David Starie
-
margaret thatcher
- Super Featherweight
- Posts: 39338
- Joined: 22 Jul 2019, 15:43
Re: David Starie
He definitely got the benefit of the doubt, but I don't think he had many full out robberies on the cards. A lot of his fights were genuinely very close and I could see how he could get them. He had a knack for stifling opponents despite being totally absent of any serious raw athletic talent. I respect that he did as well as he did with what he had.
Re: David Starie
The phantom was a great ring moniker for Otkker. He was very slippery and elusive.
He did, however, seem to benefit from some dubious decisions. The Mads Larsen "win" was as bad a decision as I can remember. Far worse than than the Robin Reid decision which wasn't that controversial IMO, although the referee was !
Anthony Mundine seemed to have found the key to beat Otkke, but Sven then pulled out a punch from nowhere and knocked Mundine out cold.
He did, however, seem to benefit from some dubious decisions. The Mads Larsen "win" was as bad a decision as I can remember. Far worse than than the Robin Reid decision which wasn't that controversial IMO, although the referee was !
Anthony Mundine seemed to have found the key to beat Otkke, but Sven then pulled out a punch from nowhere and knocked Mundine out cold.
Re: David Starie
Mundine would've been ahead on the cards had he not 'inadvertantly' put his head in play.THEBUTCH wrote: ↑01 Jun 2020, 19:22 The phantom was a great ring moniker for Otkker. He was very slippery and elusive.
He did, however, seem to benefit from some dubious decisions. The Mads Larsen "win" was as bad a decision as I can remember. Far worse than than the Robin Reid decision which wasn't that controversial IMO, although the referee was !
Anthony Mundine seemed to have found the key to beat Otkke, but Sven then pulled out a punch from nowhere and knocked Mundine out cold.
-
margaret thatcher
- Super Featherweight
- Posts: 39338
- Joined: 22 Jul 2019, 15:43
Re: David Starie
I think Sven brutally ktfo Gatti's brother and put him in the hospital and retired him too funny enough, Sven had hammer hands when he wanted 
Re: David Starie
Probably because he was that rarest of creatures - a successful Germany-based boxer who was actually German
Re: David Starie
A lot about the way boxing is promoted in Germany is straight out of a bad acid flashback. Rammstein playing their shitty cheese-metal in the ring; ring-card girls that somehow manage to look like they belong on a white-collar show in Plymouth; TV camera angles that make the action look like early PlayStation technical demos; referees that give out warnings to foreign fighters for punching local fighters in the face; promoters who openly brag about buying title wins; and for the very best fighters, apparently non-ironic nicknames from 50s B-movies like "Dr Ironfist"
Re: David Starie
I tend to view them with a mix of amusement and envy. Envy because they continue to excel at things we used to be good at, such as football and making massive amounts of complex machinery in exchange for money; amusement because, well, see aboveShhhh wrote: ↑03 Jun 2020, 06:17dookus wrote: ↑03 Jun 2020, 06:12 A lot about the way boxing is promoted in Germany is straight out of a bad acid flashback. Rammstein playing their shitty cheese-metal in the ring; ring-card girls that somehow manage to look like they belong on a white-collar show in Plymouth; TV camera angles that make the action look like early PlayStation technical demos; referees that give out warnings to foreign fighters for punching local fighters in the face; promoters who openly brag about buying title wins; and for the very best fighters, apparently non-ironic nicknames from 50s B-movies like "Dr Ironfist"![]()
![]()
![]()
I don’t think it’s possible to some up german boxing any better
They are a weird bunch the krauts. Personally I’m not that keen on them
![]()
-
My Name Is Earl
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 634
- Joined: 07 Nov 2008, 06:05
Re: David Starie
dookus wrote: ↑03 Jun 2020, 06:12A lot about the way boxing is promoted in Germany is straight out of a bad acid flashback. Rammstein playing their shitty cheese-metal in the ring; ring-card girls that somehow manage to look like they belong on a white-collar show in Plymouth; TV camera angles that make the action look like early PlayStation technical demos; referees that give out warnings to foreign fighters for punching local fighters in the face; promoters who openly brag about buying title wins; and for the very best fighters, apparently non-ironic nicknames from 50s B-movies like "Dr Ironfist"
Didn't Abraham used to ring walk to The Smurfs
Re: David Starie
My Name Is Earl wrote: ↑03 Jun 2020, 06:41dookus wrote: ↑03 Jun 2020, 06:12 A lot about the way boxing is promoted in Germany is straight out of a bad acid flashback. Rammstein playing their shitty cheese-metal in the ring; ring-card girls that somehow manage to look like they belong on a white-collar show in Plymouth; TV camera angles that make the action look like early PlayStation technical demos; referees that give out warnings to foreign fighters for punching local fighters in the face; promoters who openly brag about buying title wins; and for the very best fighters, apparently non-ironic nicknames from 50s B-movies like "Dr Ironfist"![]()
Brilliant. And not even a mention of Kalle's facial expressions and tics.
Didn't Abraham used to ring walk to The Smurfswith Father Abraham in the ring for the preliminaries.
-
My Name Is Earl
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 634
- Joined: 07 Nov 2008, 06:05
Re: David Starie
I don't know if it was ever a possibility, but Calzaghe never entertained the idea of going over there. Their parallel careersoogiebe wrote: ↑01 Jun 2020, 19:38Mundine would've been ahead on the cards had he not 'inadvertantly' put his head in play.THEBUTCH wrote: ↑01 Jun 2020, 19:22 The phantom was a great ring moniker for Otkker. He was very slippery and elusive.
He did, however, seem to benefit from some dubious decisions. The Mads Larsen "win" was as bad a decision as I can remember. Far worse than than the Robin Reid decision which wasn't that controversial IMO, although the referee was !
Anthony Mundine seemed to have found the key to beat Otkke, but Sven then pulled out a punch from nowhere and knocked Mundine out cold.
should have led to a fight but too much risk/reward on show for either? For Joe a judges verdict too dodgy..for
Sven a good chance he would have been sparked out.
Half of Oz celebrated as much as thee Germans when Mundine was starched.
-
My Name Is Earl
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 634
- Joined: 07 Nov 2008, 06:05
Re: David Starie
Was that because The Trotters only traded in London, Paris and New York?dookus wrote: ↑03 Jun 2020, 06:47My Name Is Earl wrote: ↑03 Jun 2020, 06:41
![]()
Brilliant. And not even a mention of Kalle's facial expressions and tics.
Didn't Abraham used to ring walk to The Smurfswith Father Abraham in the ring for the preliminaries.
![]()
fornicating hell, how could I have forgotten that
and yet the cheeky bastards wouldn't let our Del Boy enter to the Only Fools and Horses theme tune!
Re: David Starie
Uncle Albert wouldn't have them anywhere near Munich on account of what happened during the warMy Name Is Earl wrote: ↑03 Jun 2020, 07:04Was that because The Trotters only traded in London, Paris and New York?![]()
-
My Name Is Earl
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 634
- Joined: 07 Nov 2008, 06:05
Re: David Starie
superspitzedookus wrote: ↑03 Jun 2020, 07:12Uncle Albert wouldn't have them anywhere near Munich on account of what happened during the warMy Name Is Earl wrote: ↑03 Jun 2020, 07:04
Was that because The Trotters only traded in London, Paris and New York?![]()
Re: David Starie
-
mickey1975
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 23091
- Joined: 02 Mar 2009, 12:54
Re: David Starie
He wasn’t too worried going over for the Viet rematch.My Name Is Earl wrote: ↑03 Jun 2020, 06:56I don't know if it was ever a possibility, but Calzaghe never entertained the idea of going over there. Their parallel careers
should have led to a fight but too much risk/reward on show for either? For Joe a judges verdict too dodgy..for
Sven a good chance he would have been sparked out.
Half of Oz celebrated as much as thee Germans when Mundine was starched.![]()
Re: David Starie
Perhaps, but having wiped him out in one round first time he probably didn't fear the judges having anything to do with it. Plus he was apparently paid far more than usual to get Viet home advantage.mickey1975 wrote: ↑04 Jun 2020, 12:39He wasn’t too worried going over for the Viet rematch.My Name Is Earl wrote: ↑03 Jun 2020, 06:56
I don't know if it was ever a possibility, but Calzaghe never entertained the idea of going over there. Their parallel careers
should have led to a fight but too much risk/reward on show for either? For Joe a judges verdict too dodgy..for
Sven a good chance he would have been sparked out.
Half of Oz celebrated as much as thee Germans when Mundine was starched.![]()
Re: David Starie
He was already something of an amateur celebrity before he turned over. I was in Germany during the 88 Olympics. He got a lot of coverage.
-
margaret thatcher
- Super Featherweight
- Posts: 39338
- Joined: 22 Jul 2019, 15:43
Re: David Starie
He did 3, never won a medal there but 2x Euro champ and won bronze at worlds
-
My Name Is Earl
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 634
- Joined: 07 Nov 2008, 06:05
Re: David Starie
Calzaghe's first fight overseas sez a lot imo. If nothing else, The Calzaghe's weren't mugs at matchmaking so Viet
was a different proposition to Ottke. I don't like having a go at fighter's records but Viet's was the epitome of a padded
ledger, and as dookus says they were rewarded well for going over there. Hells bells, he was probably only the 4th best
German SM at the time.
-
margaret thatcher
- Super Featherweight
- Posts: 39338
- Joined: 22 Jul 2019, 15:43
Re: David Starie
Veit wasnt as tricky as Ottke but prob still a bit underrated based on how feeble he looked vs Joe
Veit did beat Charles Brewer and took Jurg Braehmer's 0, also beat a few title challengers like Salam and Pedromo, and Mock. So had some recognizable wins at least. He wasn't totally sh!t compared to the lot of title challengers.
Veit did beat Charles Brewer and took Jurg Braehmer's 0, also beat a few title challengers like Salam and Pedromo, and Mock. So had some recognizable wins at least. He wasn't totally sh!t compared to the lot of title challengers.
-
My Name Is Earl
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 634
- Joined: 07 Nov 2008, 06:05
Re: David Starie
There's been plenty of Brits that have done the same mapped out rout so not a dig. Braehmer didmargaret thatcher wrote: ↑04 Jun 2020, 15:16 Veit wasnt as tricky as Ottke but prob still a bit underrated based on how feeble he looked vs Joe
Veit did beat Charles Brewer and took Jurg Braehmer's 0, also beat a few title challengers like Salam and Pedromo, and Mock. So had some recognizable wins at least. He wasn't totally sh!t compared to the lot of title challengers.
stop him later on. Brewer was getting on, I'd have him levels below Ottke and even under Inkin. He had his level
and Joe had no fear going over there.
-
My Name Is Earl
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 634
- Joined: 07 Nov 2008, 06:05
Re: David Starie
By the way, he still wasn't Cal's worst opponent 
-
mickey1975
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 23091
- Joined: 02 Mar 2009, 12:54
Re: David Starie
By the way, ‘have gloves, will travel’ Joe had stopped McIntyre in Denmark before this.
Re: David Starie
Joe often made them look like bums, they were all at least European championship quality, I remember the stick he got for fighting BikaShhhh wrote: ↑05 Jun 2020, 05:15Forgot these guys existed.... frank used to really line up bum after bum for Joe at one point.mickey1975 wrote: ↑05 Jun 2020, 04:29 By the way, ‘have gloves, will travel’ Joe had stopped McIntyre in Denmark before this.
-
TheLeprechaun
- Super Middleweight
- Posts: 5170
- Joined: 27 Jun 2013, 20:42
Re: David Starie
Calzaghe is overrated due to his padded record. Here is a guy who fought garbage and got put down by the likes of Salem and Mitchell. He was very fortunate to get Mitchell back with a lucky shot instead of being taken out himself. He lost the Hopkins fight if you care about counter punching. He beat Kessler, a guy who got outboxed by Carl Froch.