Updating the BOXREC Forum Heavyweight Rankings CLOSED

[jezzamundo]

BWH Rankings as of 6 August 2016:

Champion: Tyson Fury
1. Wladimir Klitschko
2. Alexander Povetkin
3. Deontay Wilder
4. Luis Ortiz
5. Kubrat Pulev
6. Anthony Joshua
7. Joseph Parker
8. Bryant Jennings
9. Carlos Takam
10. Vyacheslav Glazkov
11. Lucas Browne
12. Bermane Stiverne
13. Artur Szpilka
14. Dereck Chisora
15. Malik Scott

Topic A - How are the rankings affected by Tyson Fury giving up all of his belts after testing positive to a banned substance?

My vote: Fury OUT

Topic B - How are the rankings affected by Joseph Parker's KO3 win over Alexander Dimitrenko?

My vote: Parker remains at #7

Topic C - How are the rankings affected by Dereck Chisora's KO2 win over Drazan Janjanin?

My vote: Chisora remains at #14


Note: This topic is for voting on the rankings of Fury, Parker, Dimitrenko, Chisora and Janjanin. Posting your own top 15 will not count as a vote. Please cast your vote in the manner that I have done above.

[greg]

I agree:
Fury - out
Parker remains at #7
Chisora remains at #14

PS: Champion - vacant

[Tarkus]

Fury - out
Parker at #6
Chisora at #14

[Horse]

Fury - Stays as Champion
Parker - Up to No. 6
Chisora - Stays at No. 14

[BitPlayer]

Fury - Champion in Recess
Parker moves up to 6
Chisa stays at 14

Active champ vacant.

[dagilechia]

Fury out, Parker 7, Chisora 14, champ-vacant

[BitPlayer]

Topic A - How are the rankings affected by Tyson Fury giving up all of his belts after testing positive to a banned substance?

A really misleading way to put it.

He's tested positive for cocaine and has mental health issues. This makes it sound like he vacated after getting caught using PEDs.

[Kronkpride]

Fury....No Change
Parker..No Change
Chisora...No Change.

Fury is the undefeated champion and every other boxer in the world is unfitting for the championship slot besides him.

[Horse]

Fury shouldn't be taken out.

It seems like a petty move to take him out now.

[HyacinthusTurnipseed]

I don't see what is gained by taking Fury out now - it isn't as if there is a fight around the corner that'd crown another consensus champion otherwise. We've got a little time just to see how the rest of the situation plays out.

Parker to #5, all the rest no change.

[Freedom2013]

Topic A - Fury OUT

Topic B - Parker to #5

Topic C - Chisora remains at #14

[jezzamundo]

Topic A - How are the rankings affected by Tyson Fury giving up all of his belts after testing positive to a banned substance?

A really misleading way to put it.

He's tested positive for cocaine and has mental health issues. This makes it sound like he vacated after getting caught using PEDs.

I guess it does look that way, though I assumed everyone here would know most of the details - I certainly didn't mean to mislead. Personally, I view Fury as the champion in recess, but didn't even think about the possibility of voting for that. This is a pretty complex issue, perhaps it needs its own thread?

[Heretic]

It will probably be really long time before Fury fights again. For that reason my vote is

Fury out


Parker stay at #7

Dimi is not relevant fight to rank top 15.


Chisora to #13

Activity points. Also Szpilka should not even be on this list.

[BroughtonRulesRefuge]

- More like it takes forever to move these poll results. Last time about 1/3 voted for changes yet no fighter moved a single place up or down.

A- Fury remains champ since BBbc is more disreputable than anything Fury has done.

B- Parker to 3rd. He and Josh way underrated compared to slackers over them.

C- Chisora to 15th. He's pants and he and Scott soon to exit.

[BitPlayer]

Topic A - How are the rankings affected by Tyson Fury giving up all of his belts after testing positive to a banned substance?

A really misleading way to put it.

He's tested positive for cocaine and has mental health issues. This makes it sound like he vacated after getting caught using PEDs.

I guess it does look that way, though I assumed everyone here would know most of the details - I certainly didn't mean to mislead. Personally, I view Fury as the champion in recess, but didn't even think about the possibility of voting for that. This is a pretty complex issue, perhaps it needs its own thread?

I suppose your'e probably right about everyon knowing it.

Maybe a separate vote is needed about if to have a champion in reccess system as I suppose it probably wasn't as obvious as I thought it was.

[greg]

...I believe Tyson Fury has officially vacated his WBA, WBO, IBO world titles. It's only logical to remove him from the rankings IMO..

[Horse]

...I believe Tyson Fury has officially vacated his WBA, WBO, IBO world titles. It's only logical to remove him from the rankings IMO..

No, it's not.

He's still clearly the champion, so he should be left in.

[greg]

...I believe Tyson Fury has officially vacated his WBA, WBO, IBO world titles. It's only logical to remove him from the rankings IMO..

No, it's not.

He's still clearly the champion, so he should be left in.

http://www.BS.com/tyson-fury-v ... es--109691
..what other proof do you need?

[Horse]

http://www.BS.com/tyson-fury-v ... es--109691
..what other proof do you need?

I think you missed my point.

[Mimmy]

http://www.BS.com/tyson-fury-v ... es--109691
..what other proof do you need?

I think you missed my point.

Horse has a point he has vacated his titles but has not retired so why remove him completely from their rankings? Fury might fight again next year so why does he need removing from their rankings just because he vacated titles?

[greg]

http://www.BS.com/tyson-fury-v ... es--109691
..what other proof do you need?

I think you missed my point.

I most likely did, ...what is relevant in this case to me though is that he voluntarily vacated the world titles and then was officially suspended by BBBofC pending further investigation...

[Lennox]

This is the Premier Boxing Organisation take on it: Tyson Fury should remain until he is deemed inactive which is 12 months at which time he only remains in the rankings if he is a champion of one of the organisations or he has a fight lined up. So he is in for one more month. www.premierboxingorganisation.com/heavyweight-200

[Horse]

This 12 months inactivity rule that so many people have with boxers is stupid.

Having 12 months out is a common occurrence in boxing.

It should be an 18 month rule, as that amount of time out is much less common for a fighter.

[Lennox]

Horse - The standard is 12 months but the ABCs will take into consideration injuries, both sides (as fights can get delayed then fall through aka Wladimir). Most fighters 90% that are top 20 do fight in a 12 month period. If a fighte returns having been ranked his former position is strongly considered. The principle of outing fighters after one year is to keep the rankings full with eligible (15) fighters. In a few weeks time Tyson Fury, Wlad an Povetkin will all strictly be inactive.

[Horse]

In a few weeks time Tyson Fury, Wlad an Povetkin will all strictly be inactive.

So we'll take them all out and have a stupid looking list. Great!