Im actually a big Jimmy fansmiling assassin wrote: ↑10 Jan 2018, 16:12Tomasino wrote: ↑10 Jan 2018, 12:43Think you’ve logged into the wrong forum matesmiling assassin wrote: ↑08 Dec 2017, 14:52 Most people disagree with me but I still think Jimmy Saville was a good man![]()
![]()
![]()
cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
-
smiling assassin
- Light Heavyweight
- Posts: 3196
- Joined: 05 Jan 2012, 13:12
-
margaret thatcher
- Featherweight
- Posts: 39201
- Joined: 22 Jul 2019, 15:43
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
i was looking up scores on eyeonthering, and i notice that our boi ruthy had chris jr beating groves

Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
Castillo won the 1st fight with Mayweather more clearly than Floyd won the rematch.
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
that fury vs Mcdermott 1 was a "robbery". The most overused expression in boxing imo (actually, maybe the term "bum"). i get it if people think big john won, but to me a "robbery" is a fight where the winner gets awarded at least 3 rounds he CLEARLY lost. it was only a 10 round fight, i gave fury the first two and the last two, and a few of the middle ones were open to debate depending on what you liked. So a "robbery" is just too extreme. I sometimes think in those types of situations, people are so surprised to see the unfancied fighter is having success, they then only see things one way. Also didn't think Fury got the credit he deserved for taking the fight so early on but thats by the by.
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
Good post. I had John winning but wasn't screaming murder when it went the other way. Realistically it doesn't matter anyway. Like you say, Fury took the fight early on, we already knew John's level and even if he'd been given the win it'd not have held Fury back.Steveh583 wrote: ↑18 Jan 2021, 16:05 that fury vs Mcdermott 1 was a "robbery". The most overused expression in boxing imo (actually, maybe the term "bum"). i get it if people think big john won, but to me a "robbery" is a fight where the winner gets awarded at least 3 rounds he CLEARLY lost. it was only a 10 round fight, i gave fury the first two and the last two, and a few of the middle ones were open to debate depending on what you liked. So a "robbery" is just too extreme. I sometimes think in those types of situations, people are so surprised to see the unfancied fighter is having success, they then only see things one way. Also didn't think Fury got the credit he deserved for taking the fight so early on but thats by the by.
-
margaret thatcher
- Featherweight
- Posts: 39201
- Joined: 22 Jul 2019, 15:43
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
i think it was the ridiculous 8-2 card that set it off most, more than fury being the fancied guy. just made it looked like it was prearranged crookedness. who the hell else scored it that way? if fury had gotten say 96-95 it wouldve been more accepted
i think john just nicked it but fair play tyson fought him right again and stopped him
tyson's had 3 rematches of fights that went the distance and he won by stoppage in all of them, he is a smart fighter who knows how to adapt
i think john just nicked it but fair play tyson fought him right again and stopped him
tyson's had 3 rematches of fights that went the distance and he won by stoppage in all of them, he is a smart fighter who knows how to adapt
Last edited by margaret thatcher on 18 Jan 2021, 16:42, edited 1 time in total.
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
Terry almost always does the right thing for the business that is boxing. At least he doesn't try and kid people on it's a sport.margaret thatcher wrote: ↑18 Jan 2021, 16:37 i think it was the ridiculous 8-2 card that set it off most, more than fury being the fancied guy. just made it looked like it was prearranged crookedness. who the hell else scored it that way? if fury had gotten say 96-95 it wouldve been more accepted
i think john just nicked it but fair play tyson fought him right again and stopped him
tyson's had 3 rematches of fights that went the distance and he won by stoppage in all of them
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
I disagree with my wife all the time on a certain topic that being people ,
She seems to think that people are predominatly nice , with a few assholes threw in ,
I disagree , I think people are predominatly twats , self serving selfish stab you in the back twats ,, with a few nice people threw in
She seems to think that people are predominatly nice , with a few assholes threw in ,
I disagree , I think people are predominatly twats , self serving selfish stab you in the back twats ,, with a few nice people threw in
-
danconnollyeire
- Light Heavyweight
- Posts: 3576
- Joined: 24 May 2012, 10:31
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
I stopped at Holyfield beat Lewis.TheGman wrote: ↑09 Jan 2018, 17:01 Robin reid beat calzaghe
Bhop beat calzaghe
Holyfield beat lewis in the rematch
Never rated fury as a fighter,great talker but just cant take to him
ODLH beat floyd
ODLH beat trinidad
ODLH beat mosley in the rematch
Sturm beat ODLH
Bhop vs ODLH was a fix
Collazo beat hatton
Chocolatito got robbed in his first defeat
Canelo got beat by lara
Mike tyson was top in probably the worst era of heavyweight boxing
I thought cotto vs mayweather was a lot closer than the judges had it,like a round or two close
GGG got beat by jacobs
I had maidana beating floyd in the first fight.
-
margaret thatcher
- Featherweight
- Posts: 39201
- Joined: 22 Jul 2019, 15:43
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
i'd say most people agree that oscar beat shane in the rematch and that sturm beat oscar
-
Ruthless-RKO
- Welterweight
- Posts: 100690
- Joined: 24 Apr 2016, 11:59
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
I've seen many comments with people saying Lewis beat Holyfield in the first bout, but Holyfield deserved the rematch.danconnollyeire wrote: ↑19 Jan 2021, 04:20I stopped at Holyfield beat Lewis.TheGman wrote: ↑09 Jan 2018, 17:01 Robin reid beat calzaghe
Bhop beat calzaghe
Holyfield beat lewis in the rematch
Never rated fury as a fighter,great talker but just cant take to him
ODLH beat floyd
ODLH beat trinidad
ODLH beat mosley in the rematch
Sturm beat ODLH
Bhop vs ODLH was a fix
Collazo beat hatton
Chocolatito got robbed in his first defeat
Canelo got beat by lara
Mike tyson was top in probably the worst era of heavyweight boxing
I thought cotto vs mayweather was a lot closer than the judges had it,like a round or two close
GGG got beat by jacobs
I had maidana beating floyd in the first fight.![]()
what on earth you smoking and where can I buy some?
-
Tuan_Jim
- Heavyweight

Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
Lots of journalists ringside scored it for Holyfield.danconnollyeire wrote: ↑19 Jan 2021, 04:20I stopped at Holyfield beat Lewis.TheGman wrote: ↑09 Jan 2018, 17:01 Robin reid beat calzaghe
Bhop beat calzaghe
Holyfield beat lewis in the rematch
Never rated fury as a fighter,great talker but just cant take to him
ODLH beat floyd
ODLH beat trinidad
ODLH beat mosley in the rematch
Sturm beat ODLH
Bhop vs ODLH was a fix
Collazo beat hatton
Chocolatito got robbed in his first defeat
Canelo got beat by lara
Mike tyson was top in probably the worst era of heavyweight boxing
I thought cotto vs mayweather was a lot closer than the judges had it,like a round or two close
GGG got beat by jacobs
I had maidana beating floyd in the first fight.![]()
what on earth you smoking and where can I buy some?
-
Boxerbeetle
- Light Heavyweight
- Posts: 32660
- Joined: 19 Sep 2011, 10:59
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
I haven’t watched it back since and don’t believe I scored it round by round on the night, but I do distinctly remember being very worried that Lennox had let the rematch slip away from him on the cards.
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
Groves was in many ways doing better in the Froch rematch than he was in the first fight. For me, he was 1 round down but was fighting at a much more controlled pace and was coming on stronger. Fight 1, he had a big lead (possibly unassailable on the cards) but was tiring and it would have been interesting had the fight continued.
Fury vs Klitchsko was razor tight.
Only fighter to run Mayweather close of Oscar De La Hoya.
Oscar is probably the fighter with the most "wrong" decision - some going for him, some going against him.
Robin Reid was NOT robbed against Ottke by the JUDGES going on the ref's call. Ottke was more underated than people give him credit and a fight with Joe would have been interesting. Yes, I would have favoured Joe but I think Ottke would have had some moments. He was clearly a lot tricker then people give him credit for - I think most people see Joe's work rate, size and power being too much for Ottke - but why didn't the likes of Mitchell, Brewer, Lardsen etc - good fighters just adopt those "be first" tactics.
Fury vs Klitchsko was razor tight.
Only fighter to run Mayweather close of Oscar De La Hoya.
Oscar is probably the fighter with the most "wrong" decision - some going for him, some going against him.
Robin Reid was NOT robbed against Ottke by the JUDGES going on the ref's call. Ottke was more underated than people give him credit and a fight with Joe would have been interesting. Yes, I would have favoured Joe but I think Ottke would have had some moments. He was clearly a lot tricker then people give him credit for - I think most people see Joe's work rate, size and power being too much for Ottke - but why didn't the likes of Mitchell, Brewer, Lardsen etc - good fighters just adopt those "be first" tactics.
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
Lewis won the first but,imo,holyfield won the rematch but with all the controversy of the first lewis was never gonna lose that fight.Ruthless-RKO wrote: ↑19 Jan 2021, 08:22I've seen many comments with people saying Lewis beat Holyfield in the first bout, but Holyfield deserved the rematch.danconnollyeire wrote: ↑19 Jan 2021, 04:20I stopped at Holyfield beat Lewis.TheGman wrote: ↑09 Jan 2018, 17:01 Robin reid beat calzaghe
Bhop beat calzaghe
Holyfield beat lewis in the rematch
Never rated fury as a fighter,great talker but just cant take to him
ODLH beat floyd
ODLH beat trinidad
ODLH beat mosley in the rematch
Sturm beat ODLH
Bhop vs ODLH was a fix
Collazo beat hatton
Chocolatito got robbed in his first defeat
Canelo got beat by lara
Mike tyson was top in probably the worst era of heavyweight boxing
I thought cotto vs mayweather was a lot closer than the judges had it,like a round or two close
GGG got beat by jacobs
I had maidana beating floyd in the first fight.![]()
what on earth you smoking and where can I buy some?
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
Its my opinion,just cause yours is different doesnt make me wrong loldanconnollyeire wrote: ↑19 Jan 2021, 04:20I stopped at Holyfield beat Lewis.TheGman wrote: ↑09 Jan 2018, 17:01 Robin reid beat calzaghe
Bhop beat calzaghe
Holyfield beat lewis in the rematch
Never rated fury as a fighter,great talker but just cant take to him
ODLH beat floyd
ODLH beat trinidad
ODLH beat mosley in the rematch
Sturm beat ODLH
Bhop vs ODLH was a fix
Collazo beat hatton
Chocolatito got robbed in his first defeat
Canelo got beat by lara
Mike tyson was top in probably the worst era of heavyweight boxing
I thought cotto vs mayweather was a lot closer than the judges had it,like a round or two close
GGG got beat by jacobs
I had maidana beating floyd in the first fight.![]()
what on earth you smoking and where can I buy some?
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
He was backed up and rocked on numerous occasionsBoxerbeetle wrote: ↑19 Jan 2021, 09:11 I haven’t watched it back since and don’t believe I scored it round by round on the night, but I do distinctly remember being very worried that Lennox had let the rematch slip away from him on the cards.
-
Djanders44
- Welterweight
- Posts: 190
- Joined: 02 Jan 2016, 00:43
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
I disagree with most, who think Muhammad Ali and Joe Louis are the #1 and #2 greatest Heavyweights of all time. I've only jumped ship recently, after many decades of thought on the subject.
-
Wee Tommy
- Heavyweight

Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
Recently I’ve seen a lot of my old posts and they embarrass mesmiling assassin wrote: ↑10 Jan 2018, 16:42![]()
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
Well, this is my cases:
Ward vs Kovalev 1 was not a robbery, but ward should be DQ in rematch
Chris Eubank jr won against Saunders, he is very underrated
I am big fan of Canelo Alvarez since maybe 2010 (most of boxrec users hate him
)
Losing last rounds have huge impact on the decision, that is reason i had Mosley winning both fights against De la Hoya
Wilder won first fight against Fury (not saying BS like it was a KO, but ive had him winning close decision)
Manny Pacqiao is top 3 ATG
Only robbery in Canelo record is first GGG fight, he won against Trout, Lara, and GGG rematch
Ward vs Kovalev 1 was not a robbery, but ward should be DQ in rematch
Chris Eubank jr won against Saunders, he is very underrated
I am big fan of Canelo Alvarez since maybe 2010 (most of boxrec users hate him
Losing last rounds have huge impact on the decision, that is reason i had Mosley winning both fights against De la Hoya
Wilder won first fight against Fury (not saying BS like it was a KO, but ive had him winning close decision)
Manny Pacqiao is top 3 ATG
Only robbery in Canelo record is first GGG fight, he won against Trout, Lara, and GGG rematch
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
Who is your top 2 all time best heavy?Djanders44 wrote: ↑19 Jan 2021, 13:40 I disagree with most, who think Muhammad Ali and Joe Louis are the #1 and #2 greatest Heavyweights of all time. I've only jumped ship recently, after many decades of thought on the subject.
-
mickey1975
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 22935
- Joined: 02 Mar 2009, 12:54
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
I have Holmes #1.TheGman wrote: ↑19 Jan 2021, 16:42Who is your top 2 all time best heavy?Djanders44 wrote: ↑19 Jan 2021, 13:40 I disagree with most, who think Muhammad Ali and Joe Louis are the #1 and #2 greatest Heavyweights of all time. I've only jumped ship recently, after many decades of thought on the subject.
-
mickey1975
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 22935
- Joined: 02 Mar 2009, 12:54
Re: cases where u/you disagree with most ppl
Bjs beat Jr comfortably. I honestly don’t know what you watched. 7-5 at the very least.Cent0089 wrote: ↑19 Jan 2021, 15:15 Well, this is my cases:
Ward vs Kovalev 1 was not a robbery, but ward should be DQ in rematch
Chris Eubank jr won against Saunders, he is very underrated
I am big fan of Canelo Alvarez since maybe 2010 (most of boxrec users hate him)
Losing last rounds have huge impact on the decision, that is reason i had Mosley winning both fights against De la Hoya
Wilder won first fight against Fury (not saying BS like it was a KO, but ive had him winning close decision)
Manny Pacqiao is top 3 ATG
Only robbery in Canelo record is first GGG fight, he won against Trout, Lara, and GGG rematch