Is Hatton P4P No1 if he beats Pacman?

[DG.]

I know there are lots of threads, Hatton says he is number 1 if he wins - is he?

Mods, can we leave this as a stand alone Poll?

[J]

no not wihout another top tenner p4p on his victory slate he isnt.

[banjo]

No, you can't just base it off one fight.

[EddieShredder]

No.

Marquez is.

[DG.]

Who said YES?

Does Ricky Hatton post on here?

[Quixall]

I know there are lots of threads, Hatton says he is number 1 if he wins - is he?

Mods, can we leave this as a stand alone Poll?

No he won't be considerd a p4p man at all......

One of the reasons is that Hatton can't move up the weights and most p4p title holders can and have done that, ie, Jones, Hopkins, Mayweather, Barrera, Pacquaio etc etc.

I think i only really did this post to prove to DG that i can "quote" properly

Well, most of the time anyway

[J]

so hagler was never p4p then?

dont agree with this weight hopping being a criteria for p4p not one bit.

[hitman_hatton1]

so hagler was never p4p then?

dont agree with this weight hopping being a criteria for p4p not one bit.

no i don't.

hopkins was level pegging with mayweather for a spell.

and he was middleweight at the time and never stepped out of that weight class.

anyway hatton won a version of the title at another weight.

that proves he can at least do it in another weight class.

[DG.]

I know there are lots of threads, Hatton says he is number 1 if he wins - is he?

Mods, can we leave this as a stand alone Poll?

No he won't be considerd a p4p man at all......

One of the reasons is that Hatton can't move up the weights and most p4p title holders can and have done that, ie, Jones, Hopkins, Mayweather, Barrera, Pacquaio etc etc.

I think i only really did this post to prove to DG that i can "quote" properly

Well, most of the time anyway

At last!

[DG.]

so hagler was never p4p then?

dont agree with this weight hopping being a criteria for p4p not one bit.

EXCEPTIONAL fighters can stay at one weight and be P4P, Hatton is not exceptional.

[DG.]

so hagler was never p4p then?

dont agree with this weight hopping being a criteria for p4p not one bit.

no i don't.

hopkins was level pegging with mayweather for a spell.

and he was middleweight at the time and never stepped out of that weight class.

anyway hatton won a version of the title at another weight.

that proves he can at least do it in another weight class.

Against a c level fighter than actually beat him.

[Quixall]

so hagler was never p4p then?

dont agree with this weight hopping being a criteria for p4p not one bit.

None of it is an exact science J, as you have said yourself,

Hagler was perhaps an exception to the rule and maybe there are one or two others, but there is no doubt that if a fighter can go through higher weight divisions and be just as successful, then people take note and applaud such accolades. That is one of the reasons for Barrera returning to the ring, to try and become the first mexican to be a four weight world champion, so i does carry some significance. Most p4p holders, however you deem the process, are invariably multi-weight world champions.

If you take the De La Hoya - Pacquaio fight, one of the attributes that people recognised was that Pacquia, a former flyweight champion, was taking on a fighter who had won a world title at middleweight and so the victory was more impressive because of that. Even you, have said in earlier posts on this thread, that posters were calling De La Hoya "shot" after the event and so are claiming that De La Hoya was still a very good and dangerous fighter, when he fought Pacquaio. It may not be fair on Hatton, who can't move up the weights, but a lot of the acclaimed fighters do and are recognised for doing so.

[observer1]

Who votes yes ?

[banjo]

Who votes yes ?

Probably Hitman_Hatton1

[DG.]

Who votes yes ?

Must have been Matthew - Ricky and HitmanHatton1!

[DG.]

Maybe Hatton should join Boxrec!

[observer1]

Maybe Hatton should join Boxrec!

i reckon he won't be half the Hatton fanboy that HitmanHatton1 is.

[DG.]

Maybe Hatton should join Boxrec!

i reckon he won't be half the Hatton fanboy that HitmanHatton1 is.

[alexpaterson]

No he wont but i cant c Pacman losing and JMM would beat Ricky Hatton