Frostieballs wrote: ↑26 Sep 2025, 19:02
A lot of his legacy depends on how highly you rate Wilder.
I don’t rate Wilder very highly at all.
Wilder isn't that great, but he's better than some give him credit for at the same time. He'd probably legitimately be a Top 30 or Top 40 all time Heavyweight which is nothing to scoff at in a sport that has existed as long as Boxing has.
I can’t see that mate. No way a top 30/40 heavyweight of all time. I could name that many just from the 80’s/90’s.
A few years ago, before his decline, I said he was European level at best and compared his level to Gary Mason’s.
I took quite a lot of stick at the time, but stand by it!
Taansend wrote: ↑26 Sep 2025, 23:44
I give Wilder more respect for his three losses to Fury than I do for any of his wins.
As for Fury, very talented fighter, big heart, and I'm glad I got to follow his whole career.
Not happy that he never met AJ & that's a tiny stain on his career but I ain't losing any sleep over it.
He didn't lose the first fight with Fury. It was a draw.
And if Fury and AJ never fight. It's not a tiny stain on their career. It's a tremendous stain, that drops them both several notches on the all time list. The loser of a fight between them would be better off for having fought and lost that fight than either would be if they never fought it at all.
It would be the equivalent of if Ali and Frazier had ducked each other their entire careers. It would disgrace them and their country.
Even I admit that's true. Same goes for Lewis and Bowe.
I don’t think the Bowe/Lewis miss is as bad as not having Fury/AJ. Perhaps that’s because I’m a big Lewis fan and simply think he’d have stopped Bowe relatively comfortably. I was never super high on Bowe and he was relatively easy to hit.
Frostieballs wrote: ↑26 Sep 2025, 19:02
A lot of his legacy depends on how highly you rate Wilder.
I don’t rate Wilder very highly at all.
Wilder isn't that great, but he's better than some give him credit for at the same time. He'd probably legitimately be a Top 30 or Top 40 all time Heavyweight which is nothing to scoff at in a sport that has existed as long as Boxing has.
I can’t see that mate. No way a top 30/40 heavyweight of all time. I could name that many just from the 80’s/90’s.
A few years ago, before his decline, I said he was European level at best and compared his level to Gary Mason’s.
I took quite a lot of stick at the time, but stand by it!
Who could you name from the 80's that's better than Wilder besides Tyson and Holmes?
Frostieballs wrote: ↑26 Sep 2025, 19:02
A lot of his legacy depends on how highly you rate Wilder.
I don’t rate Wilder very highly at all.
Wilder isn't that great, but he's better than some give him credit for at the same time. He'd probably legitimately be a Top 30 or Top 40 all time Heavyweight which is nothing to scoff at in a sport that has existed as long as Boxing has.
Is this a joke?
It's very easy to list 40 heavyweights who would beat Deontay Wilder. I could probably name a 100.
Frostieballs wrote: ↑26 Sep 2025, 19:02
A lot of his legacy depends on how highly you rate Wilder.
I don’t rate Wilder very highly at all.
Wilder isn't that great, but he's better than some give him credit for at the same time. He'd probably legitimately be a Top 30 or Top 40 all time Heavyweight which is nothing to scoff at in a sport that has existed as long as Boxing has.
Is this a joke?
It's very easy to list 40 heavyweights who would beat Deontay Wilder. I could probably name a 100.
Could you?
I'm pretty sure what you'd come up with is a list of about 45 guys that Wilder would definitely beat, 30 guys that he might beat, and 25 guys that he couldn't beat.
gregregegg wrote: ↑26 Sep 2025, 17:57
Both Fury and AJs best results are being gifted a split decision loss vs Usyk…
great point in fairness
Ok, let's take the Fury in the first Usyk fight. Highly competitive, top level fight. How would Usyk do against the 80's Brits who achieved nothing at world level despite the entire top 20 being addicted to crack for most of the decade.
He didn't lose the first fight with Fury. It was a draw.
And if Fury and AJ never fight. It's not a tiny stain on their career. It's a tremendous stain, that drops them both several notches on the all time list. The loser of a fight between them would be better off for having fought and lost that fight than either would be if they never fought it at all.
It would be the equivalent of if Ali and Frazier had ducked each other their entire careers. It would disgrace them and their country.
Even I admit that's true. Same goes for Lewis and Bowe.
I don’t think the Bowe/Lewis miss is as bad as not having Fury/AJ. Perhaps that’s because I’m a big Lewis fan and simply think he’d have stopped Bowe relatively comfortably. I was never super high on Bowe and he was relatively easy to hit.
I'm a big Bowe fan on his night, which admittedly there weren't enough of. As you know, I don't forgive Lennox getting sparked twice as easily as most, either.
mickey1975 wrote: ↑27 Sep 2025, 02:03
Even I admit that's true. Same goes for Lewis and Bowe.
I don’t think the Bowe/Lewis miss is as bad as not having Fury/AJ. Perhaps that’s because I’m a big Lewis fan and simply think he’d have stopped Bowe relatively comfortably. I was never super high on Bowe and he was relatively easy to hit.
I'm a big Bowe fan on his night, which admittedly there weren't enough of. As you know, I don't forgive Lennox getting sparked twice as easily as most, either.
Yeah. I really like the fact that Lewis avenged his losses though when means I forgive his KO losses a bit more.
For me though if you take away the Holyfield trilogy off Bose’s record there isn’t a great deal left. He took bad beatings in both the Golota fights too.
I don’t think the Bowe/Lewis miss is as bad as not having Fury/AJ. Perhaps that’s because I’m a big Lewis fan and simply think he’d have stopped Bowe relatively comfortably. I was never super high on Bowe and he was relatively easy to hit.
I'm a big Bowe fan on his night, which admittedly there weren't enough of. As you know, I don't forgive Lennox getting sparked twice as easily as most, either.
Yeah. I really like the fact that Lewis avenged his losses though when means I forgive his KO losses a bit more.
For me though if you take away the Holyfield trilogy off Bose’s record there isn’t a great deal left. He took bad beatings in both the Golota fights too.
Got to give Tyson a bit of credit then for clearing up the McDermott controversy, putting the Wilder draw right and then getting straight back in with Usyk 7 months later. Slightly above 80's British heavyweight form!
mickey1975 wrote: ↑27 Sep 2025, 04:33
I'm a big Bowe fan on his night, which admittedly there weren't enough of. As you know, I don't forgive Lennox getting sparked twice as easily as most, either.
Yeah. I really like the fact that Lewis avenged his losses though when means I forgive his KO losses a bit more.
For me though if you take away the Holyfield trilogy off Bose’s record there isn’t a great deal left. He took bad beatings in both the Golota fights too.
Got to give Tyson a bit of credit then for clearing up the McDermott controversy, putting the Wilder draw right and then getting straight back in with Usyk 7 months later. Slightly above 80's British heavyweight form!
100%.
Particularly the early career McDermott fight. The wilder 2 fight was one of the best, surprising performances I’ve seen live on TV. Wilder hasn’t been the same since.
I don’t really get why/how people are thinking Fury is in similar class to Mason or other 80s British heavyweights. He’d have boxed their heads up similar to what he did to Chisora. I think he’d have beat Bruno comfortably too.
Beat Wlad, stopped a limited Wilder twice, hammered Chisora twice and pushed Usyk to close fights (which I thought Usyk narrowly won still), stopped Whyte is in a different league to guys like Mason.
Wilder isn't that great, but he's better than some give him credit for at the same time. He'd probably legitimately be a Top 30 or Top 40 all time Heavyweight which is nothing to scoff at in a sport that has existed as long as Boxing has.
Is this a joke?
It's very easy to list 40 heavyweights who would beat Deontay Wilder. I could probably name a 100.
Could you?
I'm pretty sure what you'd come up with is a list of about 45 guys that Wilder would definitely beat, 30 guys that he might beat, and 25 guys that he couldn't beat.
I know you only got into boxing in the 2000s but even you should know it's easy to list a 100 heavyweights superior to Bermaine Stiverne and Luis Ortiz.
Wilder can't box, has no jab, no hook, can't punch in combination, is ungainly and chinny. That's why his team protected him. He isn't beating anyone decent.
At his best, does he beat any of these at their best, which is the fairest way to gauge it (~ excluding Holmes, Holyfied and Tyson):
Tim Witherspoon, Greg Page, Pinklon Thomas, Carl Williams, Mike Weaver, Michael Spinks, James Smith, Tony Tucker, Buster Douglas, Gerry Cooney, Trevor Berbick. You could even throw in there a James Broad and Michael Dokes.
I can't see him beating any one of them, personally and I have watched them and I have watched him.
NazNaci1 wrote: ↑27 Sep 2025, 09:07
Re: Wilder - Have to agree.
At his best, does he beat any of these at their best, which is the fairest way to gauge it (~ excluding Holmes, Holyfied and Tyson):
Tim Witherspoon, Greg Page, Pinklon Thomas, Carl Williams, Mike Weaver, Michael Spinks, James Smith, Tony Tucker, Buster Douglas, Gerry Cooney, Trevor Berbick. You could even throw in there a James Broad and Michael Dokes.
I can't see him beating any one of them, personally and I have watched them and I have watched him.
At his best, yes, I'd pick him against a lot of them. The thing is, we will never know...
NazNaci1 wrote: ↑27 Sep 2025, 09:07
Re: Wilder - Have to agree.
At his best, does he beat any of these at their best, which is the fairest way to gauge it (~ excluding Holmes, Holyfied and Tyson):
Tim Witherspoon, Greg Page, Pinklon Thomas, Carl Williams, Mike Weaver, Michael Spinks, James Smith, Tony Tucker, Buster Douglas, Gerry Cooney, Trevor Berbick. You could even throw in there a James Broad and Michael Dokes.
I can't see him beating any one of them, personally and I have watched them and I have watched him.
At his best, yes, I'd pick him against a lot of them. The thing is, we will never know...
NazNaci1 wrote: ↑27 Sep 2025, 09:07
Re: Wilder - Have to agree.
At his best, does he beat any of these at their best, which is the fairest way to gauge it (~ excluding Holmes, Holyfied and Tyson):
Tim Witherspoon, Greg Page, Pinklon Thomas, Carl Williams, Mike Weaver, Michael Spinks, James Smith, Tony Tucker, Buster Douglas, Gerry Cooney, Trevor Berbick. You could even throw in there a James Broad and Michael Dokes.
I can't see him beating any one of them, personally and I have watched them and I have watched him.
At his best, yes, I'd pick him against a lot of them. The thing is, we will never know...
When was he at his best ?
Wlad or Wilder 2 in my opinion. I think his head was switched on 100% for both those fights. I think it was for Usyk 1 as well but his out of the ring living caught up with him in the second half of the fight.
NazNaci1 wrote: ↑27 Sep 2025, 09:07
Re: Wilder - Have to agree.
At his best, does he beat any of these at their best, which is the fairest way to gauge it (~ excluding Holmes, Holyfied and Tyson):
Tim Witherspoon, Greg Page, Pinklon Thomas, Carl Williams, Mike Weaver, Michael Spinks, James Smith, Tony Tucker, Buster Douglas, Gerry Cooney, Trevor Berbick. You could even throw in there a James Broad and Michael Dokes.
I can't see him beating any one of them, personally and I have watched them and I have watched him.
At his best, yes, I'd pick him against a lot of them. The thing is, we will never know...
PS I was referencing Wilder, not Fury btw
Fury, yeah I can definitely see him taking the W against a few of those, no argument.
mickey1975 wrote: ↑27 Sep 2025, 09:27
At his best, yes, I'd pick him against a lot of them. The thing is, we will never know...
When was he at his best ?
Wlad or Wilder 2 in my opinion. I think his head was switched on 100% for both those fights. I think it was for Usyk 1 as well but his out of the ring living caught up with him in the second half of the fight.
Wlad or Wilder 2 in my opinion. I think his head was switched on 100% for both those fights. I think it was for Usyk 1 as well but his out of the ring living caught up with him in the second half of the fight.
mickey1975 wrote: ↑27 Sep 2025, 10:16
Wlad or Wilder 2 in my opinion. I think his head was switched on 100% for both those fights. I think it was for Usyk 1 as well but his out of the ring living caught up with him in the second half of the fight.
