Oisin Fagan v Johnny Greaves

[slapbangwhallop]

it was called as 58-55 on the night but is listed as 58-56.

Was the call a mistake on the fight.

The fight is available to view for free on spam.com

[Andy]

Mistake at our end. Corrected now
Regarding the question about boxers eligible to fight for both Irish and British titles. That opens up another can of worms. There's no default, it's just down to what was entered originally. Same as I said there's no answer that keeps everyone happy.

[slapbangwhallop]

Mistake at our end. Corrected now
Regarding the question about boxers eligible to fight for both Irish and British titles. That opens up another can of worms. There's no default, it's just down to what was entered originally. Same as I said there's no answer that keeps everyone happy.

If its just down to whatever was entered originally and its not a default then it is a little strange that every boxer from Northern Ireland is listed as British and none (bar Duddy - lets not go through that again!) as Irish.

[Andy]

We appear to be talking in circles, so I'll make this is my final post on a matter in which we can never please everyone. If a boxer is from Northern Ireland he initially go's down as being British. If he boxes off a British license (which the vast majority of the Northern Irish lads do) he is included in the British rankings. The Northern Ireland boxers themselves need to decide one way or another, British or Irish. It's up to them. And if the answer is Irish then they shouldn't be chasing British titles.

[slapbangwhallop]

We appear to be talking in circles, so I'll make this is my final post on a matter in which we can never please everyone. If a boxer is from Northern Ireland he initially go's down as being British. If he boxes off a British license (which the vast majority of the Northern Irish lads do) he is included in the British rankings. The Northern Ireland boxers themselves need to decide one way or another, British or Irish. It's up to them. And if the answer is Irish then they shouldn't be chasing British titles.

Dont British fighters chase Irish titles as well? Jamie Moore! Tyson Fury!

Trying to advance your career by going for a more significant title does not effect ones nationality.

I dont think that field should be labelled "nationality" if it doesnt reflect the boxers nationality.

[AntonS]

sligobhoy67

You, yet again, seem to be suffering extreme boredom. Maybe....to alleviate the problem you should consider knitting winter bed socks for local nursing home.

[Deno1986]

sligobhoy67

You, yet again, seem to be suffering extreme boredom. Maybe....to alleviate the problem you should consider knitting winter bed socks for local nursing home.

Sligo is not the only one who has has problem with it, most Irish boxing fans object to it also (myself included).

X3

[AntonS]

Nationality is entirely up to boxers & not fans

[slapbangwhallop]

Nationality is entirely up to boxers & not fans

without doubt that is correct. But how does that effect this discussion?

[AntonS]

This is not a discussion area of the forum

[slapbangwhallop]

This is not a discussion area of the forum

what has your comment got to do with this thread?

Of course this is a discussion area - its for discussing any queries with regards boxers records that are listed on BoxRec!

[AntonS]

It's got nothing to do with you, so why discuss it??

[slapbangwhallop]

It's got nothing to do with you, so why discuss it??

whats nothing to do with me?

so why discuss what?

Are you still talking English Ruski?