Ian 'Mr' McNeilly wrote:exittored wrote:It's also laughable that you list Pascal, Taylor, Dirrell, Kessler and Abraham as being alot better resume then Kotelnik, Maligianni, McCloskey, Judah and Maidana when in reality there's not much in it.
I'm a huge admirer of Khan and how he's turned things around. Your point about his relatively young age is one we often forget.
But the above comment doesn't hold water, IMO. The best Khan has fought from that list is probably on the same level as the worst from Froch's one. All about opinions though.
No way
Taylor was damaged goods by the time he faced Froch and not all that to begin with.
Kessler was coming off a bad loss and was always over-rated and damaged goods by the time he beat Froch
Dirrell was green and never had a significant win before Froch and wasn't rated in the Ring Top 10 Super Middleweights yet still beat him in most peoples scorecards and hasn't done anything since.
Abraham was coming off a bad loss and always garbage anyway, won a paper title in Germany and made defences against crappy boxers then was finally exposed for what he was in the Super 6, a one dimensional plodder who only had one win at Super Middleweight and that was to the very damaged Taylor.
Pascal was green and didn't have one decent win on his record and wasn't rated in the Ring Top 10 Super Middleweights when he faced Froch and just got soundly beaten by a 65 year old man.
None of the above were reigning champions at the time they faced Froch and Taylor, Kessler and Abraham were coming off damaging losses in their last or recent fight.
whereas
Barrera - All time great who just a year or two before facing Khan gave peak Juan Manuel Marquez all he could handle and went the distance with Manny Pacqauio so wasn't as over the hill as people make out.
Kotelnik WBA World Champion at time who has never been beaten decisively before or since Khan plus his stock has gone up in the last year.
Maligianni 2 time world Light welterweight champion who was still only 29 at time Khan faced him plus he was coming off the best win of his career over Juan Diaz and was a Ring Top 10 Light Welterweight.
McCloskey Unbeaten European champion and respected technical boxer and Ring Magazine Top 10 Light Welter.
Maidana One of the most feared Boxers around when Khan beat him and rated Top 5 by Ring.
Judah IBF World Champion at the time and regarded as one of the most skilled in all Boxing who was looking his best in years at his natural weight of Light Welter
Froch has only faced fighters who were crap to begin with, still green or damaged in one way or another coming into the fight but in Andre Ward he faces his first specal fighter with Skills and who is unbeaten and a reigning World Champion so lets see how he does!