Do you consider Andrade a better 160lbs fighter than Jermall Charlo?

[apollo creed]

What do you think?

[boxing_rocks]

No. It is easy to show boxing circus against limited opponents. Even Charlo may be too much for Andrade.

[Onetimeonly]

No, charlo is tighter.

[dagilechia]

Andrade vs Charlo would be 120-108 for DA

[Onetimeonly]

Andrade vs Charlo would be 120-108 for DA

Not in a million years.

[Enlightened-One]

Demetrius Andrade has a deeply unimpressive resume.

[dagilechia]

Demetrius Andrade has a deeply unimpressive resume.

better than Charlo though

[Enlightened-One]

better than Charlo though

Nope.

[Onetimeonly]

better than Charlo though

No he doesn't. I know sulecki is your boy but he's not in Williams or trout's league. Korobov is better too.

[dagilechia]

Nope.

what makes Charlo's resume better? it's worse + he lost to Korobov

[jamamb]

hard to say, theyve both been fighting lacklustre opponents. andrade seems more fluid and better defensively to me, but charlo more powerful and more willing to step on the gas

[apollo creed]

No. It is easy to show boxing circus against limited opponents. Even Charlo may be too much for Andrade.

Well Charlo fought Centeno Jr, Heiland, Korobov and Adams.

Andrade fought Kautondokwa, Akavov and Sulecki.

I'd say that both have lacklustre resumes and performance @160lbs but objectively speaking Andrade beat a better ranked mw than Charlo's.

[jamamb]

williams is probably the best opponent either fought, charlo bombed him out. could be that charlo needs better opponents to really shine. he certanly hasnt been impressive his last two but to me he looked uninterested

[Nondescript]

williams is probably the best opponent either fought, charlo bombed him out. could be that charlo needs better opponents to really shine. he certanly hasnt been impressive his last two but to me he looked uninterested

Andrade has never fought Williams has he?! Unless you're talking about the amateurs.

*Edit- I know what you mean now.

[apollo creed]

Demetrius Andrade has a deeply unimpressive resume.

Like Charlo has some mw ATG worthy resume?! lol

[apollo creed]

No he doesn't. I know sulecki is your boy but he's not in Williams or trout's league. Korobov is better too.

"a better 160lbs fighter", NOT a better 154-160lbs fighter.

[Nondescript]

It's hard to tell I think. Andrade's style is boring af overall admittedly, but then so is Billy Joe Saunders or Erislandy Lara's but they're still very skilled fighters.

It would probably be a boring ass fight to be honest and Andrade would be guilty of playing a big part in that (even though I've defended him on here)

[apollo creed]

hard to say, theyve both been fighting lacklustre opponents. andrade seems more fluid and better defensively to me, but charlo more powerful and more willing to step on the gas

Yup. Charlo is more willing to trade and fire back.

[Nondescript]

Like Charlo has some mw ATG worthy resume?! lol

Don't- he'll respond with "I never said those words! "

He likes to play the ignorant role when it suits him.

[boxing_rocks]

It's hard to tell I think. Andrade's style is boring af overall admittedly, but then so is Billy Joe Saunders or Erislandy Lara's but they're still very skilled fighters.

It would probably be a boring ass fight to be honest and Andrade would be guilty of playing a big part in that (even though I've defended him on here)

Saunders was landing good shots on Lemieux. Andrade throws wild punches which are missing. Didn't land anything of a note on Sulecki.

[Nondescript]

Saunders was landing good shots on Lemieux. Andrade throws wild punches which are missing. Didn't land anything of a note on Sulecki.

I'm not gonna defend Andrade against Sulecki as it was a terrible fight to watch.

That said though, I think Sulecki is a better all around fighter than lemieux. He doesn't possess the lights out power that David does, but if you look at his Sulecki's fight with Jacobs, he actually pushed Jacobs more than he did Andrade, and Jacobs is a proven top level fighter.

[apollo creed]

Don't- he'll respond with "I never said those words! "

He likes to play the ignorant role when it suits him.

Lol, True.

Or even better said:

User Datsue described very well this type of attention seeker-troll like E.O :

" Intelligent or not, he's a complete disingenuous arsehole who cloaks his own opinions in a veneer of bullshit while pretending that he's in fact impartial.
Yet watch him when it's someone he doesn't have a gaping wide-on for in the dock...!
It's like listening to one of those right-wing media types who thinks that saying the word "fact" can simply make inconvenient things that they don't like go away, & that if they keep thrashing things out in a long-winded convoluted fashion you'll lose sight of consensus reality & accept their Byzantine version of events that—despite their constant appeals to some sort of "objectivity"—is only supported by their opinions & their bullshit rhetoric. "

[DrDuke]

Andrade is better. He's more special.

[Nondescript]

Haha.

Me and Datsue haven't always seen eye to eye over the years, but he's a smart guy and that's a pretty spot on assessment.

[dagilechia]

he would make Charlo look hopeless