Who took the worse beating?

[oogiebe]

Wilder took the worse beating. At least AJ had his moments including dropping Ruiz and winning rounds.

[ALI]

There are many similarities, as I mentioned in another thread.

Joshua managed to fight back and landed a few big shots after he was hurt. Wilder tried but was unable to get anything to land clean.

That probably says more about the standard of there respective opponents though.

Really?

What about the Klitschko fight then? That was an absolute war, but still a very highly skilled affair between two elite and highly skilled heavyweights. Josh was in against one of the most dominant fighters of our times, and came out best after a complete barnstormer, one of the very best fights in heavyweight history. If you have forgotten, like many seem to, go watch it again and remind yourself just how good Joshua was that night. The lad has the heart of a champion, and will give Fury one hell of a fight.

Joshua is getting too much stick on here.

[Stuarty]

There are many similarities, as I mentioned in another thread.

Joshua managed to fight back and landed a few big shots after he was hurt. Wilder tried but was unable to get anything to land clean.

That probably says more about the standard of there respective opponents though.

Really?

What about the Klitschko fight then? That was an absolute war, but still a very highly skilled affair between two elite and highly skilled heavyweights. Josh was in against one of the most dominant fighters of our times, and came out best after a complete barnstormer, one of the very best fights in heavyweight history. If you have forgotten, like many seem to, go watch it again and remind yourself just how good Joshua was that night. The lad has the heart of a champion, and will give Fury one hell of a fight.

Joshua is getting too much stick on here.

Think people just get pissed off with all the hype from Sky and Matchroom and all the drivel spouted by the casuals. He comes across fake to me and i'm not a fan of him away from the ring. He bores me but he's a good fighter and i usually enjoy watching him fight. I think Fury will beat him by late stoppage if his head is right but it's by no means a sure thing as you say... Still can't see it happening till next summer at the earliest though.

[keirw]

There are many similarities, as I mentioned in another thread.

Joshua managed to fight back and landed a few big shots after he was hurt. Wilder tried but was unable to get anything to land clean.

That probably says more about the standard of there respective opponents though.

Really?

What about the Klitschko fight then? That was an absolute war, but still a very highly skilled affair between two elite and highly skilled heavyweights. Josh was in against one of the most dominant fighters of our times, and came out best after a complete barnstormer, one of the very best fights in heavyweight history. If you have forgotten, like many seem to, go watch it again and remind yourself just how good Joshua was that night. The lad has the heart of a champion, and will give Fury one hell of a fight.

Joshua is getting too much stick on here.

Not sure you read my post properly, I was comparing AJ's loss to Ruiz and Wilder's loss to Fury.

I didn't mention the Klitshcko fight, as that fight (as good as it was) is irrelevant to my post.

You may have me mistaken for one of the many AJ haters on here.

[ALI]

Really?

What about the Klitschko fight then? That was an absolute war, but still a very highly skilled affair between two elite and highly skilled heavyweights. Josh was in against one of the most dominant fighters of our times, and came out best after a complete barnstormer, one of the very best fights in heavyweight history. If you have forgotten, like many seem to, go watch it again and remind yourself just how good Joshua was that night. The lad has the heart of a champion, and will give Fury one hell of a fight.

Joshua is getting too much stick on here.

Not sure you read my post properly, I was comparing AJ's loss to Ruiz and Wilder's loss to Fury.

I didn't mention the Klitshcko fight, as that fight (as good as it was) is irrelevant to my post.

You may have me mistaken for one of the many AJ haters on here.

I'm not interested in your past posts on AJ.

Its cool, i was high as a kite when i wrote that post, thought you were incorrectly down playing Joshua.

[ALI]

Really?

What about the Klitschko fight then? That was an absolute war, but still a very highly skilled affair between two elite and highly skilled heavyweights. Josh was in against one of the most dominant fighters of our times, and came out best after a complete barnstormer, one of the very best fights in heavyweight history. If you have forgotten, like many seem to, go watch it again and remind yourself just how good Joshua was that night. The lad has the heart of a champion, and will give Fury one hell of a fight.

Joshua is getting too much stick on here.

Think people just get pissed off with all the hype from Sky and Matchroom and all the drivel spouted by the casuals. He comes across fake to me and i'm not a fan of him away from the ring. He bores me but he's a good fighter and i usually enjoy watching him fight. I think Fury will beat him by late stoppage if his head is right but it's by no means a sure thing as you say... Still can't see it happening till next summer at the earliest though.

Hope you are wrong about the date, but no surprises if it does drag out, such an occurrance is one of boxings biggest flaws.

Its another pick em fight, i just feel, on the back of Furys win over Wilder, many people have gone to sleep on Joshua's chances against Fury, which is crazy.

Joshua is far more skilled than Wilder. His shots are heavy, thuding blows, and i believe his power can seriously trouble Fury. My gut is telling me Joshua KO's him, but i can easily make a case for either winning. Great fight, boxing needs it to happen this summer.

[TheGman]

Well one thing my missus said, and she is a complete casusal, was that Wilder took his licks, kept swinging, then complained they stopped it and clearly meant it. Compare that to Josh,.....

So wilder took the bigger beating then or joshua? Joshua took his defeat like a man and mad amends,wilder has blamed the ref,his corner,the suit,anthony dirrell. Wilder took the píss out of AJ for his defeat but Wilder got a bigger hiding if you ask me lol

[TheLeprechaun]

Well one thing my missus said, and she is a complete casusal, was that Wilder took his licks, kept swinging, then complained they stopped it and clearly meant it. Compare that to Josh,.....

So wilder took the bigger beating then or joshua? Joshua took his defeat like a man and mad amends,wilder has blamed the ref,his corner,the suit,anthony dirrell. Wilder took the píss out of AJ for his defeat but Wilder got a bigger hiding if you ask me lol

Yeah but we see the difference in mentality between Wilder and Joshua. Both were beaten fighters but one of them showed he had no quit in him while the other looked to have plenty of quit in him at the end. One was laughing in the ring afterward while the other was devastated.

I think Wilder believes his excuses are valid reasons for his beating, which seems completely delusional to us but it shows his mentality is there. I think he can come back and be mentally strong enough to genuinely believe he will starch Fury or Joshua in there.

I also watched the fight with some casuals and they commented on Wilders heart. Joshua failed that test i'm afraid in the first Ruiz fight and I'm not to sure what Wlad was doing letting Joshua off the hook as the finish was there. Wlad is Wlad though, he's probably got the least heart of all I've mentioned above.

[danconnollyeire]

So wilder took the bigger beating then or joshua? Joshua took his defeat like a man and mad amends,wilder has blamed the ref,his corner,the suit,anthony dirrell. Wilder took the píss out of AJ for his defeat but Wilder got a bigger hiding if you ask me lol

Yeah but we see the difference in mentality between Wilder and Joshua. Both were beaten fighters but one of them showed he had no quit in him while the other looked to have plenty of quit in him at the end. One was laughing in the ring afterward while the other was devastated.

I think Wilder believes his excuses are valid reasons for his beating, which seems completely delusional to us but it shows his mentality is there. I think he can come back and be mentally strong enough to genuinely believe he will starch Fury or Joshua in there.

I also watched the fight with some casuals and they commented on Wilders heart. Joshua failed that test i'm afraid in the first Ruiz fight and I'm not to sure what Wlad was doing letting Joshua off the hook as the finish was there. Wlad is Wlad though, he's probably got the least heart of all I've mentioned above.

Deontay ‘I wanna murder a guy’ Wilder called... wants his dick back

[TheLeprechaun]

Yeah but we see the difference in mentality between Wilder and Joshua. Both were beaten fighters but one of them showed he had no quit in him while the other looked to have plenty of quit in him at the end. One was laughing in the ring afterward while the other was devastated.

I think Wilder believes his excuses are valid reasons for his beating, which seems completely delusional to us but it shows his mentality is there. I think he can come back and be mentally strong enough to genuinely believe he will starch Fury or Joshua in there.

I also watched the fight with some casuals and they commented on Wilders heart. Joshua failed that test i'm afraid in the first Ruiz fight and I'm not to sure what Wlad was doing letting Joshua off the hook as the finish was there. Wlad is Wlad though, he's probably got the least heart of all I've mentioned above.

Deontay ‘I wanna murder a guy’ Wilder called... wants his dick back

Wilder is never going to be mistaken for Monzon in the skills department but in terms of heart I think he has reserved the right to be given credit for having elite heart.

[oogiebe]

Deontay ‘I wanna murder a guy’ Wilder called... wants his dick back

Wilder is never going to be mistaken for Monzon in the skills department but in terms of heart I think he has reserved the right to be given credit for having elite heart.

He'll never get credit for any of his assets from some. If folks insist on calling him a bum or chicken or anything else, it only takes away from the great win Fury had. Doesn't make much sense. He's still a very dangerous fighter. Not sure if anyone else could exploit DW's lack of skills without getting smashed up.

[TheLeprechaun]

Wilder is never going to be mistaken for Monzon in the skills department but in terms of heart I think he has reserved the right to be given credit for having elite heart.

He'll never get credit for any of his assets from some. If folks insist on calling him a bum or chicken or anything else, it only takes away from the great win Fury had. Doesn't make much sense. He's still a very dangerous fighter. Not sure if anyone else could exploit DW's lack of skills without getting smashed up.

Well even though the key seems to be to put Wilder on the backfoot, few have tried, due to being petrified of getting done themselves. Ortiz had the skill to give it a go on the front foot in patches and got done brutally for his troubles. It took Furys balls, skills and size to do it which was a great achievement. I'd like to see a third fight. Wilder now knows Fury can use bully tactics and push him back so I reckon he would call upon his inner Ricardo Mayorga from the first bell this time and stand his ground and go out swinging. I wouldn't count him out entirely in a rematch but you have to make Fury a huge favourite.

Also, when you think about it, Mayorga was far more skilled than Wilder, which puts things into perspective.

[danconnollyeire]

Wilder is never going to be mistaken for Monzon in the skills department but in terms of heart I think he has reserved the right to be given credit for having elite heart.

He'll never get credit for any of his assets from some. If folks insist on calling him a bum or chicken or anything else, it only takes away from the great win Fury had. Doesn't make much sense. He's still a very dangerous fighter. Not sure if anyone else could exploit DW's lack of skills without getting smashed up.

Definitely didn’t call him a bum. Cretin yes. Bum no. Some were/are definitely lodged far up it though

[oogiebe]

He'll never get credit for any of his assets from some. If folks insist on calling him a bum or chicken or anything else, it only takes away from the great win Fury had. Doesn't make much sense. He's still a very dangerous fighter. Not sure if anyone else could exploit DW's lack of skills without getting smashed up.

Well even though the key seems to be to put Wilder on the backfoot, few have tried, due to being petrified of getting done themselves. Ortiz had the skill to give it a go on the front foot in patches and got done brutally for his troubles. It took Furys balls, skills and size to do it which was a great achievement. I'd like to see a third fight. Wilder now knows Fury can use bully tactics and push him back so I reckon he would call upon his inner Ricardo Mayorga from the first bell this time and stand his ground and go out swinging. I wouldn't count him out entirely in a rematch but you have to make Fury a huge favourite.

Also, when you think about it, Mayorga was far more skilled than Wilder, which puts things into perspective.

Mayorga was bat shivte crazy, but he had decent skills. Good points.

[coneye]

Said it for ages , Ruiz would beat Wilder i've siad a MOTIVATED Ruiz like he was against AJ stops Wilder ,,, against Fury; Ruiz always, motivated or not gets beat easy by Tyson ... ... Aj stops Wilder has well ,,, Unless he cops that hail Mary punch , he hits harder than Fury but is a bit suss ,, Wilders stanima , when he has to workk just proved questionable , and when he runs out of gas his hail mary don't work we just seen that .

Wow Fury and AJ ,, what happens , well we all know AJ has doubts in the stamina market , but he could ko Fury with one hit .... Furu can wear him down and create stamina problems , but to do it the way he done it with Wilder won't work , cos AJ is a bigger stronger man ,,, to do it by upping the boxing work rate is perhaps riskier than with Wilder ,, because , AJ has more than one hail mary in the bag , he can land hooks and body shots which will worry Fury ,, because when all said and done Fury has proven his chin is'nt much better ,, both have heart , both are big boys ,, and i hav.nt a effing clue who would win ,

alls i can say is bring it on before AJ gets beat ,, or Tyson decides he does'nt want to risk his 0 got enough money and get out to go wrestling , his dad wants him out , Big John is saying my son should retire ,, not my son should KO Aj and prove without doubt who's the King .

And i do believe Tyson listens too his Dad

[ALI]

So wilder took the bigger beating then or joshua? Joshua took his defeat like a man and mad amends,wilder has blamed the ref,his corner,the suit,anthony dirrell. Wilder took the píss out of AJ for his defeat but Wilder got a bigger hiding if you ask me lol

Yeah but we see the difference in mentality between Wilder and Joshua. Both were beaten fighters but one of them showed he had no quit in him while the other looked to have plenty of quit in him at the end. One was laughing in the ring afterward while the other was devastated.

I think Wilder believes his excuses are valid reasons for his beating, which seems completely delusional to us but it shows his mentality is there. I think he can come back and be mentally strong enough to genuinely believe he will starch Fury or Joshua in there.

I also watched the fight with some casuals and they commented on Wilders heart. Joshua failed that test i'm afraid in the first Ruiz fight and I'm not to sure what Wlad was doing letting Joshua off the hook as the finish was there. Wlad is Wlad though, he's probably got the least heart of all I've mentioned above.

One of the most moronic posts i have read on here in a long time, and thats saying something.

Well done, you achieved something today

[keirw]

Said it for ages , Ruiz would beat Wilder i've siad a MOTIVATED Ruiz like he was against AJ stops Wilder ,,, against Fury; Ruiz always, motivated or not gets beat easy by Tyson ... ... Aj stops Wilder has well ,,, Unless he cops that hail Mary punch , he hits harder than Fury but is a bit suss ,, Wilders stanima , when he has to workk just proved questionable , and when he runs out of gas his hail mary don't work we just seen that .

Wow Fury and AJ ,, what happens , well we all know AJ has doubts in the stamina market , but he could ko Fury with one hit .... Furu can wear him down and create stamina problems , but to do it the way he done it with Wilder won't work , cos AJ is a bigger stronger man ,,, to do it by upping the boxing work rate is perhaps riskier than with Wilder ,, because , AJ has more than one hail mary in the bag , he can land hooks and body shots which will worry Fury ,, because when all said and done Fury has proven his chin is'nt much better ,, both have heart , both are big boys ,, and i hav.nt a effing clue who would win ,

alls i can say is bring it on before AJ gets beat ,, or Tyson decides he does'nt want to risk his 0 got enough money and get out to go wrestling , his dad wants him out , Big John is saying my son should retire ,, not my son should KO Aj and prove without doubt who's the King .

And i do believe Tyson listens too his Dad

When asked about a potential AJ fight he said Tyson has already proved he is above that level.

That is a terrible attitude to have imo. Whether or not you believe Wilder is better than AJ, beating one is not the same as beating both.

By Big John's logic, every boxer should retire and the sport should cease to be as Fury is the best there will ever be and there is no point in anyone ever even trying to beat or even emulate him.

It is ridiculous. It also worries me immensely, as John definitely has Tyson's ear. It is no coincidence that John was slating Davison after the Wallin fight, then Davison was dumped before Fury's next fight.

I just hope that Tyson ignores his father on this occasion and tries to unify, or at least defend his title.

[coneye]

I thik people post , about heart , toughness , will to win ect ect ,, when they don't fully understand .

Thers touhgness , and an example being Wilder shown it , he kept getting hit by punches that were hard and caused cuts , knocked him down , so we look at it and say a sustained beating , BUT non of them punches were really hard enough to knock the sences out of him ,, thats why you can get a guy who looks like he's getting mudered , but wants to go on ,, hence Wilder .

Then thers a different scenario where a guy is hurt , ala AJ ,, he takes a shot and whoops its la la land , he does'nt know what the hell is going on and fights on instinct , and cops it again , ALA Aj but this guy comes back and wins the rematch easy ,,, just like Fury did .

What i'm getting at is don't write AJ off he got lamped 100% and still fought on Fury got lamped 100 % and got up to win the round , but both punches were different , one was a very concusive punch the other was not .

Wilder well he just took an 80% power beating and was always convinced he could carry on , he'd probably been hit just has hard in the gym just not has often

[rhino222]

My take on it.

Wilder was fully fit and took a hell of a beating. He showed guts and should be grateful the towel came in.

Joshuas fitness was not 100%. He was far too musclebound and the conspiracy theories revolving aroud sparring etc DO hold substance. Joshuas decision to 'quit' that night potentially saved his career.