In the first fight sure and then he had to get his ratio within normal human limits and got destroyed in the second fight.SaadOffTheDeck wrote:I would say ever, Silva would have a punchers chance. GSP would take him down at will, like Sonnen did. Seriously bro, chael treated anderson like a doormat.Impractical Poster wrote:At this point he possibly would. 7 years ago, I doubt it.SaadOffTheDeck wrote:
He would massacre Silva.
MMA
Re: MMA
-
Impractical Poster
- Middleweight
- Posts: 7636
- Joined: 18 Jun 2014, 07:28
Re: MMA
Ferguson vs Khabib should be awesome. Both of these guys have Conor shook to the point where he is only thinking about boxing.
Re: MMA
Anderson needs to retire. He doesn't have it it anymore. He shows it in flashes like when he knocked out Bisping but generally he's just lost the ability to pull the trigger. Even tonight he had a few good moments but it wasn't enough. My big question though is what the fornicate happened to his clinch game? Clinching with Anderson used to be a death sentence, Okami who entire successful career was built on being a great clinch wrestler got bashed in the clinch. Tonight Brunson who's not as great as in the clinch was able to throw without much worry for returning knees.
He's 42 years old basing anything from his career off tonight's is lunacy.
He's 42 years old basing anything from his career off tonight's is lunacy.
Re: MMA
Jacare is so good. It's a such a shame and such an embarrassment that Bisping has been allowed to hold the division up like he has. Romero certainly deserves the next shot but he should've already had it back in October. We should be getting excited about Romero vs Jacare 2 for the title about now.
-
Counter-puncher
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 39141
- Joined: 20 May 2008, 11:41
Re: MMA
Ha. As an mma noob I thought GSP would do that wrestle-fornicate thing to Silva but what do I knowSaadOffTheDeck wrote:He would massacre Silva.Impractical Poster wrote:GSP needs to get his ass back in the picture. Not sure of his current form, but the welterweight division is there for the taking. I'm sure Conor would like to make some money on that fight as well.
-
punchoutsb
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 5842
- Joined: 16 Sep 2009, 01:05
Re: MMA
Checking the results today I'm not surprised by any, but it seems a lot of people are upset about Holm getting cheap shotted twice after the bell? People acting like it cost her the first and she was robbed on the cards.
Jacare needs his title shot NOW. This guy has been in line and deserving for like two years now. Give him his shot, no one else deserves it more. He's being treated very unfairly.
Jacare needs his title shot NOW. This guy has been in line and deserving for like two years now. Give him his shot, no one else deserves it more. He's being treated very unfairly.
Re: MMA
Romero just destroyed Weidman so he does deserve it more but they both deserve their shot without having to fight again.punchoutsb wrote:Checking the results today I'm not surprised by any, but it seems a lot of people are upset about Holm getting cheap shotted twice after the bell? People acting like it cost her the first and she was robbed on the cards.
Jacare needs his title shot NOW. This guy has been in line and deserving for like two years now. Give him his shot, no one else deserves it more. He's being treated very unfairly.
-
punchoutsb
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 5842
- Joined: 16 Sep 2009, 01:05
Re: MMA
Romero also beat Jacare head to head, but Jacare was *supposed* to get a title shot after beating Mousasi. He's had 4 fights since then, went 3-1 with the lone loss being a SD to Romero. I'm fully behind Jacare on this one.p4p1 wrote:Romero just destroyed Weidman so he does deserve it more but they both deserve their shot without having to fight again.punchoutsb wrote:Checking the results today I'm not surprised by any, but it seems a lot of people are upset about Holm getting cheap shotted twice after the bell? People acting like it cost her the first and she was robbed on the cards.
Jacare needs his title shot NOW. This guy has been in line and deserving for like two years now. Give him his shot, no one else deserves it more. He's being treated very unfairly.
Re: MMA
punchoutsb wrote:Jacare has been very unlucky, he was also due to get a title shot if he beat Rockhold more impressively than Romero beat Weidman at 205. I stated earlier my major issue with the Hendo title shot was that both Romero and Jacare deserved title shots and a 46 year 14th ranked contender certainly didn't deserve one above them.p4p1 wrote:Romero just destroyed Weidman so he does deserve it more but they both deserve their shot without having to fight again.punchoutsb wrote:Checking the results today I'm not surprised by any, but it seems a lot of people are upset about Holm getting cheap shotted twice after the bell? People acting like it cost her the first and she was robbed on the cards.
Jacare needs his title shot NOW. This guy has been in line and deserving for like two years now. Give him his shot, no one else deserves it more. He's being treated very unfairly.
Romero also beat Jacare head to head, but Jacare was *supposed* to get a title shot after beating Mousasi. He's had 4 fights since then, went 3-1 with the lone loss being a SD to Romero. I'm fully behind Jacare on this one.
-
SaadOffTheDeck
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 19602
- Joined: 04 Jun 2009, 07:38
Re: MMA
I had the same kind of confidence with that superfight as I did with holyfield over Tyson for years. It wouldn't be a thriller but gsp by wide decision woukd have been as close to a lock as you get.Counter-puncher wrote:Ha. As an mma noob I thought GSP would do that wrestle-fornicate thing to Silva but what do I knowSaadOffTheDeck wrote:He would massacre Silva.Impractical Poster wrote:GSP needs to get his ass back in the picture. Not sure of his current form, but the welterweight division is there for the taking. I'm sure Conor would like to make some money on that fight as well.
-
jujigatame
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 7455
- Joined: 30 Oct 2004, 21:08
Re: MMA
I hope they can work out Bisping/Romero soon. I'm sure Romero will be the favorite, but Bisping has pulled off upsets before, and Romero is damn near 40.
I wouldn't mind seeing Rockhold/Jacare II for the next title shot. I know people think Jacare deserves it now, but I prefer he win a proper contender match to him sitting on the shelf for 8-9 months.
I wouldn't mind seeing Rockhold/Jacare II for the next title shot. I know people think Jacare deserves it now, but I prefer he win a proper contender match to him sitting on the shelf for 8-9 months.
-
punchoutsb
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 5842
- Joined: 16 Sep 2009, 01:05
Re: MMA
That's a 5-0 fight for GSP, I was saying that all along as well. I like Anderson, but man his hype was beyond belief. He was very good, but nowhere near as good as they sold him to be.SaadOffTheDeck wrote:I had the same kind of confidence with that superfight as I did with holyfield over Tyson for years. It wouldn't be a thriller but gsp by wide decision woukd have been as close to a lock as you get.Counter-puncher wrote:Ha. As an mma noob I thought GSP would do that wrestle-fornicate thing to Silva but what do I knowSaadOffTheDeck wrote:
He would massacre Silva.
-
Impractical Poster
- Middleweight
- Posts: 7636
- Joined: 18 Jun 2014, 07:28
Re: MMA
It's hard to deny how good he was when he beat the likes of Henderson, Belfort, Maia, Franklin, then moved up a weight class and dominated two guys there, one of which was a former LHW champion... all in the same run. I just think GSP would have had issues with the movement and size of Silva. What happens if GSP can't take Silva down?punchoutsb wrote:That's a 5-0 fight for GSP, I was saying that all along as well. I like Anderson, but man his hype was beyond belief. He was very good, but nowhere near as good as they sold him to be.SaadOffTheDeck wrote:I had the same kind of confidence with that superfight as I did with holyfield over Tyson for years. It wouldn't be a thriller but gsp by wide decision woukd have been as close to a lock as you get.Counter-puncher wrote:
Ha. As an mma noob I thought GSP would do that wrestle-fornicate thing to Silva but what do I know
-
SaadOffTheDeck
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 19602
- Joined: 04 Jun 2009, 07:38
Re: MMA
no reason to think he'd have issues taking him down, if he couldn't he'd be toast. Prime Silva was incredibly explosive, nowhere near the fight IQ of gsp.Impractical Poster wrote:It's hard to deny how good he was when he beat the likes of Henderson, Belfort, Maia, Franklin, then moved up a weight class and dominated two guys there, one of which was a former LHW champion... all in the same run. I just think GSP would have had issues with the movement and size of Silva. What happens if GSP can't take Silva down?punchoutsb wrote:That's a 5-0 fight for GSP, I was saying that all along as well. I like Anderson, but man his hype was beyond belief. He was very good, but nowhere near as good as they sold him to be.SaadOffTheDeck wrote: I had the same kind of confidence with that superfight as I did with holyfield over Tyson for years. It wouldn't be a thriller but gsp by wide decision woukd have been as close to a lock as you get.
Re: MMA
Don't forget he was also for a short time the number 1 WW in the world.Impractical Poster wrote:It's hard to deny how good he was when he beat the likes of Henderson, Belfort, Maia, Franklin, then moved up a weight class and dominated two guys there, one of which was a former LHW champion... all in the same run. I just think GSP would have had issues with the movement and size of Silva. What happens if GSP can't take Silva down?punchoutsb wrote:That's a 5-0 fight for GSP, I was saying that all along as well. I like Anderson, but man his hype was beyond belief. He was very good, but nowhere near as good as they sold him to be.SaadOffTheDeck wrote: I had the same kind of confidence with that superfight as I did with holyfield over Tyson for years. It wouldn't be a thriller but gsp by wide decision woukd have been as close to a lock as you get.
Silva offered to meet at 177 and GSP still didn't want it. Obviously he didn't think it was going to be as open and shut as Saad did. It would be interesting strategically though because Silva would nullify his jab by being Silva and GSP would be wary of throwing it for fear of a counter. GSP always was good at timing his TDs off a jab or countering with it, there's no proof he can do that with Silva who would be frustratingly patient and make him throw first. Size, movement, power and speed are all on Silvas side, GSP needs a perfect 25 mins which he is admittedly capable of, Silva needs one mistake either standing or on the ground. GSPs chin was never that great either and who weren't anywhere near Silvas level hurt him during his prime.
-
SaadOffTheDeck
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 19602
- Joined: 04 Jun 2009, 07:38
Re: MMA
Speed and movement? Surely you're joking. Gsp was the more explosive athlete. Surely speed and movement factor in there somewhere?
Re: MMA
He had an explosive double leg but standing Silva was quicker and moved better. GSP certainly wasn't an explosive sticker.SaadOffTheDeck wrote:Speed and movement? Surely you're joking. Gsp was the more explosive athlete. Surely speed and movement factor in there somewhere?
-
SaadOffTheDeck
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 19602
- Joined: 04 Jun 2009, 07:38
Re: MMA
Silly me, I thought MMA had more to it than striking. Yes, of course, Anderson was the far superior striker so that makes him faster and more athletic. Forgive me.p4p1 wrote:He had an explosive double leg but standing Silva was quicker and moved better. GSP certainly wasn't an explosive sticker.SaadOffTheDeck wrote:Speed and movement? Surely you're joking. Gsp was the more explosive athlete. Surely speed and movement factor in there somewhere?
Re: MMA
Yet having one explosive technique makes GSP a better athlete than Anderson? Other than a double leg what did GSP do explosively?SaadOffTheDeck wrote:Silly me, I thought MMA had more to it than striking. Yes, of course, Anderson was the far superior striker so that makes him faster and more athletic. Forgive me.p4p1 wrote:He had an explosive double leg but standing Silva was quicker and moved better. GSP certainly wasn't an explosive sticker.SaadOffTheDeck wrote:Speed and movement? Surely you're joking. Gsp was the more explosive athlete. Surely speed and movement factor in there somewhere?
-
SaadOffTheDeck
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 19602
- Joined: 04 Jun 2009, 07:38
Re: MMA
Jon Jones is the only MMA guy that approaches gsp athletically. He's a fast twitch athlete with few peers. I thought everyone knew that. The takedown and brains are the winning formula, closing the distance and the timing of the takedown are where his superior athleticism comes into play. Obviously Anderson could stop him, doesn't mean he would.
Re: MMA
Really? Yoel Romero? Jose Aldo? Jacare? Mendes? All are just as athletic as GSP was. Your definition of an athletic guy seems to be someone who has great TDs. Those 4 guys I mentioned are all explosive grapplers and strikers. Jones and GSP aren't explosive strikers at all.SaadOffTheDeck wrote:Jon Jones is the only MMA guy that approaches gsp athletically. He's a fast twitch athlete with few peers. I thought everyone knew that. The takedown and brains are the winning formula, closing the distance and the timing of the takedown are where his superior athleticism comes into play. Obviously Anderson could stop him, doesn't mean he would.
-
SaadOffTheDeck
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 19602
- Joined: 04 Jun 2009, 07:38
Re: MMA
Romero is in that league. The rest fall clearly short. You have severe comprehension issues.p4p1 wrote:Really? Yoel Romero? Jose Aldo? Jacare? Mendes? All are just as athletic as GSP was. Your definition of an athletic guy seems to be someone who has great TDs. Those 4 guys I mentioned are all explosive grapplers and strikers. Jones and GSP aren't explosive strikers at all.SaadOffTheDeck wrote:Jon Jones is the only MMA guy that approaches gsp athletically. He's a fast twitch athlete with few peers. I thought everyone knew that. The takedown and brains are the winning formula, closing the distance and the timing of the takedown are where his superior athleticism comes into play. Obviously Anderson could stop him, doesn't mean he would.
Re: MMA
Nope they really don't, if you're talking pure athleticism all are clearly in Jones' and GSPs league. Mendes is the weak link but those other 3 are all crazy athletes at least on the level of Jones and GSP. GSP shows excited explosiveness in one technique Jones relies a lot on leverage from being longer, the other guys are explosive in every technique.SaadOffTheDeck wrote:Romero is in that league. The rest fall clearly short. You have severe comprehension issues.p4p1 wrote:Really? Yoel Romero? Jose Aldo? Jacare? Mendes? All are just as athletic as GSP was. Your definition of an athletic guy seems to be someone who has great TDs. Those 4 guys I mentioned are all explosive grapplers and strikers. Jones and GSP aren't explosive strikers at all.SaadOffTheDeck wrote:Jon Jones is the only MMA guy that approaches gsp athletically. He's a fast twitch athlete with few peers. I thought everyone knew that. The takedown and brains are the winning formula, closing the distance and the timing of the takedown are where his superior athleticism comes into play. Obviously Anderson could stop him, doesn't mean he would.
Last edited by p4p1 on 13 Feb 2017, 21:34, edited 1 time in total.