Antonio Tarver

[Othro]

Where does he rank amongst the great light heavyweights?

Is he over rated ? Is he under rated ?

Did he just get a lucky punch vs Roy Jones?

[Rexob]

He's was pretty good considering he turned pro quite late in life, he has achieved a lot but not a great.

[tiny_acres]

Where does he rank amongst the great light heavyweights?

Is he over rated ? Is he under rated ?

Did he just get a lucky punch vs Roy Jones?

That was not a lucky punch against Jones.

I do not see him as an atg lightheavy A very goo one but not atg

[gregor]

I agree - very good, but not great.

His punch against Roy was not lucky, but he was lucky to fight RJJ in the proper moment. RJJ was at the beginning of decline and with his style (speed, reflexes) he had to lose quickly... as shown by the rest of his career.