Is Canelo Still in YOUR Top Ten P4P?

[Taansend]

In Boxrecs The Peoples P4P Canelo is still ranked 7th.

I know everyone does their P4P their own way & I respect that. My own way is "what have you done in the last 30 months" PLUS I'll add in overall career after that.

But each to their own.

I now have Canelo around 11th. At best.

And while we're at it, where does Vergil rank? He beat Madrimov clearer than Bud did. Plus he just wiped out a respected, but maybe flawed, fighter at 154. I now have him 10th.

[Evander]

Got Bam Rodriguez P4P Top 4
I'm picky
What you got ?

[Evander]

Usyk 1

[joshj909]

He's definitely not top 5 but he's probably somewhere just inside or just outside of the top 10. He has recent wins over Scull (23-0), Berlanga (23-2), Munguía (45-2), Charlo (35-2-1) and Ryder (32-7) which might not be the level of Crawford, Bivol, Inoue, Usyk and some others but it's a lot better than what many other top guys have been up to recently. His losses are to consensus p4p top 5 as well so not much harm done by that. This is from someone who thinks he lost the first two fights to Golovkin, is a drug cheat, ducked Benavidez and is generally overrated.

[stujones]

Great question.

I would say just outside, but it would be close.

I would have to have the following (I feel now above him).
Crawford, Usyk, Inoue, Bivol, Bam, Benevidez, Beterbiev, Stevenson - have to now be above him. Then we have others like Ennis, Haney, and some other lower weight guys who I need to see more of who I think Alvarez is competing with.

[Bobbyptsd]

Inoue
Usyk
Crawford
Rodriguez
Benavidez
Bivol
Beterbiev
Alvarez
Nakatani
Espinoza

This would be my top ten right now.

[2245724]

In Boxrecs The Peoples P4P Canelo is still ranked 7th.

I know everyone does their P4P their own way & I respect that. My own way is "what have you done in the last 30 months" PLUS I'll add in overall career after that.

But each to their own.
wordle unlimited
I now have Canelo around 11th. At best.

And while we're at it, where does Vergil rank? He beat Madrimov clearer than Bud did. Plus he just wiped out a respected, but maybe flawed, fighter at 154. I now have him 10th.

Based on recent form and activity I’d also slide Canelo just outside the top ten, while Vergil’s momentum and quality wins make a strong case for him cracking the lower end of the list.

[MPW]

In short, no. He had a so-so performance against Crawford in what was supposed to be the biggest fight of the year, a seemingly uninterested effort against Scull, and go-through-the-motions wins over Berlanga and Munguia. To me, that doesn't keep you on the list of the world's top ten P4P boxers.