Moore vs Macklin who wins?

stujones · Post by **stujones** » 25 Sep 2006, 08:56

Really looking forward to the domestic clash that is coming up, both are favourite fighters of mine and I hope the loser can come back from this.

I am going for Macklin though, I think he has learned from the Facey fight - he definately gives me the impression of being bigger at the weight and I just think has that little more natural talent than Moore.

I think Macklin will stop him mid/late rounds.

It should be a cracker though.

THEBUTCH · Post by **THEBUTCH** » 25 Sep 2006, 09:42

I give Moore the edge in this because of his extra experience in the blood and thunder fights. He's proved he fight back from the brink of defeat and he might have to again in this one.

Macklin's in with a good shout. He digs with real purpose and Moore can be hurt, that's no secret. I'm not expecting Macklin to fold easily, but think Jamie can retain again.

Either way, it's more a case of sitting back and watch the sparks fly. Great match

stujones · Post by **stujones** » 25 Sep 2006, 09:47

THEBUTCH wrote:I give Moore the edge in this because of his extra experience in the blood and thunder fights. He's prove he fight back from the brink of defeat and he might have to again in this one.

Macklin's in with a good shout. He digs with real purpose and Moore can be hurt, that's no secret. I'm not expecting Macklin to fold easily, but think Jamie can retain again.

Either way, it's more a case of sitting back and watch the sparks fly. Great match

Your first paragraph is why I am going for Macklin..... its who he got from the brink of defeat to is the problem. No disrespect to Michael Jones but apart from height and experience, I don't know one thing Michael does better than Macklin.

I think Macklin has speed, power and skills that are better than Jones. So if Jones can hit and hurt Moore - then Macklin can have him out of there.

Old bones Ian · Post by **Old bones Ian** » 25 Sep 2006, 09:49

This is a really hard fight to pick the winner, Moore has the greater experience and has a good punch , but he can be hurt as well.
This is Macklins first real big fight, he's very powerful in the early going and thats when Moore may walk into one, Macklin has so far shown a good chin , but has yet to be really tested over the longer distance, Moore has done 12 rounds and look good against Michael Jones.

So, i can see Macklin getting the job done early, or Moore winning on points, or a late stoppage for either boxer.

Sticking my neck on the line, i'm going for Moore to overcome some dodgy moments before stopping Macklin in the 10th.

DIRT SUGAR · Post by **DIRT SUGAR** » 25 Sep 2006, 10:06

Macklin digs well underneath and if he can get to Moore's body it will could be very interesting as I think Moore is a bit prone to getting hurt downstairs.

nickd · Post by **nickd** » 25 Sep 2006, 10:07

DIRT SUGAR wrote:Macklin digs well underneath and if he can get to Moore's body it will could be very interesting as I think Moore is a bit prone to getting hurt downstairs.

I agree, and Macklin is a good bodypuncher. I fancy a Macklin stoppage in the middle rounds.

Old bones Ian · Post by **Old bones Ian** » 25 Sep 2006, 11:13

DIRT SUGAR wrote:Macklin digs well underneath and if he can get to Moore's body it will could be very interesting as I think Moore is a bit prone to getting hurt downstairs.

Moore has a good body punch as well, and Macklin hasn't really been tested around that area as a pro, this fight is really about Macklin, we all kind of know Moore's stregths and weaknesses, but there are alot of unkowns about Macklin.

stujones · Post by **stujones** » 25 Sep 2006, 16:02

Terence wrote:Alright lads, here is Moore's prediction in no uncertain terms:

http://www.britishboxing.net/news_1705- ... eight.html

I got some interesting question ideas from a few strands a while back and Stu is to thank for the conversation about the knock-downs in the Jones fight, I still think solid chins mean not going down at all but what do I know

Macklin's prediction to follow in a few days and I'll see who else I can get in there for the final preview.

I cannot remember saying anything, I've made some horrendous posts in my time - hope it wasn't one of these. Or was it what I said in this thread?

leforge · Post by **leforge** » 25 Sep 2006, 16:21

Should be a cracking fight. Too close to call, Moore on points Macklin can come again at Middleweight.

E · Post by E » 25 Sep 2006, 16:32

I think Moore is just a bit too fragile and Macklin looks big and strong.

Looking forward to this one...

liamlion · Post by **liamlion** » 25 Sep 2006, 16:49

I cant wait for this fight! This is what boxing is about - a proper 50-50, all to play for, with both fighters bringing a good set of loyal fans. The atmosphere is gonna be electric.

I hope Macklin wins, but if Moore prevails (which I suspect he might) I wont have a problem with that. Both are good, honest young lads - fair credit to the pair of them for making it happen.

stujones · Post by **stujones** » 25 Sep 2006, 21:03

Terence wrote:
stujones wrote:
Terence wrote:Alright lads, here is Moore's prediction in no uncertain terms:

http://www.britishboxing.net/news_1705- ... eight.html

I got some interesting question ideas from a few strands a while back and Stu is to thank for the conversation about the knock-downs in the Jones fight, I still think solid chins mean not going down at all but what do I know

Macklin's prediction to follow in a few days and I'll see who else I can get in there for the final preview.
I cannot remember saying anything, I've made some horrendous posts in my time - hope it wasn't one of these. Or was it what I said in this thread?
Nah mate, it was a good honest back and forth about knock-downs (although it was probably on a wholly unrelated thread), I was saying that going down equals a bad chin and you said that going down but getting up shows a good chin. Funnily enough Jamie concurred with you a few days later when talking about Jones III!

Both men have talked about Duddy also so it will be good to see him in action the next night against Campas

Did I? Alot will depend on the were the punch was landed, and who was the opponent I guess. I don't think I would have ever said Audley Harrison's got a GOOD chin cause he got up vs Williams to last the course.

Tito Trinidad though has a good chin IMO, this was shown in beatings vs Hopkins and Wright (both decent, if not destructive punchers). Juan Manuel Marquez has a good chin also, despite hitting the canvas 3 times in one round vs Pacquiao.

I do think Macklin has the punch to keep Moore down, but I think it will be a wear and tear job mainly though and later than when Jones nearly won.

TerribleTerry · Post by **TerribleTerry** » 26 Sep 2006, 12:10

Macklin to get the job done and bring the title to Brum.

One area Matty is lacking a bit is hand speed IMO - his footwork has improved tremendously and he, thankfully, wont have to go looking for Moore.

His body attack is withering and his fitness is excellent. Moore is gonna have to put a herculean effort in to turn back Macklin - I cant see him producing it to be honest.

Come on the Brummie!

Post by **The Law** » 26 Sep 2006, 13:53

Macklin will win via KO after pummelling Moore to the body!

Bring it home to brum!

lurkyshaka · Post by **lurkyshaka** » 27 Sep 2006, 06:31

Macklin 'arrives' with a breakthrough win here imo.
It'll be a great fight to watch im sure as i think both will clash head on, but i think the greater speed and ability of macklin will give him the edge and allow him to overcome Moore's greater experience.

Macklin TKO between 4-7

sweetscience · Post by **sweetscience** » 27 Sep 2006, 08:28

mmooooooooorrrrrssssssseeeeeeeeyyyyy by KO 8th ROund

punchers chance · Post by **punchers chance** » 27 Sep 2006, 09:52

Macklin has the edge for me

Old bones Ian · Post by **Old bones Ian** » 27 Sep 2006, 12:03

We've yet to see what happens when Macklin in on the recieving end, if he doesn't get Moore out early, then we can see what Macklin is made of, he's got quick hands but will also have to think about defense.
Moore is still just the pick for me, but i wouldn't put money on it.

leforge · Post by **leforge** » 28 Sep 2006, 16:45

Cant wait for this fight.

TheGoods · Post by **TheGoods** » 28 Sep 2006, 17:17

What was the script at the weigh-in? Both OK?

Old bones Ian · Post by **Old bones Ian** » 29 Sep 2006, 18:00

topper123 wrote:This is a really hard fight to pick the winner, Moore has the greater experience and has a good punch , but he can be hurt as well.
This is Macklins first real big fight, he's very powerful in the early going and thats when Moore may walk into one, Macklin has so far shown a good chin , but has yet to be really tested over the longer distance, Moore has done 12 rounds and look good against Michael Jones.

So, i can see Macklin getting the job done early, or Moore winning on points, or a late stoppage for either boxer.

Sticking my neck on the line, i'm going for Moore to overcome some dodgy moments before stopping Macklin in the 10th.

smug mode

E · Post by E » 29 Sep 2006, 18:02

topper123 wrote:
topper123 wrote:This is a really hard fight to pick the winner, Moore has the greater experience and has a good punch , but he can be hurt as well.
This is Macklins first real big fight, he's very powerful in the early going and thats when Moore may walk into one, Macklin has so far shown a good chin , but has yet to be really tested over the longer distance, Moore has done 12 rounds and look good against Michael Jones.

So, i can see Macklin getting the job done early, or Moore winning on points, or a late stoppage for either boxer.

Sticking my neck on the line, i'm going for Moore to overcome some dodgy moments before stopping Macklin in the 10th.
smug mode

Hey ypu twat Macklin is still on the stretcher - have some fvcking respect!

Old bones Ian · Post by **Old bones Ian** » 29 Sep 2006, 18:04

E wrote:
topper123 wrote:
topper123 wrote:This is a really hard fight to pick the winner, Moore has the greater experience and has a good punch , but he can be hurt as well.
This is Macklins first real big fight, he's very powerful in the early going and thats when Moore may walk into one, Macklin has so far shown a good chin , but has yet to be really tested over the longer distance, Moore has done 12 rounds and look good against Michael Jones.

So, i can see Macklin getting the job done early, or Moore winning on points, or a late stoppage for either boxer.

Sticking my neck on the line, i'm going for Moore to overcome some dodgy moments before stopping Macklin in the 10th.
smug mode
Hey ypu twat Macklin is still on the stretcher - have some fvcking respect!

Bollocks , i'm not a fornicating mind reader, didn't watch the fight,

E · Post by E » 29 Sep 2006, 18:09

topper123 wrote:
E wrote:
topper123 wrote: smug mode
Hey ypu twat Macklin is still on the stretcher - have some fvcking respect!
Bollocks , i'm not a smeg mind reader, didn't watch the fight,

Fair enough mate I didn;t realise.

Macklin fought his heart out and through such fatigue it was incredible.

He went over on his face and was given medical attention and taken out on a stretcher. He managed to raise his hand and I think speak on the way out.

Hopefully it's just fatigue.......

Old bones Ian · Post by **Old bones Ian** » 29 Sep 2006, 18:11

yeah sorry if my comments were out of place, sounds as if i missed a good fight, hope Macklin recovers ok

Moore vs Macklin who wins?

Who will win the big domestic Light Middleweight clash?

Moore vs Macklin who wins?