British Top 30 P4P September 2014

[palooka]

Murray lost a questionable decision to Martinez and was elevated several places.

[Horse]

Say what you like about his match-making, but Scott Quigg is undefeated and holder of the WBA world super bantamweight title.

His matchmaking has been Brookesque. Awful stuff. Paper champion.

....and that sees him placed 12th on the British P4P rankings?

Too high?

[Horse]

He didn't deserve it last month or the month before that either.

No.

[palooka]

No, he didn't deserve it palooka, you are right my friend or; no?

[Horse]

What was Murrays big win that kept him at 3 for all those months?

Martinez.

[palooka]

What was Murrays big win that kept him at 3 for all those months?

Martinez.

The loss to Martinez?

[Horse]

I'd say this is justified based on the respective performances of Cleverly and Groves. Yes Groves was ko'ed twice by Froch but he was highly competitive in both bouts whereas Cleverly was blown away.

Indeed.

[Horse]

Murray lost a questionable decision to Martinez and was elevated several places.

Yes.

[Horse]

No, he didn't deserve it palooka, you are right my friend or; no?

I didn't rank Murray at No. 2 last month or the month before that either, my dear chum.

[palooka]

I'm more looking forward to taffytown getting in from work and getting going

What's he going to say?

Taffy can put his own points across far better than I can.

[Horse]

The loss to Martinez?

The win.

[Horse]

Taffy can put his own points across far better than I can.

I doubt that.

[palooka]

The loss to Martinez?

The win.

OK; some people thought that Frankie deserved the win v Bundu who is a very good fighter; shouldn't Frankie have held his spot?

[Horse]

OK; some people thought that Frankie deserved the win v Bundu who is a very good fighter; shouldn't Frankie have held his spot?

Martinez is a lot better than Bundu. It's not really the same situation.

[crusader]

Say what you like about his match-making, but Scott Quigg is undefeated and holder of the WBA world super bantamweight title.

....and that sees him placed 12th on the British P4P rankings?

Why should holding a title mean anything rather than purely going on who someone fought and how they performed?

Is a win over a certain boxer more impressive if it was for a trinket instead of being non-title bout that is otherwise the same?

[palooka]

OK; some people thought that Frankie deserved the win v Bundu who is a very good fighter; shouldn't Frankie have held his spot?

Martinez is a lot better than Bundu. It's not really the same situation.

Sergio was better than Bundu, way before the Murray fight though.

[Horse]

Sergio was better than Bundu, way before the Murray fight though.

No, he was better in the Murray fight as well.

Bundu is a solid fringe world level fighter. Martinez was a top 10 P4P fighter.

[Boxerbeetle]

Say what you like about his match-making, but Scott Quigg is undefeated and holder of the WBA world super bantamweight title.

....and that sees him placed 12th on the British P4P rankings?

Quigg isn't holder of the WBA belt though - not the proper one anyway. He's a long way from a genuine world title, I'd say his ranking is fair considering who he's beaten.