BoxRec Top 5
-
JAHamilton77
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 613
- Joined: 06 Mar 2006, 13:14
BoxRec Top 5
Is it possible that boxrec top 5 P4P is the actual top 5 P4P for once? Just in a different order than you might have them.
-
dagilechia
- Super Middleweight
- Posts: 5319
- Joined: 09 Apr 2013, 08:43
Re: BoxRec Top 5
my top 5 is:
1.Crawford (boxrec's 2)
2.Lomachenko (boxrec's 5)
3.Joshua (boxrec's 7)
4.Golovkin (boxrec's 6)
5.Alvarez (boxrec's 1)
i do not include Ward because outcomes of his Kovalev fights are disgusting.
worth to mention that Mayweather is added to the rank again as no 4 but i do not want to include him in my top 5 as he is in fact a retired fighter.
so i pretty much agree with boxrec
1.Crawford (boxrec's 2)
2.Lomachenko (boxrec's 5)
3.Joshua (boxrec's 7)
4.Golovkin (boxrec's 6)
5.Alvarez (boxrec's 1)
i do not include Ward because outcomes of his Kovalev fights are disgusting.
worth to mention that Mayweather is added to the rank again as no 4 but i do not want to include him in my top 5 as he is in fact a retired fighter.
so i pretty much agree with boxrec
-
SaadOffTheDeck
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 19602
- Joined: 04 Jun 2009, 07:38
Re: BoxRec Top 5
Crawford
Spence
GGG
Loma
Ward
Spence
GGG
Loma
Ward
Re: BoxRec Top 5
Canelo would not be in my top 5 and maybe not in top 10 either. Ward is a fake No. 1 by Ring Magazine and it means nothing. I think Crawford, Lomachenko, and Golovkin should be top 3, not necessarily in that order. Basically, I disagree with boxrec having Ward, Canelo, and Mayweather among the best P4P, but I understand because it is computerized.
-
boxing_rocks
- Welterweight
- Posts: 7851
- Joined: 20 May 2016, 13:11
Re: BoxRec Top 5
JAHamilton77, please create a poll with
Lomachenko
Crawford
Golovkin
Spence
Ward
Thurman
Joshua
Rigo
Inoue
Usyk
and allow 3-5 votes. Let's see what the poll says.
Lomachenko
Crawford
Golovkin
Spence
Ward
Thurman
Joshua
Rigo
Inoue
Usyk
and allow 3-5 votes. Let's see what the poll says.
Re: BoxRec Top 5
Whoa... good to see you're still breathing..JAHamilton77 wrote:Is it possible that boxrec top 5 P4P is the actual top 5 P4P for once? Just in a different order than you might have them.
-
Impractical Poster
- Middleweight
- Posts: 7636
- Joined: 18 Jun 2014, 07:28
Re: BoxRec Top 5
Ward
Crawford
Lomachenko
Garcia
GGG
Crawford
Lomachenko
Garcia
GGG
-
tiny_acres
- Middleweight
- Posts: 9453
- Joined: 17 Feb 2014, 14:43
Re: BoxRec Top 5
Crawford
Ward
GGG
Spence
Lomenchenko
Ward
GGG
Spence
Lomenchenko
Re: BoxRec Top 5
Agree, glad to see you are alive JA.JCS wrote:Whoa... good to see you're still breathing..JAHamilton77 wrote:Is it possible that boxrec top 5 P4P is the actual top 5 P4P for once? Just in a different order than you might have them.
Re: BoxRec Top 5
1 loma
2 crawford
3 GGG
4-5 i am unsure on 4 and 5. Ward lost first kovalev fight and second was a dq loss. Kovalev on the other hand didnt look good. Canelo lost to lara and lara didnt do much since his win over canelo. Gonzales had a close fight with wangek. I think 4 should be jacobs, he looked very impressiv against who many called p4p #1 GGG. Thurman, canelo or spence. One of those should be 5. I ll go with canelo 5.
2 crawford
3 GGG
4-5 i am unsure on 4 and 5. Ward lost first kovalev fight and second was a dq loss. Kovalev on the other hand didnt look good. Canelo lost to lara and lara didnt do much since his win over canelo. Gonzales had a close fight with wangek. I think 4 should be jacobs, he looked very impressiv against who many called p4p #1 GGG. Thurman, canelo or spence. One of those should be 5. I ll go with canelo 5.
Re: BoxRec Top 5
Finaly somebody thinks the way i think.RScarf1 wrote:Canelo would not be in my top 5 and maybe not in top 10 either. Ward is a fake No. 1 by Ring Magazine and it means nothing. I think Crawford, Lomachenko, and Golovkin should be top 3, not necessarily in that order. Basically, I disagree with boxrec having Ward, Canelo, and Mayweather among the best P4P, but I understand because it is computerized.
Re: BoxRec Top 5
Who the f*ck has Usyk, Inoue, or Thurman in their top 5? It's such a joke that you bothered to include these guys and not Alvarez. Stupid. Even Leo Santa Cruz should easily be above Usyk and Inoue, probably Thurman as well.boxing_rocks wrote:JAHamilton77, please create a poll with
Lomachenko
Crawford
Golovkin
Spence
Ward
Thurman
Joshua
Rigo
Inoue
Usyk
and allow 3-5 votes. Let's see what the poll says.
-
boxing_rocks
- Welterweight
- Posts: 7851
- Joined: 20 May 2016, 13:11
Re: BoxRec Top 5
I actually agree about Usyk. Just didn't want to hear questions why I didn't include him. Alvarez would still not get into the top 10.Lackeos wrote:Who the f*ck has Usyk, Inoue, or Thurman in their top 5? It's such a joke that you bothered to include these guys and not Alvarez. Stupid. Even Leo Santa Cruz should easily be above Usyk and Inoue, probably Thurman as well.boxing_rocks wrote:JAHamilton77, please create a poll with
Lomachenko
Crawford
Golovkin
Spence
Ward
Thurman
Joshua
Rigo
Inoue
Usyk
and allow 3-5 votes. Let's see what the poll says.
Re: BoxRec Top 5
Mayweather has been removed from boxrec pound for pound top 5. Now, they show Mayweather as inactive status, so he can't be rated.
Re: BoxRec Top 5
Mayweather (after he takes Connor to school)tiny_acres wrote:Crawford
Ward
GGG
Spence
Lomenchenko
Ward
Canelo
GGG (will be No 2 after he KOs Canelo)
Crawford
Lomachenko
Re: BoxRec Top 5
Crawford
Golovkin
Lomachenko
Alvarez
Joshua

Golovkin
Lomachenko
Alvarez
Joshua
Re: BoxRec Top 5
1) Lomachenko
2) Crawford
3) Joshua
4) GGG
5) Ward
2) Crawford
3) Joshua
4) GGG
5) Ward
Re: BoxRec Top 5
1. Ward
2. Crawford
3. GGG
4. Lomo
5. Rigo
2. Crawford
3. GGG
4. Lomo
5. Rigo