khan'.
slapbangwhallop
Heavyweight
Heavyweight

Re: Amir Khan

Post by slapbangwhallop »

Asterix wrote:I posted about Amir Khan in your topic because you titled it 'Amir Khan'.
oh sorry, i thought you were answering my query. np!
Tom
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 150
Joined: 28 Dec 2001, 20:00

Re: Amir Khan

Post by Tom »

the changes made to British counties in 1974 were purely political and made to aid administration in those areas ie local government, voting and postal addresses. Bolton for instance was, is and always will be in Lancashire but for admin reasons will come under Greater Manchester. In truth Liverpool should also be classed as being in Lancashire but is always entered in Boxrec, understandably, as being part of Merseyside which only exists in the minds of local government beaurocrats. I think you will find most Boltonians consider themselves to be born and bred Lancastrian no matter what lines are drawn on the maps in local government offices.
Freiheit
Editor
Editor
Posts: 2851
Joined: 28 Dec 2001, 20:00

Re: Amir Khan

Post by Freiheit »

Asterix wrote:Seeing as it's on topic, Amir Khan's height is incorrect. He should be listed at 5' 9" tall.

Please see the following video for Amir Khan and Martin Kristjansen next to each other. They are very nearly the same height. On Boxrec Khan is listed at 5' 10" and Kristjansen at 5' 7½"!!!

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=OuQurD7niBY

Kristjansen should be listed at 5' 8" at the minimum. 5' 8½" would be preferable.
Kristjansen is 172cm, and it will not get changed.
slapbangwhallop
Heavyweight
Heavyweight

Re: Amir Khan

Post by slapbangwhallop »

Tom wrote:the changes made to British counties in 1974 were purely political and made to aid administration in those areas ie local government, voting and postal addresses. Bolton for instance was, is and always will be in Lancashire but for admin reasons will come under Greater Manchester. In truth Liverpool should also be classed as being in Lancashire but is always entered in Boxrec, understandably, as being part of Merseyside which only exists in the minds of local government beaurocrats. I think you will find most Boltonians consider themselves to be born and bred Lancastrian no matter what lines are drawn on the maps in local government offices.
"is and always will be in Lancashire" - that is completely incorrect. The boundaries of counties, provinces and countries change all the time and the records need to reflect that. Maybe older people still say they are in Lancashire but younger people dont. Bolton has been in Greater Manchester for the whole of Khans life. Liverpool is in Merseyside, Bolton is in Greater Manchester etc. No matter what older people might "feel" shouldnt we go on what the actual place in called. Accurate records

Afterall with dont say the Wembley is still in Middlesex we say its in London.
Asterix
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 7128
Joined: 02 Nov 2007, 10:42

Re: Amir Khan

Post by Asterix »

Freiheit wrote:
Asterix wrote:Seeing as it's on topic, Amir Khan's height is incorrect. He should be listed at 5' 9" tall.

Please see the following video for Amir Khan and Martin Kristjansen next to each other. They are very nearly the same height. On Boxrec Khan is listed at 5' 10" and Kristjansen at 5' 7½"!!!

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=OuQurD7niBY

Kristjansen should be listed at 5' 8" at the minimum. 5' 8½" would be preferable.
Kristjansen is 172cm, and it will not get changed.
What about Khan? If you look at the video I've provided Khan and Kristjansen are no more than a centimetre apart, height-wise.
John
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 9066
Joined: 08 May 2000, 20:00

Re: Amir Khan

Post by John »

We do not recognise the existence of Greater Manchester nor have they made official application to us to be recognised.
slapbangwhallop
Heavyweight
Heavyweight

Re: Amir Khan

Post by slapbangwhallop »

JohnShep wrote:We do not recognise the existence of Greater Manchester nor have they made official application to us to be recognised.
any reason why not??

BoxRec recognises Greater London, why not Greater Manchester?
John
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 9066
Joined: 08 May 2000, 20:00

Re: Amir Khan

Post by John »

The regions are in the system solely to discriminate between places of the same name, ie Newport, Gwent / Newport, Shropshire and more importantly to make the selection of locations easier for the editors. Having a USA drop down box with 7000 town/cities is not practicable. The geographic basis is convenience and convention not currency. Most countries in the database do not have regions allocated.
Post Reply