Tampa card 111905

Post Reply
flboxing
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 34
Joined: 01 Oct 2005, 18:54

Tampa card 111905

Post by flboxing »

Main event for the night De Leon Jr. v Jacob Rodriguez
ended at 0:00 of the THIRD. Per Florida boxing regulation since the round ended, it is ruled a 0:00 stoppage of the next round, not 3:00 of the prior.

Judges and referee information for the card:

De Leon Jr. v Jacob Rodriguez
Referee: Brian Garry
Notes: Rodriguez down in the second.

Rivera v Basora
Referee: Brian Garry
Judges: 57-55 Basora (Emil Conforti) and 56-56 twice (Mike Ross and Don Balas)
Notes: Basora down at the bell of third. Rivera down in the fifth.

Samuels v Delgado
Referee: Frank Gentile
Judges: Mike Ross had it 58-56 Samuels but overruled by Don Balas and Alex Levin’s score of 58-56 for Delgado

Gonzalez v Perez
Referee: Frank Gentile
Judges: 40-36 (Emil Conforti) and 39-37 twice (Mike Ross and Don Balas)

Hodge v Pena
Referee: Brian Garry
Judges: 40-35 (Alex Levin), 39-36 (Mike Ross), and 39-37 (Emil Conforti)
Notes: Pena down in the second

Shiver v Michelle Taylor
Referee: Frank Gentile
Judges: 40-35 (Emil Conforti) and 38-37 twice (Mike Ross and Alex Levin)
Notes: Taylor down in the first


Full article is available at http://www.FLBoxing.com
evndrbsn
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 757
Joined: 10 Jul 2004, 13:20

Post by evndrbsn »

Come on, fix the Carlos De Leon Jr. result. It was 0:00 of round 3 as per Florida Boxing Commission rules.
evndrbsn
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 757
Joined: 10 Jul 2004, 13:20

Post by evndrbsn »

Whoever fixed the De Leon result put, "Not out because of injury stoppage." I think they meant, "Did not come out for third because of injury." Hope this gets fixed again.
Blue
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 3182
Joined: 28 Dec 2001, 20:00

Post by Blue »

No fixing needed; it already says TKO 3, why repeat?
evndrbsn
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 757
Joined: 10 Jul 2004, 13:20

Post by evndrbsn »

Blue wrote:No fixing needed; it already says TKO 3, why repeat?
Just sounds a little confusing, "Not out because of injury stoppage." But at least you fixed it :TU:
Blue
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 3182
Joined: 28 Dec 2001, 20:00

Post by Blue »

OK; :roll: how about now? :D

IMO, what needs fixing is the politically motivated appointments of arrogant commissioners by state governors to reciprocate past favors.
Most of them are ignorant of boxing and its traditional record keeping. :evil:

IIRC,
In England, where pro boxing was born; this corner retirement would have originally been scored as rtd 3, Time 0:10.
When the bell rang, the referee stands in front of the boxer seated on his stool and counts him out.
(The Brits are so into ceremony.) :wink:

Though most of the world follows England;
Record keepers in the U.S.A. changed rtd 3, Time 0:10 to a tko 2, Time 3:00.
The prevalent argument is the fight was terminated after rd 2 and no action took place in rd 3.

I don’t remember when Texas, Illinois & Florida went back to the oncoming rd, but only Florida has the time listed as 0:00;
which makes no sense to me. :roll:

Also; to signify that the referee stopped the fight in the heat of battle, the official decision originally was scored as rsf.
This was changed by record keepers in the U.S.A. to a tko. (Technical knockout)

The Ring Record Books 1978 thru 1984 don’t even distinguish between ko and tko, much less corner retirement. :roll:

That’s my 2 cents. :wink:
evndrbsn
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 757
Joined: 10 Jul 2004, 13:20

Post by evndrbsn »

Blue wrote: OK; :roll: how about now? :D

IMO, what needs fixing is the politically motivated appointments of arrogant commissioners by state governors to reciprocate past favors. Most of them are ignorant of boxing and its traditional record keeping. :evil:

IIRC,
In England, where pro boxing was born; this corner retirement would have originally been scored as rtd 3, Time 0:10.
When the bell rang, the referee stands in front of the boxer seated on his stool and counts him out.
(The Brits are so into ceremony.) :wink:

Though most of the world follows England;
Record keepers in the U.S.A. changed rtd 3, Time 0:10 to a tko 2, Time 3:00.
The prevalent argument is the fight was terminated after rd 2 and no action took place in rd 3.

I don’t remember when Texas, Illinois & Florida went back to the oncoming rd, but only Florida has the time listed as 0:00;
which makes no sense to me. :roll:

Also; to signify that the referee stopped the fight in the heat of battle, the official decision originally was scored as rsf.
This was changed by record keepers in the U.S.A. to a tko. (Technical knockout)

The Ring Record Books 1978 thru 1984 don’t even distinguish between ko and tko, much less corner retirement. :roll:

That’s my 2 cents. :wink:
I agree completely. Everyone wants to be different, I suppose.
Post Reply