Who would beat Golovkin at MW, past or present?

[VG_Addict]

Is there any MW past or present that you would favor over GGG?

I would favor RJJ and Toney over him.

[ewenhay]

Is there any MW past or present that you would favor over GGG?

I would favor RJJ and Toney over him.

I'd fancy quite a lot to beat him prime for prime.

Whilst I think he's a good champion I think he's over rated historically because of the number of defences he's had against comparatively weak opposition in this era.

[jamamb]

hopkins clowns him

[Loki]

Very difficult to compare eras. GGG would give BHOP, Monzon, Hagler and Toney problems. Impossible to say who’d come out on top prime for prime but fcuking great fights.

RJJ was more 168.

[gilgamesh]

Obviously any of the Greats would be live dogs against him. Robinson, Monzon, Hagler, Greb...whatever.

I'd be curious to know how he'd fare against tough, durable pressure fighters like Jake Lamotta and Gene Fullmer. We've never really seen anybody back up Golovkin all throughout a bout, it'd be interesting if these guys could.

[Ruthless-RKO]

hopkins clowns him

Clown? How? I rate Hopkins more at LHW tbh.

[jamamb]

even jermain taylor wouldve had a very good chance to beat him

[Loki]

hopkins clowns him

Clown? How? I rate Hopkins more at LHW tbh.

Nobody is clowning GGG. He might lose a fire fight was Hagler or Monzon and could be outboxed by BHOP or Toney, but any of those fight are pick’ems.

[Loki]

even jermain taylor wouldve had a very good chance to beat him

Have you been taking stupid pills?

[Loki]

Obviously any of the Greats would be live dogs against him. Robinson, Monzon, Hagler, Greb...whatever.

I'd be curious to know how he'd fare against tough, durable pressure fighters like Jake Lamotta and Gene Fullmer. We've never really seen anybody back up Golovkin all throughout a bout, it'd be interesting if these guys could.

Robinson beats GGG; that’s a certain in my book. The others, impossible to tell really.

[jamamb]

danny jacobs easily couldve gotten the decision, taylor had plenty of speed and enough skill to give ggg the same type of problems. ggg is plodding and easy to hit even for lower level opponents

[Loki]

danny jacobs easily couldve gotten the decision, taylor had plenty of speed and enough skill to give ggg the same type of problems. ggg is plodding and easy to hit even for lower level opponents

I rate Jacobs a lot more than Taylor. The only recent fighter who had a shot to beat GGG was Pirog.

Can I just ask all; who was BHOPS best win at 160?

[gilgamesh]

danny jacobs easily couldve gotten the decision, taylor had plenty of speed and enough skill to give ggg the same type of problems. ggg is plodding and easy to hit even for lower level opponents

I rate Jacobs a lot more than Taylor. The only recent fighter who had a shot to beat GGG was Pirog.

Can I just ask all; who was BHOPS best win at 160?

Tito Trinidad or maybe Glen Johnson or Antwun Echols

[Loki]

danny jacobs easily couldve gotten the decision, taylor had plenty of speed and enough skill to give ggg the same type of problems. ggg is plodding and easy to hit even for lower level opponents

I rate Jacobs a lot more than Taylor. The only recent fighter who had a shot to beat GGG was Pirog.

Can I just ask all; who was BHOPS best win at 160?

Tito Trinidad or maybe Glen Johnson or Antwun Echols

Not that great really. Tito jumped up from Super Welter (had only one fight at 160) and The Road Warrior had a few loses when they fought. RJJ also beat him at 160 and he lost Taylor.

I’d take GGG wins over Jacobs and Canelo (he won on my card).

I think Robinson, Hagler and Monzon have better records or at least better wins, at 160 than GGG and BHOP.

[ewenhay]

I rate Jacobs a lot more than Taylor. The only recent fighter who had a shot to beat GGG was Pirog.

Can I just ask all; who was BHOPS best win at 160?

Tito Trinidad or maybe Glen Johnson or Antwun Echols

Not that great really. Tito jumped up from Super Welter (had only one fight at 160) and The Road Warrior had a few loses when they fought. RJJ also beat him at 160 and he lost Taylor.

I’d take GGG wins over Jacobs and Canelo (he won on my card).

I think Robinson, Hagler and Monzon have better records or at least better wins, at 160 than GGG and BHOP.

I would agree but would add that Hopkins' opposition at middleweight would be a deeper talent pool than Golovkin's overall.

[gilgamesh]

I rate Jacobs a lot more than Taylor. The only recent fighter who had a shot to beat GGG was Pirog.

Can I just ask all; who was BHOPS best win at 160?

Tito Trinidad or maybe Glen Johnson or Antwun Echols

Not that great really. Tito jumped up from Super Welter (had only one fight at 160) and The Road Warrior had a few loses when they fought. RJJ also beat him at 160 and he lost Taylor.

I’d take GGG wins over Jacobs and Canelo (he won on my card).

I think Robinson, Hagler and Monzon have better records or at least better wins, at 160 than GGG and BHOP.

No as a matter of fact Hopkins was the first person to ever defeat Glen Johnson. Glen was 32-0 heading into that one.

[gilgamesh]

I rate Jacobs a lot more than Taylor. The only recent fighter who had a shot to beat GGG was Pirog.

Can I just ask all; who was BHOPS best win at 160?

Tito Trinidad or maybe Glen Johnson or Antwun Echols

Not that great really. Tito jumped up from Super Welter (had only one fight at 160) and The Road Warrior had a few loses when they fought. RJJ also beat him at 160 and he lost Taylor.

I’d take GGG wins over Jacobs and Canelo (he won on my card).

I think Robinson, Hagler and Monzon have better records or at least better wins, at 160 than GGG and BHOP.

They absolutely do

[Loki]

Tito Trinidad or maybe Glen Johnson or Antwun Echols

Not that great really. Tito jumped up from Super Welter (had only one fight at 160) and The Road Warrior had a few loses when they fought. RJJ also beat him at 160 and he lost Taylor.

I’d take GGG wins over Jacobs and Canelo (he won on my card).

I think Robinson, Hagler and Monzon have better records or at least better wins, at 160 than GGG and BHOP.

No as a matter of fact Hopkins was the first person to ever defeat Glen Johnson. Glen was 32-0 heading into that one.

I guess I should check BoxRec before posting. I could’ve sworn he’d lost a few early fights. I stand corrected. But, I still take GGG win over Jacobs and the W he should’ve got over Canelo.

[Loki]

Tito Trinidad or maybe Glen Johnson or Antwun Echols

Not that great really. Tito jumped up from Super Welter (had only one fight at 160) and The Road Warrior had a few loses when they fought. RJJ also beat him at 160 and he lost Taylor.

I’d take GGG wins over Jacobs and Canelo (he won on my card).

I think Robinson, Hagler and Monzon have better records or at least better wins, at 160 than GGG and BHOP.

They absolutely do

Shame Monzon and Hagler missed each other; slightly different eras.

[BitPlayer]

On top of some of the ones mentioned, I'd include Bob Fitzsimmons.

[gilgamesh]

Not that great really. Tito jumped up from Super Welter (had only one fight at 160) and The Road Warrior had a few loses when they fought. RJJ also beat him at 160 and he lost Taylor.

I’d take GGG wins over Jacobs and Canelo (he won on my card).

I think Robinson, Hagler and Monzon have better records or at least better wins, at 160 than GGG and BHOP.

No as a matter of fact Hopkins was the first person to ever defeat Glen Johnson. Glen was 32-0 heading into that one.

I guess I should check BoxRec before posting. I could’ve sworn he’d lost a few early fights. I stand corrected. But, I still take GGG win over Jacobs and the W he should’ve got over Canelo.

Yeah I had him beating Canelo wider than he beat Jacobs personally.

[boxing_rocks]

even jermain taylor wouldve had a very good chance to beat him

Have you been taking stupid pills?

No need. He was born stupid.

[boxing_rocks]

Records don't fight in the ring. The only guys I would give chances against Golovkin are Hagler and Leonard.

[Ilya Muromets]

Is there any MW past or present that you would favor over GGG?

...

No, i don't think so.

[SenorPipino]

Canelo today. Maybe Charlo. Possibly Saunders.

All time.....Hagler, Monzon, Valdes, Benvenuti, Hopkins, LaMotta, Toney (Nunn probably) and SRR.

Greb sounds like he whups Golovkin but I've never seen him in action so I hesitate to include him in these hypothetical discussions.

But Greb would really have Golovkin whining. He was one of the dirtiest guys ever and he was very effective with his treachery.